Militaries can stop a problem; they can’t fix a problem. We stopped Saddam Hussein but left Iraq with Iran-backed militias, creating a global ISIS. We killed Osama Bin Laden, but departed Afghanistan still under Taliban control with al Qaeda extant. Hitler was stopped, but it took the Marshall Plan to fix Germany.
Israel’s Defense Forces’ spokesman admitted the same regarding Gaza: “Hamas is an idea ... anyone who thinks we can eliminate Hamas is wrong.” It’s why Israel might feel safe, but won’t be secure without a two-state solution. Hence Oct. 7’s surprise attack coming 50 years after Yom Kippur’s.
Roosevelt vs. Marshall
When facing a decimated Germany, President Franklin Roosevelt initially refused its economic and political reconstruction: “The German people must have it driven home to them that the whole nation has been engaged in a lawless conspiracy against the decencies of modern civilization.”
He approved the Morgenthau Plan, which required that U.S. occupation forces would “take no steps looking toward [Germany’s] economic rehabilitation,” keeping starvation and disease only low enough not to endanger themselves.
Germany then suffered two years of growing poverty, desperation and discontent with cities razed, millions homeless, jobless, without civil law. Realizing that similar ruthless conditions imposed on Germany after WWI led to another war, President Harry Truman set out to fix it politically and economically.
He rescinded the Morgenthau Plan’s directive on “national security grounds,” while approving $20 billion for reconstruction, the beginning of what became known as the Marshall Plan, after his secretary of state, General George C. Marshall.
Truman and Marshall thus laid the foundation of America’s greatest power: its power to convene nations for a common cause that serves all in a U.S.-led order. The nation’s universal values of secure and just governments, open and fair markets, individual and human rights brought together nations sharing these values in countless multilateral organizations and agreements, resulting in a stronger, safer, healthier and more prosperous America and world.
Now, though, this world order confronts a growing authoritarian collaboration. China’s monetary largesse and Russia’s mercenaries attract eager bedfellows, especially in the Global South, assembling countervailing multilateral organizations to America’s.
From BRICS — almost half of humanity and 35% of global GDP — to the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation, the new coalitions’ emerging agendas range from weaning global trade off reliance on the U.S. dollar to an alternative global vision to redress grievances about “out of balance power” wielded by America’s order.
In response, America has contrasted its universal values with China’s and Russia’s “might makes right” approach, as China persecutes its Uyghur citizens, rams Philippine vessels, and imposes an illegal claim to South China Sea’s entirety, and Russia invades its neighbor and targets civilians.
This competition for future partners by the world’s two “orders” matters greatly because nearly every issue is a national security worry. Take connecting the world: who buys microchips or 5G wireless from whom, or who lays undersea telecommunication cables terminating where, determines who taps or inserts backdoors in them for espionage and cyber warfare.
Our universal values
Americans reeled from Hamas’s horrific Oct. 7 attack, and the terrorist group’s appalling hostage-taking and sexual and barbaric abuse of young girls and women.
Yet, the breadth of Israel’s uncritical offensive with constrained access to humanitarian aid contrasts starkly with the universal values America claims. America’s abetment of Israel’s indiscriminatory strikes has harmed our national security as charges of American hypocrisy on the “rule of law” are leveled not just by China but those nations we need as future partners for our security.
U.S. leadership was correct in its resolute support for Israel, but then harmed America’s national security by feckless words without commensurate action to ensure Israel’s adherence to rules of discriminate warfare. Discrediting America’s declaration that universal values apply to all peoples has injured our nation’s safekeeping in a new global era where friends and allies now matter as much in peacetime as war.
What America did for Germany, we must do for Gaza, for the same national security reasons. With crucial U.S. support, Israel’s military has stopped the same “problem” in seven wars. While safe after each, Israel was never secure. When the Marshall Plan fixed Germany’s “problem,” it left the country — and America — secure.
The estimated cost of Gaza’s reconstruction is $50 billion — including locating thousands of buried bodies and unexploded ordnance. That will take decades if Israel’s customary material restrictions remain. American leadership should ensure those restrictions are lifted.
Reconstructing Gaza
America must now assume global leadership for Gaza’s physical reconstruction, assembling requisite multinational funding to begin to repair the harm to our security. Simultaneously, we must ensure Gaza’s peaceful political co-existence with Israel’s by a two-state solution.
Does accountability for America’s universal values matter? When I convened the first high school-age robotic Olympics, 158 nations’ teams gathered in Washington, D.C. During the “Parade of Nations” practice in Constitution Hall, the teams waiting their turn quietly watched from the stands. Quiet, until the Palestinian team walked in. Then — and only then — almost every youth stood and clapped.
We need to change the minds of these nations’ future leaders about the universal application of our values. America can do that starting with fixing Gaza the way we fixed Germany.
Joe Sestak, a former Navy vice admiral, was Director for Defense Policy for the National Security Council during the Clinton administration and represented a southeastern Pennsylvania district as a Democrat in the U.S. Congress from 2007 to 2011.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.