As students returned to school this fall, a renewed wave of concern over school shootings kicked up discussions about the purpose of gun ownership in America. Much of the advocacy to regulate gun ownership has been led by women in groups such as Moms Demand Action for Gun Sense in America that view the rise in gun sales as linked to school shootings, domestic violence, death by suicide and violent crime.

These activists might be surprised to know that it was another group of women during World War I who radically rethought and expanded the role of guns in American society. At the turn of the 20th century, gun ownership was often linked to ideals of masculinity and notions of men as protectors. National defense and home defense were one and the same, both thought to be dependent on the right to bear arms protected by the Constitution. But with millions of men deploying to Europe to fight World War I, women led the movement to defend the home — and with it, claimed gun ownership rights for themselves, hoping that doing so would help secure other rights as well.

In 1914, Americans were anxiously watching the war in Europe. While men’s groups tended to focus on military readiness and the impending draft, women’s groups called attention to the mass crimes against women, including rape, in France and Belgium, and debated about what to do if the men in their families were unavailable or unable to protect them.

For some of these women, the answer was to arm themselves in preparation for the kinds of violence civilians were confronting across the Atlantic. That way they could keep the home front safe if men had to deploy overseas.

Advertise with us

Neither the U.S. government nor many gun clubs initially advocated for the idea of women with weapons. In addition to the traditionally masculine reputation of shooting, these women ran into stereotypes that associated female gun ownership with rural life and the lower classes. But that would soon change. These activists made women’s gun ownership part of the movement preparing the country for war. Now led by elite, urban women, thousands joined existing women’s gun clubs and started new clubs in their communities, colleges and workplaces.

The American Women’s League for Self Defense, based in New York City, launched an extensive program to train women in marksmanship and military drill. Women met at the swanky Astor hotel or shot on hotel rooftops and conducted extensive summer training camps that combined traditional leisure pastimes such as canoeing and swimming with shooting, weapons cleaning and even cavalry drilling. In cities across the nation, the sprint to women’s marksmanship started a fashion for women’s shooting “cellar clubs.”

Gun manufacturers took notice. Military contracts boosted the industry in case the U.S. became ensnared in the war. But with men increasingly getting their guns through military service, sales of personal weapons plummeted. That left manufacturers flush with inventory. To drum up sales, gun companies turned to women, citing home defense, advocating for women’s cellar clubs and including photos and vignettes of women halting assaults or home invasions. Some touted lightweight, smaller-fit gun models with ornate craftsmanship to appeal to conventional femininity.

As the market for women gun owners grew, so did wider support for armed women. In 1915, Congress authorized civilian use of military rifle ranges for men but didn’t specifically prohibit women. The change prompted women to arrive at the ranges with their own rifles and ammunition, hoping that the servicemen present would provide weapons training. They did.

As more men’s shooting clubs noticed the trend and accepted women, the National Rifle Association began accepting female members (though only as honorary or associate members) and made trap shooting matches co-ed. Annie Oakley, the woman most associated with guns in America thanks to her sharpshooting performances in William “Buffalo Bill” Cody’s traveling Wild West shows, taught wealthy women marksmanship at a resort and spent the summer of 1918 showing off her skills at military training camps. By the end of the war, the U.S. government equated women’s home defense with other forms of wartime patriotism, including volunteer nursing and resource rationing.

Advertise with us

But women saw other benefits to arming themselves. National defense, and with it, home defense, had long been considered a hallmark of good citizenship, but generally that civic responsibility was tied to manhood and, by extension, the right to vote. Women hoped that if they took on this defense responsibility, it would be a boon to the campaign for women’s suffrage, which was gaining momentum during the war.

Women also saw guns and shooting prowess as ways to protect themselves and their children from domestic abuse, a major crisis at the time. The temperance movement, which was fueled by women who believed eliminating alcohol would mitigate domestic violence and child abuse, was peaking in part due to recognition of this problem.

At the end of the war, the fervor for women’s shooting receded. The dual passage of the 19th amendment, which guaranteed women — at least white women — the right to vote, and the Volstead Act in 1919, which triggered prohibition, accomplished two huge goals of women’s gun rights advocacy. There was no longer a need to demonstrate home defense as an argument for citizenship, and without a war going on, women’s shooting lost its patriotic sheen.

But the push had cemented the idea in American society that arming oneself for home defense and for national defense were patriotic duties equally protected in the Constitution. After World War I, the threat of invasion from a foreign army faded, but fear of crime and personal attacks in the home endured. Gun manufacturers, in adapting their marketing approach, found that both women and men had become enthusiastic gun customers.

In 2008, in District of Columbia v. Heller, the Supreme Court issued a landmark ruling that legally redefined the purpose of gun ownership in America. Overturning many years of precedent and legal thinking, Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the majority that the Second Amendment “protects an individual right to possess a firearm unconnected with service in a militia, and to use that arm for traditionally lawful purposes, such as self-defense within the home.”

Advertise with us

While the Heller decision and other subsequent rulings broadening gun rights have infuriated many Americans who see them as dangerously misreading the Constitution, these rulings enshrined the redefinition of gun ownership in America that women began to bring about during World War I. Far from seeing enhanced gun ownership as dangerous for women, they saw owning guns and learning to shoot as a way to protect women from abusive men while also staking claim to full citizenship, including the right to vote. Ironically, the women today fighting to regulate firearm ownership are taking advantage of the changes that came from the success of their gun-toting forebears.

Miranda Summers Lowe is a modern military history curator at the National Museum of American History, Smithsonian Institution, and an officer in the Army National Guard.