Dr. Anthony Fauci made headlines last week by announcing his plan to step down, at the end of 2022, from his roles at the National Institutes of Health and the White House.

The COVID-19 pandemic made his name a household word; our four-year-old grandson even made up a song about how Dr. Fauci got an ouchie on his . . . I had best leave the location of the ouchie to the reader’s imagination.

Dr. Fauci is an expert in immunology, not in public health, but he became the face of public health during the AIDS and COVID-19 pandemics. His announcement provides us with a moment to reflect on the state of public health in America.

The goal of public health is to keep the public healthy; ideally, to prevent disease altogether. Methods include health education and communication, sanitation, controlling for example the mosquitoes that carry West Nile virus and ticks that carry Lyme disease, keeping our air and water free of toxins and disease-carrying bacteria.

Advertise with us

When all this is going well, almost nobody notices.

Public health also includes immunization (vaccination) against specific diseases when vaccines are available. It includes early detection of disease, with screening and diagnostic tests, and early treatment to save lives and prevent long-term disability in those already infected.

With respect to COVID, there is room for debate about how well public health achieved its goals, and where it fell short.

There is no debate about how public health information about COVID was communicated to the public.

In a word, poorly.

Advertise with us

The blame does not fall entirely on public health agencies. Coordination was terrible among the White House, the COVID Task Force, the Surgeon General, the CDC, mass media, social media, and politicians. The public was barraged with different, conflicting messages from different sources.

There was added confusion because information kept changing. While this was because the science itself evolved rapidly, it only fueled the public’s distrust. More on this later.

There was unprecedented tangling of scientific, ideological, religious and philosophical agendas on everything from closure of bars to stay-at-home orders to masks to sanitation to medications to vaccines. Many public health officials endured threats and abuse for their good faith efforts.

Without getting too academic about it, public service messages should be clear, crisp, concise, correctly targeted and consistent.

All of which poses challenges.

Advertise with us

The medical profession, to which I belong, is not good at being clear, concise, or crisp when we communicate with our patients. It is bad enough that we often use technical words that are unfamiliar to most people. Everyone does not know exactly what DNA and RNA are, or what a virus is, or how different vaccines works.

Communication gets worse when the same words mean different things in medicine than in everyday English. We all know of people who were initially pleased to hear that their cancer tests were “positive,” since in everyday English a positive thing is a good thing.

At least when a doctor and patient are speaking one-on-one, there is an opportunity to ask questions and get clarification. But public health messages go out on the airwaves and on posters and billboards for all to see. Everyone who sees these messages does not pay attention to them, and everyone who pays attention does not remember them or understand them in the same way.

Advertising agencies create their public messages by testing dozens of sounds and images and slogans on focus groups. They target different audiences whether they are selling braces or denture cream, motorcycles or wheelchairs. It’s an expensive and time-consuming process. We don’t provide public health agencies with the time or the resources to operate this way, especially during a galloping pandemic.

Finally, being consistent remains a huge challenge for COVID messaging, since the story isn’t over yet and new discoveries are still emerging.

Advertise with us

To take just the example of masks, the first message we heard was that healthy people did not need to wear face coverings to prevent COVID transmission. The Surgeon General even tweeted, “People, stop buying masks!” Public health authorities chose this initial message because they didn’t yet know that many people could be infected with the virus without symptoms and still transmit it to others. Also, the authorities didn’t want the public hoarding surgical masks that were needed for first responders and health care providers.

But when they finally changed their message and told us all to mask up, they were accused of backtracking and even of lying. There is also something called the “primacy effect,” where the first message we hear is the one we take to heart and remember.

We typically think of science as a slow, tedious, step-by-step process in the laboratory, where scientists conduct one experiment after another until they are satisfied the results are sound, and then submit those results to a scientific journal. If and when the “peer reviewers” approve, sometimes after multiple revisions, the paper gets published.

Then other scientists repeat the same experiments to see if they get the same results. If that happens, clinical trials are conducted and reported and the private company that owns the patent begins manufacturing the test, vaccine or drug in question. Then the FDA has to decide whether the evidence supports approval, and then insurance companies or the government have to agree to pay for it, then manufacturing ramps up and finally the product becomes available to the public.

These things usually take years, and we usually complain about how slow the process is. In in the case of COVID, the technology had advanced so much, from working on other viruses, that scientists were able to move at lightning speed. Publication and regulatory processes were speeded up. New screening tests, and then vaccines, and then treatments were developed in record time.

Advertise with us

While many were delighted at the rapid scientific progress, others were more suspicious and felt things had moved too fast to be trusted. Perhaps if scientific progress on COVID had taken several years, we would have been less rattled by the developments. But more people would have died.

Because of intense public interest in COVID, every step of the scientific process was covered by the media in real time and became fodder for public debate. Nobody in the public could pay attention all the time, and when they did, it seemed like there was a new story every time, which became frustrating. At a football game, we accept that sportscasters make different predictions during the first kickoff return than they do after the two-minute warning, but we don’t forgive health officials that easily.

Better public health communication in the future will surely depend on better coordination among the agencies entrusted with updating the public, as new information becomes available, and doing so clearly.

But it will also require the public being more patient and becoming more acquainted with the process of science.

The media have a major role to play in reporting accurate information rather than sensationalizing it, and in helping their audiences understand the process better, before the next pandemic hits.

Advertise with us

That is when we will find out how much better we have become at communicating public health messages to save more lives. By then we won’t have Dr. Fauci to kick around any more.

Dr. Mary Ganguli, MD, MPH, is Professor of Psychiatry, Neurology, and Epidemiology at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and School of Public Health. She lives in the Point Breeze neighborhood of Pittsburgh.