For centuries before the first OBGYN and the professionalization of obstetrical medicine in the United States, midwives offered expert knowledge and assistance in pregnancy and labor to nearly every childbearing person, typically in their own home with the support of family or other community members. Today, we call this “community birth” and it may occur in a home or birth center. While some birth centers are attached to or housed within hospitals, most are freestanding and supervised by midwives.
Despite generations of propaganda that has stigmatized community birth, for healthy childbearing people with low risk pregnancies these experiences are associated with better outcomes, for them and their children. And yet birth centers and midwifery are still available to relatively few people. Worse, due to the history of medicine and race in America, people of color remain particularly underserved.
Community birth
In the fall of 2012, I was 23 years old and aiming to live in Pittsburgh, near where I grew up. My job search landed me at The Midwife Center in the Strip District, a freestanding birth center whose 40-year history makes it one of the oldest in the country. The experiences and knowledge I earned there led me to pursue a Ph.D. in public health, and to study racial disparities in birthing care in particular.
The most recent descriptive study of birth center clients reported a 10% rate of caesarian sections compared to 32% nationally and a 2% low birthweight rate compared to 8% nationally), both birth outcomes that bring greater health risks for the childbearing person and infant. The same study reported that just 8% of birth center clients identify as Black, even though they represent 15% of births.

Meanwhile, outcomes for Black childbearing people are far worse than for white childbearing people. Perhaps most shocking statistic is that high-income Black people who do not smoke experience worse birth outcomes than low-income white people who smoke. In other words, it’s not behavior or even poverty: The divergence in birth outcomes is clearly a matter or race.
Read More
Some of the worst birth and infant health outcomes are in the South, where Black people make up more of the childbearing population. We also see the most severe practice restrictions for birth centers and midwives in this region. In a 2017 study, areas with higher Black birth rates were associated with lower levels of midwifery integration across a state’s healthcare landscape, with many Southern states having the lowest levels of integration.
Furthermore, restrictive regulations at the state level have left a major geographical gap in access to birth center care throughout the South. Currently, there are no open birth centers in Alabama or Mississippi.
Midwifery and race
This is particularly upsetting given the history of American midwifery, and its intersection with race. For centuries, midwives were the primary caretaker during pregnancy and labor to nearly every childbearing person. At the turn of the 20th century, the newly professionalized field of obstetrics, composed almost entirely of white male physicians, saw midwives as a threat to their authority and the emerging business of hospital-based birth.
Physicians invested in the standardization of perinatal care and expansion of hospital-based birth contributed to disinformation campaigns, attributing high pregnancy-related death rates to the continued practice of midwives, even though contemporary research refutes this. In fact, midwives of the early 20th century were practicing antiseptic techniques before physicians, resulting in reduced rates of infection and death.
Midwives and birth centers in the U.S. today, as well as their clients, are steeped in the vestigial paternalism of obstetric medicine. Standardization of perinatal care, while intended to proliferate best practices and maximize health benefits for childbearing people, failed to integrate centuries-old midwifery knowledge and instead promoted the authority of the (white male) physician.
In the South, where Black midwives were the most prominent and trusted for over 300 years, the transition away from midwifery care was slower. Even as physicians began to dominate perinatal care, Black midwives continued practicing in Southern communities, largely because the Black people living there were still being denied formal medical services. They still had to endure slanderous campaigns from physician and hospital organizations, which included being characterized as uneducated, unhygienic and superstitious.

The association of midwifery with Black women only enhanced suspicion of the practice, especially in the South. Even during the resurgence of midwifery care and birth centers in the 1970s, spurred by the largely white women’s movement, the wisdom of Black midwives and birth workers stayed buried.
We can see the vestiges of that today in the lack of birth center access in that part of the country: Stretching from east Texas to Southern Virginia, Black people make up at least 15% of the childbearing population in nearly every county. Birth center locations appear to outline this region, almost as if by design.
Healthy birth practices for all
One of the best ways to improve Black maternal health will be to ensure broad access to midwives and birth centers across the lines of race and class. Again, for the 85% of pregnancies that are low risk, community birth is the safer option. But as it stands, both the clients and staffs of birth centers tend to be overwhelmingly white – a reality that doesn’t reflect the history of American midwifery.
The entire health care system, from birth centers themselves to universities to hospitals to governments, should make it a priority to recruit and incentivize people of color to enter the practice of midwifery. As the popularity of community birth continues to grow, it cannot become a service associated primarily with white and wealthy people. Rather, it must be accessible to all who stand to benefit from the ancient wisdom of midwifery – largely preserved and passed down in America by Black women.
It is essential for advocates for racial health equity and access to birth center care to understand and respond to the racist history of maternal care in America. Further, it is critical for us, as white scientists, researchers and midwives, to defer to the expertise and lived experience of Black childbearing people and Black leadership in this journey. The lives and health of childbearing people, and their babies, depend on it.
Sarah Annalise Sanders is a Postdoctoral Associate in the School of Public Health at the University of Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.