Examining the concept of international law, for many, is a distant and perhaps useless endeavor. Yet there are examples daily, from Ukraine to Gaza, from the seas and beyond, that prompt cries and questions. How can there be law when there is no sovereign body to enforce it? How can any state, on behalf of its citizens, give up sovereignty and subject itself to the vagaries of decisions by other states, or even by individual judges, on the legality of its future actions? Can there really be International law that not only responds to today’s violations of legal norms but also prevents future violations?
In a world filled with conflicts, these questions affect people’s lives on a daily basis. And the answers have been in place for almost exactly 75 years.
The hope of global law
Two examples of efforts to get states to conform to common norms are the Convention Against Genocide, completed on Dec. 9, 1948, and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, completed on Dec. 10, 1948.The 75th anniversary of these important instruments of international law was marked in Lviv, Ukraine, on Dec. 8-10 by 75 international law scholars from 14 countries.
Amid a war zone where air raid alerts sounded, these scholars joined with 75 international law scholars from Ukraine at Ivo Franko University under the sponsorship of the American Society of International Law and the Ukrainian Association of International law. Together, the scholars reflected on the hopes generated by these two historic documents, and we considered whether the rule of law is possible in the future for the world and, in particular, for Ukraine after the terrible violations of international law by Russia in its invasion and occupation.
The United Nations and its post-World War II international legal order were inaugurated with great hope for global peace and security. One of the successes of international law has been the development of international courts to prosecute crimes committed during war and aggression: from the Nuremburg Tribunal, to the international tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, to special tribunals dealing with a number of conflicts and the International Criminal Court. There, judges have considered past acts of dictators, generals and ethnic leaders. Convictions were rendered and prison sentences imposed.
But has that process enhanced the rule of law for the future? Do leaders like President Putin of Russia care at all that their actions are crimes under international law?
When law is broken
Events in Ukraine, the Levant and too many other parts of the world can easily lead to the conclusion that these previous successes have given way to systemic failure. After all, this was our first conference in an active war zone. As participants in the Lviv conference, we were fully aware of the limitations of law in the face of aggression and excessive use of force when, on Dec. 7, we boarded busses in Warsaw and were briefed on security protocols required due to the threat of Russian attacks on Lviv.
Those preparations emphasized that the next few days would not be limited to a mere intellectual discussion of gross violations of international law and human rights. They would involve personal and practical responses to those violations.
The scholars at Lviv spent a great deal of time discussing decisions in the International Court of Justice, the International Criminal Court and the European Court of Human Rights focused on past conduct of Russia. Ukraine has used the international legal system to seek accountability for Russia’s many acts that violate international legal norms.
But Ukraine remains mired in a struggle to throw off Russian intervention and continued violations of international law. Like domestic criminal law, international criminal law often fails to prevent future conduct, even when it is effective in some way in providing retribution and punishment for past conduct.
International law matters
Ukraine itself has demonstrated the positive impact of international law. Even during the earliest days of the Russian invasion, Ukraine was cognizant of its responsibilities to captured Russian soldiers and its own need to respond to international law violations with international law compliance.
That responsibility included posting articles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights on the walls of facilities where Russian prisoners of war are kept. This is evidence of the positive value of international law, as well as evidence of a country working to demonstrate humanity over retribution.
And Russia has demonstrated that even President Putin can be influenced by international law. In the ICJ, Russia has engaged for the first time in submissions on the merits of a case brought against it under the Genocide Convention. They may not have wanted to be there, but the fact that they are engaging “in court” brings hope: 21st century wars should be fought with lawyers, not with soldiers.
As Professor Harold Koh completed his keynote address at the closing session of the Lviv conference, each of us in the auditorium heard the air-raid application alarm sound loudly on our cellphones. A Russian MiG-35 had taken off from a location that made Ukraine a likely target, and we all waited for information on its path.
Once we received assurances from our security personnel that the fighter jet was not headed for Lviv, we completed the conference and adopted the “Lviv Principles” that reaffirm the commitment to international law represented by the Genocide Convention and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Ronald A. Brand is the Chancellor Mark A. Nordenberg University Professor and Academic Director of the Center for International Legal Education at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law. Charles T. Kotuby is the Professor of Practice and Executive Director of the Center for International Legal Education at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.