Our region’s history is rich in labor-management relations — both good and bad. But today, Labor Day speaks to the successes and possibilities of labor-management cooperation.
On this, our celebrated day of honor for those who serve us daily and build our country, it’s a pretty good bet more than one cookout will have a union family hosting a management neighbor or vice versa. While we can only speak firsthand to the construction industry, we have come to discover there’s far more we have in common than not, and that industry success is based on cooperation and mutual respect.
Many of our union construction locals and contractor organizations have been in existence for more than 100 years, and have been involved in shaping the evolving labor-management landscape. We founded the Builders Guild of Western Pennsylvania in 1999 to cooperatively address the issues facing our industry so that both union members and the companies who employ them can flourish.
The Builders Guild is comprised of 16 construction union locals, nine contractor associations and the Pittsburgh Regional Building Trades Council. We certainly don’t agree about everything, and some of our meetings can get somewhat lively, but we always do our best to seek common ground — and that is what makes this organization work.
Today, one of the biggest battles we fight is for relevance in a changing economic and political landscape, especially for industries we rely on for employment for our members and contractors: energy, manufacturing, utilities. Some believe that these industries — and as a result our industry — won’t be needed in our “new” economy.
But it’s our union members and these industries that built Pittsburgh’s wealth, and we remain a vibrant source of family-sustaining jobs. Our members understand this, and so do our management counterparts. But it often seems lost on the very politicians who claim to support good-paying union jobs, while working against us or sitting idly by as some of the most critical industries that employ our members and contractors are attacked.
Read More
The modern issues for labor in these industries go far beyond the traditional wages, benefits and work rules. Our unions and contractors now find the need to seek respect from civic boosters and economic development groups that no longer want to be associated with the industries, values and jobs that built this country. It is important to embrace “new” industries, but their arrival doesn’t eliminate the need for pouring steel, building roads, constructing factories, hospitals, research facilities and office towers, and generating the power to keep the computers running, electric vehicles charged and homes safe and comfortable.
Meanwhile, these “new” industries, such as mega mail order warehouses and trendy coffee shops, are now confronting a workforce awakening to the idea of taking responsibility for their own destinies. They are beginning the process that, for us, has culminated in a new era of cooperation.
From struggle comes resolution and shared interest. Throughout the pandemic, shop owners posted signs explaining the labor shortage this way: “Nobody wants to work.” Did they ever consider that, just possibly, nobody wants to work for mediocre wages, uneven hours, and no benefits?
It’s remarkable and a credit to the Builders Guild, and our labor and management members, that fair wages and good faith have led to a sense of common purpose. There has been a tendency among many younger workers who view themselves as white collar, but barely earn enough to declare themselves middle-class and have been taught that all progress derives from individual achievement, to disdain organized labor. Certainly, skill and intelligence help in the workplace, but without allies aligned in a common purpose, you lose not just power but a sense of personal satisfaction and communal accomplishment.
Unions can and should lift up everyone: workers and management; individuals and families; companies, industries and the entire country.
Both business and labor have learned — most glaringly in the past few years — that shifting production overseas, often to adversarial countries, provided short-term profits at a huge social cost. And of course, this was accompanied by a curious phenomenon. Anything with a smokestack, or any job requiring gloves and steel-toed boots, suddenly became low-class in the eyes of many people inclined to brag about their degrees.
As the pandemic dragged on some of these very people celebrated grocery store workers, waste haulers, factory workers, truck drivers, skilled tradespeople and many others who continued to work and ensure we all had what we needed. Sadly, their memories are awfully short.
We have discovered that the biggest threat to our unions is not management, and the most potent threat to our contractors is not labor. Rather, the challenges we face turn on policies, regulations and laws that would damage our industry and those we rely heavily upon — and the dismissive elitism of those who have a vision of a region and economy that is not realistic or sustainable without our traditional industries. These are the issues on which we must have common cause if we are to thrive and grow.
The Builders Guild provides a recurring forum for labor and management to work in unison on these issues, as well as recruiting, training and retention programs for the skilled trades. We offer careers with family sustaining wages, health care and benefits.
As for those who may question this type of cooperation between unions and companies, we have learned that union-management cooperation is not a matter of selling out. It’s a policy of buying-in.
Thomas Melcher is the business manager for the Pittsburgh Regional Building Trades Council. Rege Claus is the executive director of the Mechanical Contractors Association. They are co-chairs of the Builders Guild of Western Pennsylvania.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.