During the Depression Era, professional boxing was Pittsburgh’s favorite sport. Every section of the Steel City had fighters representing its population.
The North Side had Irishmen; the South Side, Poles; the Upper Hill, Blacks, and the Lower Hill, Jews. Boxing promoters played up the neighborhood and ethnic angles to draw large crowds, mostly to the Duquesne Garden where feature bouts took place.
Let me describe two of the greatest before I get to Pittsburgh’s most popular boxer. In 1929, the North Side’s Teddy Yarosz, a future world middleweight champion, made his professional debut.
Following in his footsteps were a string of Pittsburgh’s boxing world titlists and top-ranked contenders, trained in gyms around the Monongahela Valley. Yarosz fought eleven world champions and top contenders in his career and defeated ten of them.
Boxing analysts consider Harry “The Windmill” Greb the best boxer, pound for pound, in the sport’s history. He was Pittsburgh’s most accomplished fighter, defeating, multiple times, the most skillful light and middleweights. In 1937, he fought thirty-seven times in a single year, a record.
Pittsburgh’s most popular
But the most popular boxer was the “Pittsburgh Kid,” Billy Conn. He was on the losing end of one of boxing history’s most famous, legendary what-might-have-been matches.
On June 18, 1941, Conn narrowly lost to America’s hero, world heavyweight champion Joe Louis, the “Brown Bomber.” Conn was ahead on points on the judges’ card through 12 rounds, until he foolheartedly abandoned his bobbing and weaving strategy to trade punches blow for blow with Louis.
Had he stuck to his game plan, he would have taken Louis’s championship belt. No one, he found out too late, could punch with Louis.
Conn had steadily moved up in weight classes from lightweight, to middleweight to heavyweight, but in their Polo Grounds showdown he gave away twenty-five pounds. Louis tipped the scales at 199; Conn, 174.
Thousands of Yinzers traveled to the Polo Grounds, the New York Giants’ home stadium, to root for the “Pittsburgh Kid” in his quixotic quest to upset the invincible Louis, defending his title for the seventh time.
Locals who could not make the journey to New York had an excellent option. They could go to the Pirates game where club management advertised that the Forbes Field loudspeakers would be hooked up to transmit the Mutual Broadcasting System report of the “fight of the century.”
The ballgame would pause at 10 p.m. when the bell rang for Round One and would resume at the conclusion of the historic bout.
The financially sinking Pirates team, which that season had a total attendance of 482,241, an average of little more than 6,000 per home game, had to attract paying customers. The previous game, an afternoon affair with the Giants, drew only 1,586, despite featuring future Hall of Famer Carl Hubbell pitching for New York.
On the big night, the Forbes Field gates opened at 6:30 p.m., with the first pitch scheduled for 9:15 p.m. Popular local musician Danny Nirella serenaded the crowd, playing popular tunes of the time throughout the twilight hours.
Forbes Field’s 1941 highest single-game attendance, 24,738, eagerly awaited Pittsburgh sports’ history’s most anticipated if unconventional doubleheader, baseball and boxing.
When home plate umpire Jocko Conlan gave the “Play ball!” command at 9:22 p.m., Pirates’ hurler Max Butcher threw the first pitch. Then, after 3-1/2 innings, the tower lights were turned off, and the fans settled back to listen to Conn and Louis go at each other.
Billy Conn’s mistake
Conn knew about the fearsome Louis. Former heavyweight champ James J. Braddock, “The Cinderella Man,” compared Louis’ right to being “nailed with a crowbar.” Louis stalked his victims in a cold, calculated manner, his shark-like eyes fixed on his prey. Of Louis’ 68 victories, 54 were knockouts.
The scouting reports on Louis didn’t faze Conn; he exuded confidence. The champ was a fast starter, always looking to land the KO punch in the early rounds. Conn had a slick, standup style that he maintained until the fateful 13th round when Louis decked him.
A hush settled over Forbes Field when the referee’s count reached ten. Conn was Louis’ 18th victim since June 1937, when he captured the heavyweight crown against Jim Braddock.
After the referee raised the victorious Louis’ hand, reporters asked Conn why he abandoned his winning strategy. Conn blamed his stubbornness: “I guess it’s the Irish in me. I knew I hurt him and had him going in the 12th round and was going out for a knockout, but he got to me first. All they say about his hitting is true. His punches feel like the kick of a mule, and they really hurt when they land.”
Meanwhile, back at Forbes Field, after the pitchers warmed up, the action continued at 11:18 p.m. Because of an MLB rule that prohibited innings to start after 11:50 p.m., umpires called the game at a 2-2 tie.
Butcher went all the way, 11 innings, and fans saw eight Hall of Famers on the field, including umpire Jocko Conlan: from the Pirates, shortstop Arky Vaughan, catcher Al López, coach Honus Wagner and manager Frankie Frisch; from the Giants, outfielder Mel Ott, catcher Gabby Hartnett and manager Bill Terry.
The Pittsburgh Kid stayed home
World War II delayed the highly anticipated Conn-Louis rematch until 1946. Fighting this time at Yankee Stadium, both fighters were older, slower, and out of shape after long layoffs. Louis still won easily with an eighth-round knockout.
The “Pittsburgh Kid” never strayed from his Steel City roots. Conn married Mary Louise Smith, daughter of “Greenfield” Jimmy Smith, a former, light-hitting MLB infielder. Until his death, Billy lived in his native Pittsburgh and resided in the same Squirrel Hill home he bought in 1941. Mary Louise and Billy remained married until his 1993 death at age 75. In 2017, at age 94, Mary Louise passed.
But today, more than eight decades after Conn’s memorable slugfest against Louis, generations of Pittsburghers fondly recall how close the “Pittsburgh Kid” came to knocking off the great Joe Louis.
Joe Guzzardi is a member of the Society for American Baseball Research’s Forbes Field Chapter. Contact him at guzzjoe@yahoo.com. His previous article was “The dictator who stacked his team with Black players from Pittsburgh.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.