SHARPSBURG, Pa. — When German immigrant Peter Wagner founded his shoe store here in 1854, Franklin Pierce was in his second term as the 14th President of the United States and fellow Sharpsburg resident Henry Heinz was only ten years old.

Six generations and 169 years later, the Wagner Shoes stores are still in business and still run by the same family. Seven generations is a remarkable feat for any family business. According to Ernesto Poza, professor and expert on family enterprises, fewer than 4% of family businesses survive to the fourth generation, and companies that do make it to the fifth generation are so uncommon there is little research available to document it.

Mark Wagner, 30, is that seventh-generation family member. He runs the business along with his father, Greg, and brother, Ben. Across the river from the site of the original Sharpsburg story — in Lawrenceville — Mark stands in the center of one of the two Wagner Quality Shoes still operating in the region (the other is in Monroeville) and says he credits the longevity of the family enterprise to the perseverance and resilience of his ancestors.

“Peter Wagner was a cobbler; everything in that first shoe store in Sharpsburg was made by hand by him,” Mark said, as Sunday morning brunch customers peer into the large picture windows filled with shoes to see what’s new.

Advertise with us

“Eventually the handmade shoes went to factory-made shoes; when his sons came into the business — Sylvester and John — they really expanded the business, and Wagner Quality Shoes had stores Downtown, on the South Side, in Manchester, Duquesne, Homestead, Verona, the original Sharpsburg and here in Lawrenceville,” he explained.

In the 1920s this region was a melting pot of European immigrants, as well as a destination for booming Black migration from the South, all looking for jobs in the robust coal and steel sectors. They flocked to Wagner’s, either on foot or on the streetcar, for their affordable prices and customer service that treated them no different than the well-heeled.

“It’s always been families and working class,” said Mark Wagner, “We’ve never been that boutique, high-end — even in those days.”

The Wagner family's fortunes suffered during the Great Depression, but all stores stayed afloat. It was Mother Nature who caused them their greatest blow — in the form of the St. Patrick’s Day Flood of 1936.

“The flood placed most of the stores underwater, heavily damaged with no insurance to recover the losses. We closed all of the stores except the ones in Sharpsburg and here in Lawrenceville,” he explained.

Advertise with us

Wagner Shoes actually filed for bankruptcy after the deluge, and Mark’s great-grandfather, Myron Wagner Sr., had to buy back the business at auction.

“His son, Myron Jr., my grandfather, who is 95 today, took over after returning from the Korean War,” Mark explained.

Through the generations, the next Wagner in line always took over the business by choice, while expanding its footprint, if you will, in the independent shoe world.

“My dad and I, we both worked at the shoe stores basically our whole lives; while we went into college with open minds, thinking we didn’t know what we were going to make our careers in, when we both came out of school, we were both ready to make our careers in the shoe business,” he said.

In the 1990s his father joined with Todd Lewis and several other investors and bought Gilbert Levy’s Shoe Fly in State College, another family-owned store founded in 1854. When the iconic Gordon’s Shoes owner Chuck Gordon retired in 2020, they also bought that family store and made it part of the Shoe Fly family.

Advertise with us

Mark appreciates that his grandfather, Myron Jr., 95, is able watch the family shoe business finally recover its presence in the region, albeit 87 years after the Depression and the Great Flood.

“Today that partnership that included my father that bought Shoe Fly recently bought the Appalachian Running Company, and we now have stores across Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia and in the D.C. area,” Mark said.

One of the enduring traits of any Wagner store — whether it’s the Gilded Age storefront on Butler Street or the athletic shoe store at the Waterfront — is the old school customer service. No one hands you a shoe box and walks away while you decide if it fits: They watch closely and ask questions to make sure it’s the right show for the right foot.

“We have taken that legacy that Peter Wagner began years ago and kept that ethos of treating everyone the same and with respect well into this century — and we’ve been rewarded with customers whose father’s father’s father bought his work boots for the mill, or the generations of mothers who brought the kids in to buy their school shoes,” Mark Wagner said.

Wagner’s has survived the emergence of big-box chains, discount stores, athletic companies and warehouses. They’ve even survived supply chain problems during the pandemic and online retail shoe shopping.

Advertise with us

“The reason people always come back is the customer service. You cannot get that walking into a store with boxes of sizes to pick from and a shoe-horn and not much else,” Mark said.

Currently there are 10,227 independent shoe stores in America, and the Wagner family is in the thick of it. All along Butler Street, almost every storefront is a small independent businesses, and they all understand that the key to survival is how you treat the customer — which isn’t always easy in an era of perpetual surliness.

There is something almost magical about finding a store like Wagner Shoes, one that has weathered bankruptcy and dark days, yet finds itself stronger and still intact nearly 100 years later. It speaks both to a frontier generation long gone and to a new generation emerging — and to a spirit of striving for the American dream that endures even now.

North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, a New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt”: zito.salena@gmail.com.