The distinguished historian of the American frontier Ray Allen Billington once described the United States’ vulnerabilities on the world stage in terms that perfectly capture the personal character and foreign policies of Donald Trump. “In few other lands,” he wrote, is “nationalism carried to such extremes of isolationism or international arrogance.”
As harsh as this sounds, Billington was no America-basher; quite the opposite. He was a passionate defender of the historian Frederick Jackson Turner’s “Frontier Thesis,” which holds that the challenges of “winning a wilderness” forged a unique American culture and identity whose strengths were democracy, egalitarianism, idealism, courage, discipline, inquisitiveness and innovation.
He knew that these creeds and qualities had won the nation victory after victory on the even more perilous frontier of global leadership in the 20th century. He was specifically referring here to extremes, not norms, the great flaws that often mar great natures.
Living by a code
America attained that leadership in true frontier style, arriving as the rescuing hero time and again during World War I, World War II, and the Cold War.
Yet the nation retained it by embodying another vital quality of the frontiersman: He lived by a code, upholding in his words and deeds a rules-based order higher than himself, even if the morality upon which it was based was often compromised by stark encounters with raw nature and imperfect men.
At his best, those struggles instilled in him a profound humility before the inescapable harshness of life. And if the frontiersmen subdued the wilderness, they also replaced it with something — a democratic civilization.
Read More
With Trump’s return to the presidency, America is again to be led by a man whose persona is a caricature of the “restless, nervous energy” that Turner described as the temperament of the frontiersman. Instead of living by a code, he has contempt for the rule of law. Instead of commitments, he has transactions. Instead of discipline, he has impulses.
Instead of offering an innovative vision of a democratic international order, he foments chaos. His bipolar swings between isolationist ranting and the arrogance of wanting to star on the world stage are an intense distillation of the American vulnerabilities Billington wrote of, making a mockery of his slogan “Peace through strength.”
More perils than before
The menace that these traits pose to the United States and other countries is increased in magnitude by the fact that the international situation is far more perilous than it was during his first term. Though he has re-won the presidency by showmanship, that act will not deliver a desperately needed security for Americans or other peoples in the real world.
The latest “forever war” in Ukraine is not going to be ended “in 24 hours” by any deals Trump offers or threats he makes. His contempt for NATO and threats not to honor our treaty obligations to defend its members unless he feels they are paying enough will only embolden Vladimir Putin’s European ambitions. These ambitions will take the form of cold, calculated moves over time, not the visceral reactions that pass for “policies” in Trump’s mind.
In the Middle East, Trump’s belief that his infinite capacity for dealsmanship will reconcile Israel with Arab autocrats, and that his threats will cow any adversaries, will come up against the complexity of the region’s multiplying wars.
The unending agony of Gaza and now Lebanon is a powerful recruitment tool for Islamic extremists, which can only be countered by a swift end to the fighting followed a significant reconstruction and reform agenda that will offer all Muslims hope for the future. None of this is within the capabilities or inclinations of Donald Trump, whose notion of a reform program is to hurl crippling tariffs against friends and foes alike.
And looming over a darkening horizon there is always Afghanistan, the bleeding frontier where our current age of strife began. Thanks largely to Trump’s raw deal with the Taliban, it is again a bastion for Al Qaeda and a variety of other terror groups, all building their strength and biding their time for the moment to strike America when it is most distracted by these other crises.
A dark and treacherous pass
How did we come to enter this dark and treacherous pass? How were America’s strengths overwhelmed by its flaws, to the point where a living embodiment of the latter has been twice elected to the highest office in the land? At the hour of our global triumph, a terrible test revealed that the American elite had become alienated from the frontier virtues that had made it a great nation.
For more than half a century after the end of World War II, “America First” meant American leadership. The Europeans, Asians, Africans, and Latin Americans who were delivered from authoritarianism, fascism, and communism by the United States looked to it not just for victory but for vision.
Out of the unprecedented violence that attended the nation’s rise to this position there emerged international institutions fathered in Washington that worked to prevent a repeat of this strife or at least to contain it, while striving for a world in which it was replaced by more constructive endeavors.
At the UN, in NATO, the IMF, and many other intercontinental engagements from palaces to plains, American democracy “gained new strength each time it touched a new frontier,” as Turner had put it. And that dynamic also delivered an ample prosperity at home.
To be sure, there were tragic misadventures such as Vietnam along the way, and the imperative of winning the Cold War often led America into contradictory alliances with authoritarian states which were an affront to its values. Yet as the 21st century dawned, it found itself the undisputed leader of the world, with a power that derived as much from the continuing belief in other lands that it was a force for a rules-based democratic order in a chaotic world as it did from the economic and military strength that it was hoped would bring that order about.
As it turned out, this hardy though vulnerable national fabric began to unravel not when we were attacked on 9/11, but because our leaders couldn’t master the crisis. Lacking the courage and humility to admit that Islamic extremism had risen to be a global threat via its contradictory alliances with Saudi Arabia and Pakistan, Washington struck out blindly with misdirected, undisciplined conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq that only made the problem worse.
The “forever wars” which wasted vast amounts of precious blood and treasure shattered America’s hard-won image abroad as a creative innovator, not a destroyer, and culminated in a bitter harvest at home of angry disillusionment with the incompetent elites who had inflicted them on the nation and the world.
As always happens in the wake of military defeat, this anger soon became a reciprocal interaction of foreign failures emboldening the voicing of domestic grievances, ranging from the inequities in the economy to fury that the national heritage was being attacked as a shameful history of the abuse of helpless minorities and nothing more.
Surviving the chaos
The tragic irony in all this is that those who voted for Trump are that part of the citizenry, many of them male, white and rural, for whom the myth of the frontier still has a great resonance as a pillar of national identity.
Yet, long separated from its reality, they have bought into a crass media version of it drawn from movies, television shows, and social media, culminating in the gross posturing of a “reality show” performer who hates the presidential retreat of Camp David because it is too rustic.
If the United States is to survive the deepening age of chaos which Donald Trump will only deepen, it must somehow return to the real frontier values out of which it emerged. And matters are so dire that such a return must begin with a profound humility before the inescapable harshness of life.
Vanni Cappelli, a freelance journalist, is the president of the Afghanistan Foreign Press Association. His previous article was “Saudi Arabia changed the world and America helped the nation do it.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.