It was early in June of 2020 when then-Speaker Mike Turzai, R.-Allegheny, walked through the front entrance of the House Chamber to call the Monday afternoon session to order. A stunned parliamentarian, Clancy Meyer, stated the obvious: “Mr. Speaker, we have a problem.” In the four decades he’d served as House rule-interpreter-in-chief, Mr. Meyer had refereed plenty of rowdy bouts of incivility, fisticuffs and intoxication, but he’d never seen this.
The immediate obstacle, recalled an aide, was the towering presence of Representative Jake Wheatley — a decorated Marine combat veteran and a member from Pittsburgh. Mr. Wheatley and other members of the House Black Caucus made the unusual — and highly provocative — choice to commandeer the Speaker’s rostrum and live-stream their mutiny to the world. He politely informed the Speaker he wouldn’t be making the climb up the few remaining steps to his usual position at the center of the room. There would be no regular order today. The only topic would be the death of George Floyd and calls for police reform.
Capitol business stopped as staffers texted and tweeted the link to the live showdown between the state’s most powerful conservative and a cohort of angry and unruly progressives.
As Speaker, his power over the body was considerable but not absolute. State Capitol Police could remove members, cite them and possibly detain them. Beyond forcible removal, the Pennsylvania Constitution allows each legislative body to “punish its members or other persons for contempt or disorderly behavior in its presence,” and, with a two-thirds vote, even to expel them. The legislature has exercised this option for far lesser offenses. Mr. Turzai had options.

Predictably, some members of the GOP caucus egged the Speaker on, hoping he’d opt for punishment. After all, the rogue House members were billing their actions as “a takeover.” Anything less than deploying the full punitive power of the legislature would empower the protestors and whittle away the power of the majority — and not just this Republican majority, but all future majorities. They were ready for Mr. Turzai to make a play for his own viral moment.
Instead, Mr. Turzai responded by taking a seat: a defiant act of listening. Instead of his usual perch up front, he assumed the posture of a rank-and-file member, listening from the floor. Then, he instructed other House GOP leaders to leave their Capitol offices and join him in the chamber. They needed to hear this, too.
When an 90 minutes of speeches were exhausted, Mr. Turzai walked to the podium and demonstrated his understanding by repeating what he heard with equal parts humility and empathy. The father of three boys knew something about timing and tempers. This wasn’t a moment to shame or to punish. He wanted them to know he’d heard every word of their plea for action. “I understand silence is not the answer for what is happening.”
Anger and pain — no matter how distorted or influenced by momentary passion — needed to be channeled. They had brought their grievance to the right place, he declared. The legislative process could withstand a little civil disobedience and chanting if it led to hearing the perspective of millions of disaffected citizens.

The self-described “sixty-year-old white man” knew his experiences were worlds apart from life on the street. He’d never have to give his children “the talk” about steps to prevent a traffic stop from leading to an arrest or worse. He and most other suburban and rural members had been spared the agonies of routine funerals for young friends, cousins and children. He knew that even if there was a tinge of showmanship to this made-for-social-media moment, these lawmakers had walked where he had not.
“We want to find an appropriate manner in which to offer up legislative solutions,” he said. “You’ve taken it upon yourselves … to actually provide tangible solutions, and we need to take a serious look at those.”
In the hours that followed, Mr. Turzai convened meetings between leaders and dissident lawmakers, moving a package of stalled bills into the pipeline for debate. He offered no promises but a fair hearing. Allies and critics agree he at least delivered that much.
What went wrong in Tennessee?
When Tennessee House Speaker Cameron Sexton faced his own takeover challenge this March, de-escalation wasn’t on the table. When a trio of lawmakers — one white and two Black — disrupted House proceedings with a bullhorn demanding action on gun legislation following the Covenant School shooting in Nashville, the majority’s message machine went on a branding mission.
This, they argued, was the Democrats’ version of January 6.
“It was an insurrection, and even the media who’ve been covering it calls it an insurrection,” Speaker Sexton told a reporter. “They were trying to incite people. They incited people on the balcony to be disorderly and disruptive to shut us down and try to make us adjourn, which I refused to adjourn. We finished the people’s work.”
Adding fuel, Tennessee House Republicans questioned the protestors’ motives: “It’s never been about change for the three #TennesseeMe members. Their only interest is being in the spotlight.”
The escalation continued, triggering the majority’s decision to pursue a dramatic Holy Week expulsion process, with offending members required to stand at the podium in the well of the House to defend themselves.
Given the largely Christian makeup on both sides of the aisle, and plenty of preachers and Sunday school teachers in the ranks, the process sounded more like a church trial than legislative business. Scripture references abounded, and comparisons to crucifixion and resurrection were read into the record. Add to that the several hundred chanting protestors, inside and outside the building, and the moment had all the elements of chaos.
The rest of the saga is still unfolding. The two Black members were expelled, while the white member survived by a single vote. Hours later, Nashville City Council used its authority to reinstate one of the decorum breakers. The other will likely win a special election and return in triumph.
So, who exactly is winning in this circus? In the political sense, unfortunately, maybe everyone. The so-called “Nashville Three” are, at least momentarily, folk heroes and fundraising phenoms. The Speaker’s future is less certain, but he’s likely burnished his law-and-order credentials for at least the next election cycle.
The tale of two speakers is cautionary. While no one in politics ever fully evades charges of showmanship or insincerity, leadership decisions are a matter of record. If the goal of legislative service is passing laws or getting things done, people in charge must convince themselves of the need to rebuild a culture of listening, coalition building and debate that chooses to persuade, not merely to provoke.
Mr. Turzai is retired from politics now. The next time a legislative body is tempted with the promises of “going viral,” both sides should ask him how to just say no. He’ll make the time.
Jeff Coleman is founder and principal at Churchill Strategies in Harrisburg. He represented the 60th legislative district in Armstrong and Indiana Counties from 2001 to 2004 and ran for the Republican nomination for lieutenant governor in 2022.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.