In 1972, 497 people died in the terrible and often sectarian violence that wracked Northern Ireland. In that brutal year, the British army killed 13 innocent Catholics and wounded 14 more on Bloody Sunday. The Irish Republican Army (IRA) killed 10 innocent people and wounded another 130 on Bloody Friday. And the Loyalist paramilitaries — Protestant groups that used violence to prevent a united Ireland — murdered 121 mostly innocent Catholics in their sectarian campaign.
Hoping to control the violence, the British army, on this day fifty years ago, launched Operation Motorman dismantling the “no-go” areas from which the paramilitaries operated. On this very same day, an IRA unit, allegedly in response to Operation Motorman, set off three car bombs in the small village of Claudy, killing 9 innocent people. July 31 was also the day in 2007 that Operation Banner, the British military operation in Northern Ireland, officially ended.
Yet the violence continued and claimed approximately 3,600 lives, of whom 2,037 were innocent civilians. The violence only ended with the 1994 IRA and Loyalist ceasefires and the 1998 Good Friday Agreement (GFA).
But the conflict had not ended. Instead, it had transformed into a political conflict. The 1994 Loyalist ceasefire statement acknowledged this fact when it stated, “Let us firmly resolve to respect our differing views . . . with our battles in future being political battles.”
Now the Catholic/Republican/Nationalist (CRN) community could work politically for a united Ireland, while for the Protestant/Unionist/Loyalist (PUL) community, their feelings of insecurity only deepened. They still had to fight to maintain the Union, now politically.
An example of this insecurity occurred in 2012, when Belfast City Council voted to fly the Union Jack over City Hall on only 17 specific days. This action brought Belfast in line with the rest of the United Kingdom, but many Unionists/Loyalists viewed this as an attack on their British identity, since the flag had flown everyday before this. The result was six weeks of rioting.
Read More
Then in 2016, Brexit brought new problems for the U.K. and Northern Ireland. Initially, many within Unionism/Loyalism saw Brexit as a victory. However, it ended up creating another existential crisis for Unionism/Loyalism because of Boris Johnson’s Brexit Withdrawal Agreement that includes the Northern Ireland Protocol.
This Protocol leaves Northern Ireland in the EU Single Market along with the Republic of Ireland, while creating an economic border in the Irish Sea between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. In other words, it treats the island of Ireland as a single economic unit. While Northern Ireland has benefitted economically, the Protocol has only heightened Unionist/Loyalist fears that they are another step closer to a united Ireland. This has brought with it renewed political instability and threats of violence.
In the face of this “threat” to their place in the U.K., populist leaders have emerged within Unionism/Loyalism to fight the Protocol and shift Unionist politics further to the right, both on the Protocol and more broadly.]
This emerging grass roots populist movement, the Traditional Ulster Voice (TUV), and its allies put significant political pressure on the largest Unionist party, the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP), forcing it to change its position on the Protocol from fixing it to scrapping it completely. Under mounting pressure to ‘do something,’ the DUP resigned the office of First Minister in February of this year, collapsing the government and creating a political vacuum — and another crisis in Northern Ireland.
The DUP’s goal is to beat back the threat from its right flank by forcing the Johnson government to end the Northern Ireland Protocol. Consequently, it refuses to go back into government until Britain scraps or amends the Protocol to its satisfaction, even though doing so would violate international law. While the House of Commons has recently passed a law abrogating sections of the Protocol, it faces stiff opposition in the House of Lords — and the EU recently launched legal action and has threatened a crippling trade war that would hurt the Northern Ireland economy.
Beyond the political challenges, an unstable situation exists on the ground. The Loyalist Communities Council (LCC), which represents the views of the Loyalist paramilitary groups, “temporarily” withdrew its support for the Good Friday Agreement on March 3, 2021, because of the Protocol. And in April, rioting broke out in Belfast followed by sporadic violence throughout the year. While the LCC has yet to reaffirm the GFA, it has rejected violence and worked to quell the riots.
Then in March of this year, Loyalists linked to the Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF), blaming the Irish government and the E.U. for the Protocol and the political crisis, planted a hoax bomb to prevent Simon Coveney, the Irish Foreign Minister, from speaking in Belfast. This action reinforced the LCC message that ‘Until they [Ireland] accept and repair the damage they have created, Irish government ministers and officials are no longer welcome in Northern Ireland.’
Underlying Unionist/Loyalist actions is the belief that they can end the Protocol by making Northern Ireland ungovernable. However, just saying “No!” and threatening violence are no longer options, if they ever were. Unionism/Loyalism must face the reality that the Protocol, or some form of it, will remain. Withdrawing from government, shouting “No!” and threatening violence may be popular, but these are not policies. They only deflect from the real problems Northern Ireland faces.
Fifty years on from the terrible year of 1972 and 15 years on from the end of Operation Banner, political instability, as well as the possibility of violence, still threatens Northern Ireland. The question for Unionism and the Loyalist leadership is how to preserve the peace, as well as the Union.
First, Unionism must recognize that the real problem is not the Dublin Government or the E.U. but the leadership of Unionism itself, in particular the DUP, that championed Brexit, undercut former British Prime Minister Theresa May, and then trusted Boris Johnson.
In a situation where only 29% of the electorate would vote for a united Ireland tomorrow, Unionism should be appealing to the growing middle ground who don’t vote Unionist or Nationalist by making the case for a Union that works for all.
Instead, the populist wing of Unionism is ascendant and bringing back the old mantra “Ulster will Fight and Ulster will be Right,” all the while ignoring the urgent social, economic, health, climate and education issues facing Northern Ireland.
This populism, to its peril, ignores a prescient warning from a 1977 essay, “Think or Perish” that appeared in the UVF journal Combat. The authors, both life prisoners at the time, argued that “‘Populism’ is no substitute for truth” and “Those of us who rejected the ‘philosophy of right’ for the ‘philosophy of populism’ in the past have been proven wrong.”
Fifty years on, if Northern Ireland is to move forward and not relive the dark days of the conflict, the Unionist and Loyalist leaders must learn and embrace this lesson.
Tony Novosel is Senior Lecturer Emeritus in the History Department at the University of Pittsburgh and author of “Northern Ireland’s Lost Opportunity: The Frustrated Promise of Political Loyalism.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.