The story of the four chaplains, two Protestants, one Catholic and one Jew, captured America’s attention during World War II and was one of the most powerful examples of moral courage in the war.
Very early in the morning of Feb. 3,1943, a torpedo fired from a German submarine hit the SS Dorchester, a ship carrying about 900 troops across the Atlantic. The damage was massive and the ship rapidly began to sink.
Panic and chaos ensued, but in the midst of the disaster were the four young chaplains handing out life jackets. When the life jackets ran out, they each gave up their own life jackets to save four others. They were last seen by a number of the 200 survivors linking arms and praying as the ship went down into the sea.
Pittsburgh honors the chaplains
Just last week I was at a Seder, the traditional Passover meal when Jews retell the story of the Exodus from Egypt. A major holiday on the Jewish calendar, it reminds us that we were once slaves and now are free, and that we carry an obligation to care for those who suffer in our own time.
My son, who was leading the seder, sought to include some moments in American Jewish history as part of the lead-up to America’s 250th anniversary, and included the story of the four young chaplains — two Protestants (George L. Fox and Clark V. Poling), one Catholic (John P. Washington) and one Jew (Alexander D. Goode).
The story of the four chaplains is a story of courage, self sacrifice and interfaith brotherhood and unity, and a story of four men who knew their obligation to care for those who suffer in their own time.
The story also inspired a local response here in Pittsburgh. Hyman Rogal, a popular insurance broker was about to be honored for his years of service to the Young Men and Women’s Hebrew Association (YM&WHA) on Bellefield Avenue, a forerunner of the Jewish Community Center in Squirrel Hill.
He insisted that what he wanted more than anything was a mural honoring the four brave chaplains which would hang in the Y building. As he wrote in his autobiography (kept in the University of Pittsburgh’s archives), “This incident gave evidence to the world that although envy, hatred and jealousy divide us, they, our teachers, stood united arm-in-arm, sacrificing their lives by giving their lifebelts to others.”
Joseph Katz, founder of the Katz Business School at the University of Pittsburgh and famed art collector, made several trips to New York before hiring William Dean Fausett to create the mural that today hangs in the JCC building at the corner of Forbes and Murray.
Another tragedy
Seventy-five years after the death of the chaplains, Pittsburgh would experience another tragedy. On Oct. 27, 2018, 11 Jewish worshipers were gunned down during Sabbath services at the Tree of Life synagogue in the worst antisemitic incident in American history.
That tragedy continues to reverberate. But so too does the response that followed, a response in which the spirit of the Four Chaplains lived on.
People of different faiths and backgrounds came together — standing guard, sending funds, writing messages of sorrow and support, offering comfort, mourning side by side.
The Passover Seder and the Tree of Life massacre force us to grapple with the fact that evil exists, that it must be confronted, that freedom and human rights must be protected in each and every generation.
But the story of the Four Chaplains and the interfaith response to the Tree of Life murders offers us another vision.
It is one of kindness, of empathy, of solidarity, of courage, and of interfaith understanding and connection. Evil exists, but so does good.
A new vision
In the not-too-distant future, the new Tree of Life Educational Center will open to visitors. It will highlight the shattering events of Oct. 27, but it will also offer a larger vision: that we are bound together in our common humanity and shared destiny, that we are part of a broader community that needs to right the wrongs and mend the world as best we can together.
That is our enduring legacy for us to carry forward.
Barbara Burstin (burstin@pitt.edu), who teaches history at the University of Pittsburgh and Chatham University and has written a biography of Pittsburgh mayor Sophie Masloff, is doing research on a book entitled “Nineteenth Century Pittsburgh VIPs who you probably have never heard of.” Her previous article was “The sad and ongoing history of antisemitism in Pittsburgh.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.