As the old saw goes, “Two Jews, three opinions.” Since the destruction of the Second Temple in Jerusalem by the Romans in the year 70 C.E., Judaism and Jews have thrived on passionate disagreement. It is a principle enshrined in the subsequent centuries in the Talmud  — our central text after the Bible — and one which continues to play out in the Jewish world today.

And yet, as the Talmud also reminds us, while students of the school of Shammai disagreed on virtually every issue of Jewish law with those of the school of Hillel, they also continued to marry each others’ daughters, and maintained a tradition of affection and camaraderie between them.

Judaism has been, for the last two millennia, a fundamentally democratic tradition. The value of your opinion on any aspect of Jewish life comes not from who your parents are or how much Bitcoin you own, but rather how much Torah and commentary you have learned. Respectful disagreement and honoring the minority opinion are baked into our tradition.

Democratic engagement

There are a few basic principles found on the Jewish bookshelf which support hearty engagement in American society.

Advertise with us

The first, found in Deuteronomy 16:20, is “Tzedeq, tzedeq tirdof”: “Justice, justice shall you pursue.” The repetition of the word “justice” implies two types of justice: the more immediate, daily justice between you and me, between individuals, and the larger picture of justice, that is, among groups: between governments and peoples or rich and poor and so forth. Both commitment to the rule of law and just behavior in all our pursuits is an essential plank in Judaism.

Talmudic tradition also upholds the principle of “Dina demalkhuta dina,” or “the law of the land is the law.” Our obligation to pursue justice is tied to the wider community in which we live.

We cannot merely follow Jewish law and the law of the land, but we must also strive to make sure that the law of the land is just. The 12th-century scholar Maimonides teaches us that if you live in a place where the norms of behavior are evil, you should pick up and move somewhere else.

The Talmud also upholds the principle of free speech by citing the example of a “rebellious elder” who publicly disputes a judge’s ruling. While the Torah mandates punishment in such a situation, the Talmud argues that if the elder states that he is merely stating a personal opinion in opposition to the court, and does not encourage others to violate the law, then he is not punished. The implication is that free speech is permitted as long as it does not lead to illegal action.

Liberty of conscience

President George Washington sent a thank you letter to the Jewish community in Newport, Rhode Island, following his visit there in 1790 (he traveled there with Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson).  The warden of the congregation had been part of the public ceremony greeting him.

Advertise with us

“Deprived as we heretofore have been of the invaluable rights of free Citizens,” Moses Seixas said, “we now with a deep sense of gratitude to the Almighty disposer of all events behold a Government, erected by the Majesty of the People — a Government, which to bigotry gives no sanction, to persecution no assistance — but generously affording to All liberty of conscience, and immunities of Citizenship: deeming every one, of whatever Nation, tongue, or language equal parts of the great governmental Machine.”

In his response, Washington spoke not only of the freedom and tolerance engendered by American democracy, but perhaps gave a knowing wink at the Jewish role in helping to shape democracy. “The Citizens of the United States of America have a right to applaud themselves for having given to mankind examples of an enlarged and liberal policy: a policy worthy of imitation. All possess alike liberty of conscience and immunities of citizenship,” he wrote.

“It is now,” he continued, “no more that toleration is spoken of, as if it was by the indulgence of one class of people, that another enjoyed the exercise of their inherent natural rights. For happily the Government of the United States, which gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance requires only that they who live under its protection should demean themselves as good citizens, in giving it on all occasions their effectual support.”

A thriving nation

I am fortunate to be a fifth-generation American, and extraordinarily grateful for the opportunities this country has given me and my people, opportunities which were denied to us as outsiders in other lands where the Jews have lived.

As long as we all continue to uphold the principles of our republic, as long as bigotry and persecution are held at bay, and we maintain our commitments to justice, free speech, and respectful disagreement, this nation will continue to thrive.

Seth Adelson is the Senior Rabbi and spiritual leader of Congregation Beth Shalom in Squirrel Hill. His previous article was “Seeking return after a painful year.”