COVID-19 was a catastrophe and, throughout history, humanity’s responses to catastrophes have been a nearly unbroken series of abject failures. And now, as avian influenza spreads through dairy cattle herds in multiple states, many healthcare leaders say they would not be ready if it spreads widely among humans.

Meanwhile, the Centers for Disease Control is being hamstrung by state agriculture departments and dairy farmers, as it struggles to track the virus. Politico describes this gap as “emblematic of the trust gap between key agriculture players in both red and blue states and federal health officials.”

This version of the avian flu virus, H5N1, probably won’t spread among humans, but it might. But some day, perhaps soon, some virulent virus will hit us as hard as the coronavirus did, or even harder.

And we won’t be prepared. The whole government, federal, state and local, remains at a high-risk to botch the next crisis.

Advertise with us

It’s hard to understand how we got here. In the four years since the start of the pandemic, there has never been a proper accounting of what actually happened and why.

How could we have gotten here?

That our COVID-19 response was a failure seems a foregone conclusion. Excess deaths, for instance, were up to 83% worse in the US than in Western Europe through the end of 2021. Contrary to conventional wisdom, though, the causes of our failure were not political.

Although it’s true that containment failed, the differences between the choices made by most Republican and Democratic governors have been greatly exaggerated. It is also true that federal crisis management collapsed and that this occurred during the Trump administration, but systemic problems existed long before 2020 and continue to exist today.

Last year, Philip Zelikow, the former executive director of the 9/​11 Commission, convened a group of physicians, epidemiologists and former senior government officials. The Covid Crisis Group produced “Lessons From the Covid War,” a clear-eyed analysis of what we did and didn’t do then, and what we should be doing now.

“This is really a crisis of competence,” Zelikow told NPR in an interview. “People knew about the danger. They had the science. They were willing to spend the money. The failure was in knowing what to do and how to do it and then getting ready to do it.”

Advertise with us

There are some very good reasons humanity’s responses to catastrophes so often fail badly. Catastrophes overwhelm us, affecting everyone in the same way at the same time. They’re like a tidal wave no one can resist.

They ignore political boundaries, requiring cooperation from people with very different interests and agendas. They sow chaos, making quick, coordinated action almost impossible. They demand information and resources immediately way beyond what is available.

As a result, many people, even emergency management professionals, think the challenges are just too great. They believe that planning for catastrophes is wasted effort, an exercise in futility.

Critical coordination

This view misses the critical role of coordination, and the even more fundamentally critical role of planning. Planning means knowing what must be done and who is on the hook to do it.

Planning enables coordination and, with effective coordination, nothing is impossible. In a resource-rich environment such as ours, only coordination can plug the information and resource gaps and manage the negative outcomes, the consequences, of the disaster. Coordination is the value that emergency managers bring, along with the bedrock principle of accountability.

Advertise with us

When we saw the outbreak in Wuhan in January 2020, the emergency management team at my organization, NYU Langone Health, put ourselves there, to size it up. We activated our crisis teams weeks before New York City became the first U.S. epicenter of the pandemic.

By engaging all levels of our enterprise early, we were signaling that the incident, although seemingly far off and remote, was in reality a serious threat. In a crisis, this step is critical to removing the psychological barriers that hinder effective action. It prepares people to act in the unusual and extensive ways a crisis requires.

People asked us then why we were working so hard when the pandemic had not yet come. The answer was because we knew that when we finally did see a tidal wave of infectious patients, our options for dealing effectively with the crisis will have long since run out.

The real heroes, of course, were the nurses and doctors and clinical and support staff who worked on the floors, around the clock, saving lives. But they need emergency managers and a nimble organization that learned and evolved constantly, from updating safety protocols to changing the use of hospital spaces.

This contrasts with the clumsy federal bureaucracy, and the failure of its various components, from HHS, to CDC, to DHS, to FEMA, to take an ownership stake in the crisis. Instead they pointed at each other, and dithered, while the virus spread rapidly — and invisibly — across the nation.

Advertise with us

The one way to do this

The people responsible for protecting the nation from such threats must stop dithering and pointing fingers at each other for past failures — though we need to keep studying the past to better understand what we need to do now.

They must start to reconfigure our government and other systems to confront the unknown in a complex environment. There aren’t two ways to do this — to know what must be done and who is on the hook to do it. There is only one.

A leadership voice (i.e., the White House) must call for a comprehensive, proactive, integrated, and all-of-nation planning program. The president must create a National Catastrophic Planning Team to lead it.

This team would start its work by breaking down the walls between the various silos within the Department of Health and Human Services itself. That department has several separate agencies that should be working closely together on this.

These include the CDC, the National Institutes of Health, the Food and Drug Administration, and several less well known ones, like the Biomedical Advanced Research and Development Authority and the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.

Advertise with us

It would gradually expand throughout the rest of the federal government and then on to the states, local governments, tribal nations and territories, gradually encompassing the whole of community through a meaningful connection to academia and the non-profit, not-for-profit, faith-based and voluntary sectors.

One of the Covid Crisis Group’s major findings was that only business, and certain parts of the military, have the know-how that we need. The National Catastrophic Planning Team would build more of these public-private ventures to get the big things done.

Because of the near-certainty of future pandemic outbreaks, this would start with the urgent need for early detection and tracking systems for infectious disease.

A better prepared America

We can do this. Politics didn’t cause the crisis and cannot now be our excuse for inaction. Pandemics are just one of the many risks that inhabit the threat-rich landscape that we all face.

It’s one we know we’ll face again and maybe soon, and one whose destructive effects we know we can reduce — if we take action now. Through leadership and a nationally shared commitment to prepare for the next pandemic, we can ensure that America is better prepared, and that means that fewer Americans will die.

Kelly McKinney, a former deputy commissioner at the New York City Office of Emergency Management and chief disaster officer at the American Red Cross in Greater New York, is now chief of emergency management at NYU Langone Health in New York City.