CORAOPOLIS, Pa. — When Richard Stack opened Dick’s Sporting Goods in 1948, the store was primarily a bait and tackle shop that served the Binghamton, N.Y., area. His eldest child, Ed, said in his book that as a teenager, he loathed working in the store — but by 1994, when Ed was 29 years old, he moved the headquarters here and launched a massive expansion, opening over 108 stores.
In 2002, Ed Stack took Dick’s public, and it soon expanded by purchasing rival stores like Gaylon’s Trading Post. By 2018, Dick’s was the largest sporting goods store in the country, and Mr. Stack had become a billionaire.
One year later, after the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla., Mr. Stack decided that Dick’s would phase out gun and ammunition sales from their stores. He made a clever public relations pitch: Though he was a gun owner himself, he didn’t want to be part of the problem, and so after deep reflection, he was removing certain guns from the shelves and halting the sale of firearms to anyone under the age of 21.
Within several months, the limitation on gun sales morphed into a “test” to pull all guns from ten stores, which soon expanded to 125 stores. Now the entire hunting category, including Dick’s Sporting Goods’ Field & Stream business, is being shuttered.
Mr. Stack certainly has been successful — in his 36 years as CEO, the company has expanded to nearly 1,000 stores and has made billions — though he did lose 62 employees on the day he decided to go from being a retail genius to a gun control advocate. He also lost the loyalty of thousands of customers across the country — in particular some here who love to support a local company, even if it is pricier, over its competitors.
Dick’s is now part of a new “self-sorting” in American retail that traditionally begins when a C-Suite executive decides to pick a side in the country’s political or culture wars, moving the country’s polarization into the retail space and often alienating long-time customers.
Read More
Mike Platz is one such customer. The 65-year-old retired IT professional and Navy veteran said that for decades he was a loyal Dick’s customer, but when they decided to weigh in on politics, he was done: “It is bittersweet because it’s local, but the stance they took on the Second Amendment hurt them. I never understood that because they sold guns the proper way.”
Mr. Platz, an avid outdoorsman from Gibsonia, now shops at Dunham’s. “I started using them more for some of the niche items I needed, but over time I’ve expanded that to workout gear, hunting gear and actually have bought a pistol and a rifle from there, as well as ammo,” he said.
Meanwhile, the face of gun ownership has changed dramatically since Mr. Stack took his stand in 2019 — and new gun owners are increasingly representative of the American population: New gun owners are more likely to be female, non-white and younger than existing gun owners.
Firearm purchases began to spike in 2019, when over 13 million background checks were recorded. According to an analysis conducted by the National Sports Shooting Foundation, those numbers increased to 21 million in 2020, during the beginning of the COVID pandemic, and decreased slightly to 18.5 million in 2021.
Of those gun purchases in 2021, over 5.4 million were by first-time gun buyers, over 33% of whom were women.
In that same NSSF survey, retailers reported a nearly 44% increase in Black people purchasing firearms, a 40% jump in purchases by Latinos and a 27% boom in sales to Asian Americans. The biggest change is specifically among Black women, among whom the NSSF reported a whopping 87% increase in gun ownership.
Elizabeth is a 40-year-old mother of four who is always chasing new equipment and clothing for kids who seem to outgrow their athletic wear weekly. She’s a former devotee of Dick’s who now prefers Dunham’s, which she says continues to stay out of the political fray.
“We have purchased quite a bit from Dunham’s over the years, including my favorite tennis shoes, my son’s favorite winter jacket, my husband’s work pants and most recently, new gear for my son’s baseball season,” said Elizabeth, who declined to give her last name.
“I find it peaceful to shop in a place that does not make headlines for itself by making political statements,” she added. “Dick’s didn’t have to make a political statement when removing guns and ammo from their stores. They could have quietly done it and called it a business decision if it was called into question.”
Elizabeth said, “making such statements is virtue signaling. It tries to rally a crowd that probably doesn’t shop there anyway, but it also alienates the crowds who do shop there.”
Dunham’s roots are in West Bloomfield, Mich., in 1937 in a small shop called Dunham’s Bait and Tackle along Telegraph Road. The original store lured customers with clever weekly fishing shows on radio. Today, there are more than 240 stores spread out throughout the country, and Dunham’s is considered the largest sporting goods chain in the Great Lakes region.
Not that much has changed about Dunham’s other than its square footage — walking into a Dunham’s today is like walking into an oversized field and tackle general store. It has a very “Americana” feel to its inventory, and its prices are affordable.
Dunham’s is likely never going to compete in size and scope with Dick’s, and it’s unlikely that the Troy, Mich.-based company is going to dive into politics in either direction — unless you are of the belief that carrying clothing with the American flag on it is political.
Dick’s, however, is continuing to change.
Beginning in 2024, Dick’s will open 20 massive 100,000-square-foot facilities called “Dick’s House of Sport” that will feature batting cages, a 32-foot climbing wall, a virtual golf experience that allows visitors to experience courses around the world and, of course, a “wellness center.” The stores will also feature an outdoor field and running track that will also double as an outdoor movie theater in the summer and a skating rink in the winter.
One will be opening at the former Sears location in Ross Park Mall next year.
One thing is certain: While Dick’s is getting more high-end and moving away from the customer base that brought it to the dance for over 40 years, its decision to remove guns from its shelves has changed nothing in terms of legal gun purchases — or illegal ones. Not selling guns didn’t prevent any shootings; bad guys are still getting guns.
Elizabeth said something Dick’s has accomplished is helping to further divide us: “Like I said, they could have just quietly removed them over time, but making a big production about it means it was more about them virtue signaling than anything else.”
North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, a New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt”: zito.salena@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.