Chris and his wife live in a three-sided coal basement dug out of the side of a hill at an intersection in Pittsburgh, with a tarp forming the fourth wall of the structureChris and his wife live in a three-sided coal basement dug out of the side of a hill at an intersection in Pittsburgh, with a tarp forming the fourth wall of the structure. With five roads converging on the spot, Chris can take advantage of longer red lights and walk down longer lines of cars with a sign that signals — sometimes in all caps — a current need: “PROPANE, RAT TRAPS, BATTERIES, WATER, FOOD, PRIVATE LANDLORD.”

At one of these long red lights, after I gave him some granola bars and water, he told me that he lives in the “cave” with his wife. Chris had a very long rap sheet by a young age, and until recently had been living in subsidized housing. His building was condemned, and he and his wife moved into this old coal basement.

“Nobody will give me a lease,” he told me. He described his new home as “nice, except the rats keep getting into our food supplies, and it can be cold sometimes.”

Just above the surface

By “private landlord,” he meant someone who would overlook his criminal record and lease him an apartment. I couldn’t give him an apartment, but I did offer him a cigarette.

Advertise with us

There are many who would balk at the idea of giving Chris a cigarette. It’s not just that cigarettes do not contribute to any of the basic needs that we associate with survival. They actively work against physical well-being. But that is to confuse help that contributes to surviving and help that contributes to thriving, and to underestimate how important it is for people to thrive (as well as they can) as well as survive. Separating “survival needs” from “thriving needs” works to dis-integrate a human being.

We often imagine that to survive is to hold our heads above water. And this image has some nice resonance with the literal origins of the word “survive,” which comes to us from the Latin super (above) and vivere (to live). To survive is to hit the minimum thresholds for staying alive — breathing just above the surface of death. We eat, we sleep, we shiver to warm up, and we do it again the next day.

When we buy homeless people food, we often buy nutrient-dense food with a long shelf life, and very rarely do we think to throw some chocolate in the grocery cart. Or a pack of cigarettes. But folks living on the streets — or in a cave — need more than granola bars; right now, not later when they have a job and a house.

When we focus only on the survival needs of the homeless, we risk dis-integrating the human person. Thriving has more to do with what we live for and less to do with what keeps us alive. Often taking a red-light-minute to hear a story reminds a person that they have a story to tell.

But necessary is not sufficient. Imagine only addressing a plant’s need for water without considering its need for more sunlight, better soil, protection from animals. What we need for for physical survival is not what we need for living a fully human life.

Advertise with us

Thriving is of a different order than surviving because thriving incorporates bodily needs into an integrated, spiritual whole. Spiritual needs, of course, are not as assertive or measurable as physical needs.

We might become uncomfortable when thinking about the need for tenderness; the need to be seen and heard; the need to be loved and to love, and feel uncomfortable especially about offering them to others. But these needs are essential for human beings to live a more human life.

Two years ago, I encountered a man collecting old cigarette butts out of a sidewalk trashcan. I brought him to my car, where I gave him a whole pack of cigarettes, a doughnut, and a large cup of coffee.

I’ll never forget his response: “Are you an angel? Did God send you to me this morning?” Giving this man a pack of cigarettes was an encounter with transcendence. He was served with abundance and with the recognition that he was more than a protein-processing machine. It’s that gratuity — that “uselessness” of some things — that reminds us that we can hope for more than three hots and a cot.

Holding on

Groups and programs, like the Pittsburgh program Mobile Thriving Respite, described by Brent Robbins in these pages, or Christ in the City in Denver and Philadelphia, are completing what the government programs and homeless ministries are doing for the survival needs of the homeless. I applaud these efforts, and I think we need to recognize them as just as necessary as their survival-needs counterparts.

Advertise with us

According to the Oxford English Dictionary, “thriving” comes to us through an Old Norse word meaning “to clutch, grip, grasp, lay hold of with sudden effort.” I like this connection because it reminds me that thriving is as much about hope as about achieving.

Clutching — vigorously grasping — implies receiving something valuable, but it also indicates a need to hold on to something for dear life. Thriving, it turns out, is constituted by all those moments when we are recognized in our noblest parts, and we hold onto those moments for dear life. We can’t just help people living on the streets survive. We must do what we can to help them thrive.

James DeMasi is the executive director of the Beatrice Institute. An earlier version of his article was printed, for which we apologize.