Whether a small town is doing well or struggling to stay afloat, one of the most consistent reminders that a sense of civic pride and hope is flourishing or remains part of the town’s DNA is that cheerful welcome sign that greets visitors when they enter.

It works as an ambassador of sorts to let the visitor know — and to remind the resident — they’ve now entered someplace special, with the hope that they will shop in the local businesses, stop at the local coffee shop or diner and sit a spell … the concomitant hope that they take part of their experience back home with them when they leave.

Yet that cheerful welcome sign is often absent in many towns and city neighborhoods in the country — because the community’s identity has been absorbed into a larger, nearby city’s identity. Therefore, a visitor’s first impression is often determined by the first person they interact with.

Raieleesa Ptomey takes that responsibility very seriously in Pittsburgh’s Strip District neighborhood. The 54-year-old is directing cars off busy Penn Avenue into the parking lot at 20th and Penn where she works. On the street, cars are all over the place, cyclists are weaving around the traffic, and tempers start to rise as folks jockey to find a place to park.

Advertise with us

Ms. Ptomey immediately diffuses any tensions with a broad smile, a warm welcome and a flurry of suggestions as passengers pile out of their cars to either experience the Strip for the first time or to do their regular shopping. Dressed in a dark navy uniform complete with a cap, Ms. Ptomey — along with Jules Troiani, the proprietor, and his nephew, Josh Troiani — deftly valet each car in the open lot that has served Strip District patrons for over 50 years.

Keys change hands, walkie-talkie instructions come from the booth as to where to park the SUV that just pulled up — as well as the three cars they need to navigate out of the perfect grid for the three patrons who are ready to leave. Everyone new to the Strip asks where to eat. Regulars ask about how the families are doing.

The interactions are a reminder that many city neighborhoods all across this country still possess that “rural” sensibility that everyone in their town — or in this case, neighborhood — is part of a community.

“We are the heart of this neighborhood; we are like our own small town here,” explains Ms. Ptomey. “There are no franchises here. Everyone is their own unique small business — it is the kind of authenticity you only find in a small town.”

Parking lot owner Jules Troiani says his roots in the restaurant business taught him the fundamentals of the guest experience: “Whatever happens here — from the moment our valet touches your car door — impacts every business on the street. We want people to know we are so thankful you are here, and I have to make sure your experience is pleasant, or you’ll blame Bella Notte or you’ll blame Penn Mac.”

Advertise with us

For nearly 100 years, the Strip District has operated as marketplace to the larger city, with many of the iconic businesses — like Pennsylvania Macaroni, Wholey’s fish market, Stamoolis market, Mancini’s Breads and Schorin catering supplies — having operated here during most of that time. Newcomers like Café Raymond and Enrico Biscotti started as vendors selling their specialties on the street or in coffee houses.

“Most of the deals made on this street to go from having a table on the sidewalk to owning a brick-and-mortar shop all started with a handshake,” explains Mr. Troiani.

Pat Lee has spent much of his career as a butcher at Wholey’s. Two days before Christmas, he was carving fresh-caught salmon on a butcher block to an audience of the curious watching him prepare the fillets. “I worked at Benkowitz fish market for several years before they closed,” he said of the other iconic fish market that served the Strip for nearly 100 years before closing in 2013. “I have been here ever since. I love my job. I love the small town feel of people coming to watch the butcher ready their food. I have been able to put three kids through college doing what I love, where I love,” Mr. Lee said.

Neighborhoods like the Strip are like small towns in more ways than just their sense of community. They also often find themselves struggling with government leaders who want to rearrange or — worse yet — tear apart the fabric of the community to fit their vision of how it should function, much the way rural small towns have fought decisions that have decimated them for generations.

Ask anyone who lived in Pittsburgh’s “East Street Valley” 40 years ago what it was like to have their neighborhood completely erased so that suburbanites could have speedier access to Downtown for work and play; the neighborhoods of East Liberty, the Hill District and Chateau were all chopped up or leveled for the urban renewal projects of the Great Society era.

Advertise with us

The shattering of a city neighborhood for big government projects is no different an emotional experience than the strangulation of small towns with the erosion of manufacturing jobs.

Walk along what once was East Street, a bustling hub of small enterprise, and there’s an eeriness in the remnants of weed-choked coal cellars and old foundations as cars whiz past along Interstate 279. The tight-knit sense of community and belonging that once filled the small businesses that made up the heart of the Hill District are mostly gone as well, as are the homes and businesses.

The people who lived and worked and prayed in these once-special places fought hard to save them — no different than Youngstown, Ohio, did when it tried to recover from Black Monday, Sept. 19, 1977, when 5,000 workers were laid off and the Campbell Works steel mill shut its doors.

Mr. Troiani says there exists in all of those who work to preserve a neighborhood that rural, small-town determination to not let the big guys upend it all.

He points to the newly renovated Terminal building on Smallman Street, a fancy new development pushed by the administration of outgoing Mayor Bill Peduto. While the building is a beautiful rehab of the old produce terminal, Mr. Troiani says it lacks the most important element needed to make a small town flourish: “A sense of community and the characters that make a place special. That’s why that is not thriving over there; the planners and city government think it is just retail dollars and big box stores that will make it successful, and it won’t.”

Advertise with us

A car pulls in and keys exchange hands. Mr. Troiani greets the two women with familiarity, helps them out of their car as they ask him where to go to breakfast.

“Try Café Raymond’s right over there,” he says, pointing out the restaurant a few doors away: “The ricotta pancakes will make your heart sing.”

North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt.” zito.salena@gmail.com.