In the summer of 2026 America will celebrate 250 years of independence. The stories we know make independence seem like a foregone conclusion. In reality, the fact that thirteen colonies agreed to declare independence together was something of a miracle.

To understand what was actually a bewildering road to independence, we need to look elsewhere — the Forks of the Ohio River. What happened in Pittsburgh 250 years ago is where we need to start. And it involved a local war and a massacre of native peoples.

Civil war and revolution both

A year before the battles of Lexington and Concord, colonists throughout America did not like or trust one another. Nowhere is this better illustrated than in Pittsburgh. In the same decade that the colonies would promote a “common cause” and call for an American union, there was a civil war at the Forks.

In the preceding decades, both Pennsylvania and Virginia thought that the region surrounding the confluence of the Allegheny and Monongahela Rivers belonged to them. When the British — ever looking to save money — ordered the redcoat garrison at Fort Pitt to pack up and head east late in 1772, those colonial rivalries quickly descended into chaos.

Advertise with us

Both Pennsylvania and Virginia created new jurisdictions to encompass the settlement. For a time, Pittsburgh belonged to both Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania, and West Augusta County, Virginia.

Officials from Pennsylvania and Virginia intimidated and arrested one another. Men fought in the streets of the tiny village of Pittsburgh. Virginians occupied the abandoned Fort Pitt, renamed it after their governor, Lord Dunmore, and, a month after the Boston Tea Party, called for the militia to organize and defend it against Pennsylvania’s claims.

This was a troubling development for the revolutionary movement that was building to a crisis back east. Patriot leaders like Sam Adams needed Pittsburgh: if the backcountry did not support them, or worse, fought against them, the Revolution didn’t stand much of a chance. Pittsburgh was vital, and it was in chaos in 1774.

But then things took an even more distressing turn. All of the conflict and commotion that roiled the streets of Pittsburgh alarmed Native peoples, especially the Shawnee, Delaware, and Mingo Indians who lived all around Pittsburgh. With armed bands of partisans marauding around Pittsburgh, they were concerned that peace would not last long in the Ohio Valley, and that they would be the targets.

They were right. Tensions were reaching a boiling point with colonists eager for more land, who did not recognize the Natives as having any rights.

Advertise with us

On April 30, 1774, a group of seven Native peoples — four men, two women, and an infant — climbed into canoes along Yellow Creek and paddled about a mile down to the Ohio River. They crossed the river over to participate in a ceremony that they thought would keep the peace. They were meeting settlers associated with the Cresap family, frontiersmen who became famous throughout the colonies for their bravado and scheming — and their greed for land.

Half of the party came from the family of Logan, a rising leader among the Mingo. He and his family had relocated to the Ohio Valley in the early 1770s, coming from the Susquehanna River region, where his father had been one of the most prominent diplomats of the eighteenth century.

Logan himself wasn’t there, but his brother, sister, mother, and infant niece made up most of the party that paddled across the Ohio. Today, they would have passed under Ohio Route 7 and a graffiti-covered railroad trestle as they caught the big river’s current while headed for a small, two-room cabin on the other side.

Known as Baker’s Bottom, the cabin sat just behind what is now the parking lot of the Mountaineer Casino and Racetrack in New Cumberland, West Virginia, about 35 miles northwest of Pittsburgh and 90 miles downriver.

The massacre

When they arrived, the Natives were invited into the cabin’s front room, where a few colonists poured them drinks and began the process of keeping peace along the river. Things were tense but the alcohol helped.

Advertise with us

Someone proposed a shooting contest as a diversion to further clear the air. Several went outside and identified a target. You go first, the colonists told the Natives, and the latter fired, leaving themselves disarmed. The trap was sprung.

When the shooting started, more than a dozen colonists hiding in the back room of the cabin ran out into the yard, attacking the Natives, who sprinted for their canoes. Bullets took down one man, then another and another. The elderly woman fell too.

The other woman clutched her baby as she ran for the water’s edge. When she realized escape was impossible, she turned and begged the men to spare the child’s life. She’s the daughter of a white man, she pleaded, hoping that might convince them to spare her. They paused, allowed her to cover the baby — and shot her in the face.

Two more canoes of Mingo Indians were in the middle of crossing the Ohio when the shooting started, and the ambushers fired on them too, killing another two and severely wounding a third. In all, eight people were killed at what would become known as the Yellow Creek Massacre.

It’s doubtful the colonists who perpetrated this massacre knew that most of the dead were the family of Logan. He would soon seek revenge for the cold-blooded murder of his kin. As a result, the entire Pittsburgh region — already on edge in the midst of a colonial civil war — would descend into a bloody war with Native peoples, principally the Shawnee.

Advertise with us
Logan finds his family murdered by settlers on April 30, 1774, in what is now New Cumberland, W.V.(Library of Congress)

The Yellow Creek Massacre was the flashpoint that led to a war between Virginia (who then claimed Pittsburgh as theirs) and the Shawnee Indians that raged all summer and fall, into the time that the First Continental Congress sat in Philadelphia. It threatened to upend what they wanted to accomplish there.

Over the next several months, Pennsylvanians watched as the Virginians took the lead on prosecuting this war. Virginia’s governor, Lord Dunmore, personally came to Pittsburgh to oversee one of the state’s two invasion forces.

On Oct. 10, 1774 — while the First Continental Congress sat in Philadelphia to discuss how to respond to Britain’s “Intolerable Acts” — one of the most extensive and largest battles between colonists and Natives was fought, resulting in a victory for Dunmore’s Virginians.

It would take the rest of the 1770s for Virginia to relinquish its claims to Pittsburgh and for it to become part of Pennsylvania. Throughout that time, revolutionary leaders back east continued to fret over what might be happening in Pittsburgh, and especially about how the British might be taking advantage of all these hard feelings to turn Logan and his people against the United States.

Yellow Creek might very well have destroyed America’s bid for independence: had Native peoples, enraged by Dunmore’s War with the Shawnee, joined en masse with the British, it very well could have threatened the whole enterprise. Patriot leaders were going to have to work very hard to prevent that from happening — and they did.

Advertise with us

The road to independence

What does all this have to do with our 250th celebrations of American independence? It is a reminder that the road to American independence was hardly inevitable, or straight.

And it wasn’t all happening far away to the east. The brewing civil war in Pittsburgh and the escalation of that conflict into a bloody war with Native peoples in Ohio show just how unpredictable, violent, and chaotic those months leading up to independence were.

Two hundred and fifty years ago, Pittsburgh was a strange and scared place, but it was a vital one if the Revolution was going to succeed. That this part of the world became part of an independent United States was itself a bewildering, fascinating affair.

All this also reminds us that our history is more complicated and less purely heroic than our stories. Michael Cresap, at first blamed for the massacre at Yellow Creek, would be transformed by the Revolution into a hero alongside George Washington. In death, he helped cement the pioneer myth at the heart of the new republic.

When we commemorate July 4, 1776, we must remember how the event we celebrate was intertwined with horrific events, like what happened to Logan’s family at Yellow Creek.

Robert G. Parkinson is associate professor of history at Binghamton University. His history of the Yellow Creek Massacre, “Heart of American Darkness: Bewilderment and Horror on the Early Frontier,” will be published on May 28. He grew up in Pittsburgh.