This time of year, they pop up nearly everywhere — under the tree, on the desk at work and in front yards, church yards, religious school yards and even corporate plazas. Nativity scenes are so familiar to us that we often pass them by with barely a glance. We even see them year-round in the form of bumper stickers underscored with the admonition “Keep Christ in Christmas.”
Nativity scenes today seem to symbolize the warmth and coziness of the Christmas season. But of course the reality, as related in Luke’s Gospel, was one of deprivation and desperation: The Holy Family, including a mother only moments from giving birth, was turned away from the supposed houses of hospitality in Bethlehem. “She wrapped him in swaddling clothes and laid him in a manger, because there was no room for them in the inn.”
Times have changed. Or have they? Is there room in the inn today? Despite our fondness for Nativity scenes, have we understood their message? Do we care? Should we care? How can we care? Isn’t it too late?
I never met Dorothy Day, cofounder, along with Peter Maurin, of the Catholic Worker newspaper and movement. But you and I have been or have met many of those she had in mind when, in 1945, she wrote:
It is no use to say that we are born two thousand years too late to give room to Christ. Nor will those who live at the end of the world have been born too late. Christ is always with us, always asking for room in our hearts. But now it is with the voice of our contemporaries that he speaks, with the eyes of store clerks, factory workers and children that he gazes; with the hands of office workers, slum dwellers and suburban housewives that he gives. It is with the feet of soldiers and tramps that he walks, and with the heart of anyone in need that he longs for shelter. And giving shelter or food to anyone who asks for it, or needs it, is giving it to Christ.
Hospitality was a hallmark of Dorothy Day’s spirituality. Born in 1897 in Brooklyn, Day was a writer and social activist from a young age. After a tumultuous early life, she entered the Catholic Church in 1929, without giving up one bit of her social and political radicalism.
Read More
She died in 1980, but her legacy continues to this day and extends to this city in the form of houses of hospitality: places where people who fall through the cracks of our society can find welcome, sustenance and peace.
She first founded a house of hospitality in New York in 1936, and within five years there were 32 such houses in 27 cities, including Pittsburgh. It was in 1937, inspired by Day, that Pittsburgh priest Father Charles Rice and others affiliated with a local group known as the Catholic Radical Alliance opened St. Joseph House of Hospitality on Wylie Avenue in the Hill District.
According to a document in the House’s archives, “The policy of the House was established on the basis of the prototype in New York, that is to say, to furnish food, shelter and clothing free of charge without questioning, keeping of statistics or case-records, in short, without red-tape of any sort.”
The house survives today, now on Bedford Avenue, as a program of Catholic Charities of the Diocese of Pittsburgh. In the spirit of Dorothy Day and of the Holy Family, it offers practical assistance to those who are without shelter or at-risk of losing their homes.
It was there, on Bedford Avenue some fifteen years ago, that I came face-to-face — literally — with Dorothy Day’s legacy of hospitality. Enrolled in a university course on social issues, I was assigned to create a project demonstrating the difference between justice and charity: Justice is what we owe to one another as a moral obligation, while charity goes above and beyond that obligation.
But soon it was clear that I had become the project.
Someone referred me to then-Director Paul Dvorchak, who graciously accepted my approach and assigned me to the clothing room. There, for several years, it was my privilege to be the Friday afternoon haberdasher. I quickly learned I was not so much helping the men with clothing, as they were opening my eyes to Dorothy Day’s vision of hospitality.
This she called a “personalist view,” which focuses on the value and dignity of the human person and emphasizes that we are morally responsible for one another. This responsibility isn’t charity, but the baseline of justice, and the foundation of any decent society. About this personalism, much of which she attributed to her mentor Maurin, she once wrote:
In following such wisdom, we move away from a self-centered individualism toward the good of the other. This is to be done by taking personal responsibility for changing conditions, rather than looking to the state or other institutions to provide an impersonal ‘charity.’
Returning to Bethlehem two millennia ago, and to the streets of Pittsburgh today, the challenge Dorothy Day presents to each of us is to find a way to make room in the inn. Look around. There is no shortage of opportunities. Christ came into the world deprived of human hospitality — except the shepherds, who pitched in where the innkeepers refused — and the questions he posed continue to challenge us today.
Did you give me food when I was hungry? Did you give me a drink when I was thirsty? Did you take me in when I was homeless and a stranger? Did you clothe me when I was naked? Did you come to see me when I was sick, in prison or in trouble?
Dorothy Day answered those questions:
And to those who say, aghast, that they never had a chance to do such a thing, that they lived two thousand years too late, he will say again what they had the chance of knowing all their lives, that if these things were done for the very least of his brethren, they were done for Him.
This kind of hospitality asks us to experience our own nativity — a new birth of thought and action. It is a vision that challenges us to look on the other without stopping to ask whether they are worthy, but instead to have the vision to see and courage to say, “When I look at you, I see Christ.”
What a world that would be. May we be inspired to build it by every nativity scene we see, remembering that Christ was born in a manger because there was no room for him at the inn.
James K. Hanna completed a master’s degree in theology from Duquesne University and volunteered at the St. Joseph House of Hospitality. He lives in Peters Township.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.