HEMPFIELD TOWNSHIP, Pa. — The best explanation of an election’s meaning is sometimes encapsulated in one conversation with one voter, especially if their answer is wonderfully blunt.
“I guess you could say I voted against Trump and not for Fetterman, depends on how you look at it,” said one voter, a retired firefighter who declined to give his name. “I just couldn’t trust Dr. Oz; then there was the whole Doug Mastriano thing, I mean what is his deal? And then Trump made too much noise about running right before the election and taking swipes at the Florida governor and it was all too much for me.”
He did, however, vote for Mike Doyle over Summer Lee: “My problem with Lee is my problem with Mastriano and Trump — too far from the center for me. I don’t know a lot about Fetterman; I just know he had no ties to Trump.”
As he walks towards his car with his wife waiting for him in the front seat, he leans over, hand to the side of his mouth and whispers in my ear, “She didn’t vote. She doesn’t like anyone.”
From the very beginning of covering this midterm election cycle, the twists that began in the primary contests for both parties, with Mr. Fetterman besting U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb and Mr. Oz besting David McCormick, never unwound themselves during the general election race.
Mr. Fetterman, who many in his party believed to be unelectable even before a severe heart condition and stroke impaired his ability to communicate effectively, won by having banked just enough goodwill in the red counties of the state during multiple years of campaigning for statewide offices. This is what ultimately stopped Mr. Oz from crossing the finish line.
Read More
Political newcomer Oz overcame a long list of negatives, mostly having to do with his residency and his previous life as a celebrity TV huckster, that earned him an 18-point deficit early on. When all the votes are counted, he will have cut that deficit to four or five points.
Among Mr. Oz’s biggest challenges in the general election were the two candidates running for governor: Democrat Josh Shapiro, who was masterful at building a coalition of Democrats and Republican voters, and Doug Mastriano, who was not masterful — at coalition building, or fundraising, or any of the fundamentals of a successful run for any public office, let alone governor.
That Mr. Oz bested Mr. Mastriano by about 10% is a testament to the heart surgeon’s willingness to do the hard work of talking with voters and forming coalitions. It’s also a testament to the continued willingness of Pennsylvania voters to split their votes between parties.
Mr. Oz’s other problem was former president Donald Trump. Mr. Oz was never very Trumpy, yet once you earn the endorsement, you really can’t avoid standing on the stage with him when he does a rally in your state — even if he barely mentions you in his message to voters.
Youngstown State political science professor Paul Sracic said that while Mr. Trump is still the master salesman, his product has gone stale: “Republicans who were afraid to cross him for fear of his loyal voters now have a weapon to go after him. There is blood in the water after this election cycle.”
The one certainty from pollsters on both sides of the aisle going into this election was that inflation, crime and the border were on the top of mind of voters. The missing piece was that while voters said unequivocally in exit polls they did not care for President Joe Biden, they loathed Mr. Trump more. As he bragged about his purported influence during rallies in the last days of the campaign and hinted at announcing his 2024 candidacy, independent voters who were breaking for Republicans stopped dead in their tracks — some of them stubbornly remaining in their cars.
Mr. Oz, along with Jeremy Shaffer who was running for the 17th congressional district, were unable to shake off the association with Mr. Trump and Mr. Mastriano — despite running two very good campaigns — and fell as a result.
They weren’t the only ones. It appears that in Pennsylvania this cycle was a Blue Wave: the exact opposite of what happened here in 2020, where down ballot Republicans succeeded across the board, despite losing the top of the ballot to Mr. Biden.
Former Democratic state party chair T.J. Rooney said he has whiplash trying to define what the message is coming out of the 2020 and 2022 election cycles — because both of them are upside down: “I think the biggest takeaway from Tuesday’s election is that voters really don’t like a lot of their choices, and so they do things we don’t expect them to do.”
Mr. Fetterman, Mr. Rooney said, won in part because of the looming presence of Mr. Trump, “but while that part was pretty granular, Fetterman defied conventional wisdom by over-performing expectations in the Philadelphia suburbs while mining votes in places Democrats typically don’t go.”
That paid dividends. No, Mr. Fetterman did not win Crawford County, but reducing the margin in teeny-tiny little counties across the state is every bit as effective as moving the needle somewhere else. In short, Mr. Fetterman believed that a vote in Forest County means as much as a vote in Chester County, and it turned out he was right.
Mr. Rooney said that gamble defied conventional wisdom because Mr. Fetterman really didn’t run on a platform of much of anything at all; instead, voters broke on emotion.
“He ran on a feeling, effectively conveying the story of every man and every woman — even if his own life story didn’t convey that experience,” said Mr. Rooney.
A lot of people will line up to take credit for bringing Mr. Fetterman over the line, including Barack Obama and Joe Biden, who did events for him in the final days of the campaign. But the truth is that Donald Trump may ultimately get more credit for Mr. Fetterman’s victory — and all the Democrats’ wins up and down the ballot — when the story of the 2022 midterms is put down in the history books.
North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, a New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt”: zito.salena@gmail.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.