In heated elections involving contrasting visions, it is not unusual for partisans, on both sides, to wax eschatological about the demise of this or that -ism. This year, the refrain was about the fate of democracy, not to mention creeping socialism and fascism. It was a show made for the media, as prurient pontificators channeling John Donne declared about our expiring political experiment, “The breath goes now….”
Yet our democracy was ailing well before the 2020 elections and the recent midterms. Insufficient investment and attention have been paid to expanding civic learning and engagement for all our people — prerequisites for a healthy democracy. When coupled with the growing polarization of our society, it is not surprising that many fear our democracy is in grave peril. But it is precisely our recognition of the fragility of democracy, even after 246 years, that may provide the impetus for more urgent efforts to preserve it by doubling down on civic education and doubling up on civic engagement, and civic action.
Well before the midterms that supposedly put the fate of democracy on the ballot, there has been even something more foundational at stake: our civic-mindedness as “one nation.” Unfortunately, too many grievances and resentments are fraying the bonds of civic kinship and imperiling democracy. Some polls show that about 50% of Americans expect a civil war soon. Meanwhile, confidence in civic institutions has plummeted precipitously, with only 25% and 23% of Americans expressing confidence in the Supreme Court and the presidency, respectively. And Congress takes the cake with only 7%! Other surveys show worsening race relations and a widening rural-urban divide, with troubling implications for social and economic stability.
Clearly, our civic house is not in order, regardless of whether Rs or Ds control Congress or the White House. But, while democracy did not die last week, we can surely accelerate its demise if we do not commit ourselves to strengthening our civic fabric by cultivating the knowledge, skills, dispositions and practices of citizens in a healthy democracy. Instead of waiting until the election season to hand-wring, finger-point, and ululate about democracy’s imminent demise, we need to invest in fundamental prerequisites for sustaining democratic citizenship for future generations.
Our civics education report card doesn’t place us on the honor roll. Surveys show that only about one in three Americans would pass the basic citizenship test used for naturalization. Moreover, civics education has increasingly been relegated to the margins as many schools prioritize raising math and reading scores or investments in STEM. Meanwhile, social studies teachers receive disproportionately little support and often carry much higher workloads.
Furthermore, there is little agreement regarding the content of civics curricula. For example, a RAND survey indicated that only 23% of civics teachers agreed “promoting knowledge of social, political, and civic institutions” should be one of the top three course objectives. Likewise, just 40% selected “promoting knowledge of citizens’ rights and responsibilities.” Another daunting challenge is the issue of inclusivity and equitable access. An estimated 60% of rural youth and 30% of urbanites live in what some commentators have dubbed “civic deserts” — places with few opportunities for people to “meet, discuss issues or address problems.”
The recent social and political turbulence may have awakened more Americans to take a more active interest in preserving the Republic. Some exit polls from the midterms suggest more Americans, regardless of political affiliation, understand keenly that we cannot take our democracy for granted and need to tend to it assiduously going forward. I hope this translates into a greater willingness to make key investments in building the knowledge, skills and habits of informed and engaged citizens who respect democratic norms and can engage in civil discourse with people of diverse and different viewpoints.
The growing urgency to preserve democracy for generations to come has given rise to many commendable initiatives. For example, Civic Learning and Democracy Engagement, an organization founded by the College Promise and two leading higher education organizations, works in partnership with institutions across the U.S. to advance civics education through the groundbreaking “Shared Commitment Pledge.” Other institutions are working with the National Constitution Center (NCC) to support education for democracy. For example, the University of Pittsburgh Johnstown has launched a unique American Democracy Scholar Certificate in partnership with the NCC, combining theory, experiential learning and civic action.
Beyond just advancing knowledge of fundamental American political, economic and social institutions, these robust civics programs also foster a deeper appreciation of shared norms, values, dispositions and habits essential to democratic citizenship. These include an appreciation of respectful civic discourse, free speech, diverse viewpoints and developing greater agency through voting and participating in the political process to advocate for change from the grassroots up. Ramping up such initiatives nationwide will produce a more informed, active and engaged citizenry, much more resilient and able to handle the vicissitudes of the political winds.
Recall Ben Franklin’s admonition, “A Republic if you can keep it!” In that vein, sustaining democracy requires ongoing housekeeping and periodic housecleaning. So rather than waiting until frenzied election seasons to focus on the fate of our democracy, we need to double down on civic education and double up on civic action for the long haul.
Jem Spectar is president of the University of Pittsburgh Johnstown.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.