As a Jewish journalist with the last name Rothschild whose job is to explore and debunk conspiracy theories, I’ve heard pretty much every accusation and myth in the book. And it’s a long and detailed book.
Despite not being related to the wealthy banking family that originated in Frankfurt, I’ve been told by conspiracy believers time and time again that I run cover for their various evil schemes, discredit “citizen journalists” who are on the right track and spread their lies at will.
A non-exhaustive list of the Rothschild conspiracies I’m supposedly “covering up for my family” includes owning the U.S. Federal Reserve and almost all other central banks, funding both sides of every war, controlling the media and entertainment, having enough wealth to feed and house every human on earth, holding occult sacrifice rituals and assassinating any leaders who get in their way.
Oldest hatred, new forms
Of course, the Rothschilds are far from the only Jews to be stung with these accusations. It’s hard to imagine any Jewish families who haven’t experienced antisemitism in some way. Virtually every society in every age — even nations with virtually no Jewish population — have looked at Jews with some toxic mix of distrust, scorn, loathing or violent rage.
The horrific events in Gaza are causing another spike of both pro-Hamas protesting and generalized anti-Jewish sentiment, most of which is aimed at American Jews who have nothing to do with the Netanyahu government’s conduct and believe in a solution that doesn’t involve violence.
While antisemitism is often called “the oldest hatred” by scholars, it hasn’t taken the same exact form throughout the generations. Many of the most prominent modern myths about Jewish power and control entered popular culture within the last century.
The very idea of a secret Jewish society running the world first exploded into the public consciousness thanks to the success of various translations of the “Protocols of the Elders of Zion,” one of the foundational documents of modern anti-Jewish paranoia. Others sprang up during the Great Depression, the years leading up to World War II, the Red Scare and, more recently, the rise of the nakedly antisemitic alt-right.
All of them are based in primordial Jewish tropes and myths. As I write in “Jewish Space Lasers: the Rothschilds and 200 Years of Conspiracy Theories,” misguided notions of Jewish financial domination, supernatural business acumen and secret plotting against Christian communities stretch back to before the time of Jesus Christ, with Jewish religious and cultural practices fueling spasms of violence against Jews in ancient Greece.
The tropes and myths
The perceived superiority that Jews have with money dates to the Middle Ages, when Jews were often the only communities allowed to lend money at interest to Christian rulers, leaving “court Jews” in the precarious position of being both needed and scorned. Such tropes have left an almost permanent impression on many cultures that Jews are just wealthier and/or “better with money” than everyone else – sometimes with terrible consequences.
And while the hideously antisemitic blood libel, which accuses Jewish elders of murdering Christian children and consuming their blood in occult rituals, may have originated in 1140s England, its fingerprints are all over the QAnon conspiracy theory’s belief that Jewish elites drink “adrenochrome” harvested from kidnapped children.
The Rothschilds and other prominent Jews are firmly placed in the center of all these and so many more vile theories. And anti-Jewish sentiment isn’t just mobs and genocidal conspiracy theories — it’s an ever-present feeling that Jews, particularly western Jews, are disloyal and clannish, cheap and scheming, and somehow both puppet-masters and professional victims.
These paradoxical and unevidenced theories persist because antisemitism is incredibly prolific, extremely hard to root out and surprisingly lucrative for its creators. As I write in “Jewish Space Lasers,” deranged books about Jewish machinations are hugely popular, no matter the decade. Each new book and thread and film updates and repurposes old tropes about Jewish power and control, recontextualizing them for different countries and time periods. And each time, they find ready audiences ready to blame calamities both global and personal on “the Jews.”

The thousand-plus page tome “Jewish France,” written by a Rothschild-obsessed French antisemite in 1886, sold half a million copies just in its first few years. Leading up to the Second World War, the “Protocols” became so popular that, according to scholars of the document’s history, it’s second only to the Bible in the number of English-language copies printed.
And in the 1970s, two John Birch Society speechwriters penned “None Dare Call it Conspiracy,” a paranoid classic that’s moved as many as 5 million copies. And now, viral threads on X/Twitter blaming the Rothschilds for “creating” Israel or accusing American Jews of disloyalty and treason suck in thousands of dollars in ad revenue for their creators.
A butcher’s bill
The damage these myths and conspiracy theories have done make up a butcher’s bill that can never be fully totaled up. There has, of course, been organized violence done to Jews by governments. And there is an even higher, perhaps uncountable number of acts that aren’t genocide or pogrom, but no less harmful — professional slights, cruel jokes, graffiti, vandalism, assaults, threats, discrimination and outright murder.
No Pittsburgh resident ever should need to be reminded of the 11 Jews murdered in the Tree of Life Synagogue days before the 2018 midterm election by a mass killer hopped up on deranged conspiracy theories that Jewish bogeyman George Soros was paying immigrants to illegally enter the U.S. to slaughter white people. Antisemitism isn’t a distant threat happening somewhere else, or an echo of history. It is here, now, and has always been.
How can anyone look at this tide of pain and think anything can be done to stop it? As both a Jew and someone who extensively studied anti-Jewish sentiment, I believe it can be met not with more paranoia or fear — the things they want the most.
To save one life
Instead, we can choose to meet the moment with humor, grace, resilience and the knowledge that a better world is possible in our individual acts. We can spot our own biases and prejudices. We can understand the fear and exhaustion American Jews are feeling right now and offer support that has nothing to do with politics or historical slights.
And we can see the code words antisemites use to denote Jews without saying “Jews” — terms like “globalists” and “European bankers” and chalking up everything to funding by the Rothschilds or Soros — and push back against them. We can do it privately, away from the prying eyes and dogpiles of social media. We can do it gently, with knowledge and understanding. But we can do it.
These small actions won’t end antisemitism, because nothing from Ancient Rome to the latest Trump rally has. But Judaism recognizes that to save one life is to save the entire world. So maybe it’s an appropriate way to look at the problem: Just as we save the world one life at a time, maybe we stop antisemitism one life or one act at a time as well. When the problem is this massive and the solution so small, perhaps that’s the place to start.
Mike Rothschild is the author of “Jewish Space Lasers: The Rothschilds and 200 Years of Conspiracy Theories.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.