In a Wall Street Journal opinion piece this week, the co-directors of the future Department of Government Efficiency, Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy, revealed the broad outlines of an ambitious plan to right-size the government. This could be a good thing, but the DOGE team must be careful not to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
The bathwater in this case, as described by Michael Lewis in “The Fifth Risk,” is “the biggest portfolio of catastrophic risks ever managed by a single institution in the history of the world.” The world today is a complex, threat-rich landscape and any attempt at reform must account for the similarly complicated nature of that single institution.
A unique opportunity
The new administration has a unique opportunity and a profound responsibility to strengthen the nation’s defenses against catastrophe.
As we have seen with every national-level disaster over the past 50 years, from Hurricane Andrew to Hurricane Katrina to the Covid-19 crisis, the federal government, with its complex landscape of siloed agencies and overlapping responsibilities, is a terrible crisis manager. As we look ahead to a treacherous future, it is difficult to imagine an organization that is less suited to deal with it.
Something must be done, for the sake of our national security.
The danger is that with a big deliverable and a short timeline, the personalities in charge of DOGE will prioritize short-term efficiency over long-term stability and effectiveness. Putting risk first will be hard for them. Entrepreneurs are in the opportunity business and part of what makes them successful is their indifference to risk.
Strategies that include mass layoffs, for instance, are a non-starter. Ramaswamy has floated the idea of firing everyone whose Social Security number ends in an odd number. “Boom. That’s a 75% reduction done,” he said in a recent interview. Boom indeed.
When speaking of boom, Ramaswamy should seriously consider the Department of Energy. DOE is responsible for everything from countering the North Korean threat to shoring up our fragile electrical grid. At the same time, it scours the world to make sure loose nukes don’t fall into the wrong hands.
During the Obama administration alone, it collected enough weapons-grade plutonium and uranium to make 160 nuclear bombs. That is just the tip of the iceberg. With this DOGE rocket counting down the days until liftoff, somebody needs to put the risk issues first.
Look before cutting
Putting risk first means looking carefully before you cut. In addition to the obvious, headline-grabbing scenarios like hurricanes and cyberattacks, the DOGE team of “small-government crusaders” must look for the “black swans,” catastrophic risks like the next generation bioweapon or the existential threat of AI.
Responsibility for anticipating these low-probability, high-consequence risks is embedded in many different agencies across the federal system. Our government owns them because no other entity, private-sector or otherwise, can come close to being able to take them on.
In addition to the black swans, there is the challenge of what Michael Lewis calls the “fifth risk” — the existential threat posed by neglecting slow-burn, systemic challenges, like climate change.
Upon first contact with the sprawling bureaucracy, the DOGE team will discover a federal wire diagram that is complexity itself: 2,000 cabinet-level departments, boards, commissions and agencies stitched together over some 250 years of history with more than two million employees.
Distinguishing the live wires from the dead ones will be impossible without careful study. Before cutting any wire, it must be run to ground, all the way down, through the states and the locals, to the end user. Where else is it connected? That interconnectedness, and its interdependencies, will be the source of any unintended consequences of the DOGE endeavor.
Additionally, putting risk first does not mean leveraging advanced technology to speed up the process, as Musk has suggested. Nobody wants an hallucinating AI algorithm triggering a world-ending mistake. We need a structured, reliable approach designed to minimize errors, one that will systematically assess risks and impacts. DOGE must partner with risk experts, contrarians and red teamers who will challenge its every assumption, every step of the way.
Although cost and efficiency are important objectives, true progress requires a clear vision of an end state: a nimble, effective organization. To get there, DOGE must work to break down the walls of the government’s many silos, one by one. It must unearth the white-hot risks, existing and new and enhance our government’s ability to anticipate and address them.
Once dismantled, the federal system must be reconnected in a way that ensures coordination and maintains accountability, thus creating resilience for a dangerous future.
Put risk first
The risks managed by the federal government are too significant to be left to a rushed or poorly conceived process. They require humility, foresight, and a commitment to understanding the systems at work and the people they serve. Without these, the risks of unintended consequences will only grow, and the price of reform could be far higher than we can afford.
Kelly McKinney, a former deputy commissioner at the New York City Office of Emergency Management, is assistant vice president of Emergency Management + Enterprise Resilience at NYU Langone Health in New York City. His previous article was “We could be ready for the next pandemic.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.