I could feel the election results in my bones. On Election Day around 10 a.m., I drove five minutes from our house in rural western Pennsylvania to our local polling place: a defunct elementary school, now a community center.
I didn’t go first thing in the morning as I thought there could be a short line before work. But by mid-morning, my polling spot is usually pretty empty. I can walk right in, go the desk, sign in, and vote.
I like to vote in person. I don’t want a mail-in ballot. I like to be surrounded by my neighbors, to get a sense of who’s there and maybe, if they talk, what they’re thinking.
More than filling in boxes
Over the years, I’ve known a few poll workers — a babysitter’s grandmother, a YMCA lifeguard — and they make me feel at home. And I want to feel the process. I want to feel my right to vote. It is more than just filling in boxes on a piece of paper.
I often see the fellow who has painted our house a couple times. He’s one of the few Democrats I know here and he’s usually standing in front of the school with a Democratic sign. But this year he wasn’t around; there was no Democratic signage at all.
We Democrats are accustomed to seeing a predominance of Republican signs on our rural roads. I’d estimate about one Harris sign for every 20 for Trump, but I’d never seen a complete lack of Democratic representation at the school entrance.
Then, another surprise: the line circled out of the old gymnasium and snaked around the hallway twice. A poll worker came out and told us that the line was even longer at 7:15 a.m. and if that pace kept up throughout the day, every one of our township’s 1487 voters will have come out to vote. Not likely to happen, he said, but so far, amazing. Many remarked how crowded it was.
I said hello to the local equine dentist, ahead of me in line. He told me he’d retired, that his shoulders were shot after many years cleaning horses’ teeth. He said loudly that he kept getting mailings about how his wife had voted in 2020 and 2022 and encouraging her to vote again in 2024.
If his wife had voted in 2020 and 2022, he said, election officials knew something about her that he didn’t because his wife had died in 2018. He told the poll workers the same story later on.
The words didn’t come
A woman walked in carrying a baby and I started to ask if she’d like to go ahead of me, but the words didn’t come out. I looked around and no one seemed to notice her so I kept my mouth shut. Don’t cause trouble, I said to myself. It’s a long line and first come first served.
But the truth was, I was intimidated. My Democratic friends and I have long been in the habit of keeping our opinions to ourselves. We feel silenced here — blue fish swimming in a red sea, whispering at the gym or the farm store so no one hears our points of view. I still feel ashamed that I didn’t offer the young mother my help.
And I left with a bad feeling for Harris. If the Trump supporters got the vote out here, in our miniscule township, they probably did everywhere across Pennsylvania. I was not surprised on the morning after the election that Harris had lost.
Most of the people in this small rural community are Trump supporters: the stone mason, the electrician, the contractor, the arborist, the auto-mechanic, probably the equine dentist. The list is long.
It is recognized, but not apparently taken seriously enough by Democrats, that these hard-working people feel left behind in this land of poverty, high gas and grocery prices, suicide, joblessness and drug overdoses.
I may feel silenced in this county, but they feel silenced in much of the country and no matter how you cut it, it isn’t a good feeling.
This time, listen
The results in Westmoreland County were 64% for Trump to 35% for Harris. Some Democratic strategist much smarter than I needs to use this western Pa. county as a test market. The Democratic machine still hasn’t figured out how to speak to rural folks in a way to which they can relate.
Do something other than holding gigantic rallies. Listen to what they have to say. They have sent you the same message again, stronger this time: they will not continue to be overlooked.
Daryln Brewer Hoffstot is the author of the essay collection “A Farm Life: Observations From Fields and Forests.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.