I grew up watching Andy Van Slyke lock down center field at Three Rivers Stadium, and he was my favorite athlete in any sport. When I got him on the phone last week and told him that, he laughed. “I was just worried about getting on the field and playing,” he said. “I was kind of oblivious to what fans really thought, because you read the newspaper and that was it.”

Except in the summer of 1992, there was no newspaper to read. The Teamsters struck the Pittsburgh Press on May 17 of that year, shutting down both dailies under the joint operating agreement. The Press never recovered, eventually being acquired by and then folded into the surviving Post-Gazette. The greatest Pirates team most of us will ever see played most of its final act in a city that couldn’t read about it.

That team deserves to be remembered, and the current one, built around back-to-back Cy Young winner Paul Skenes and all-everything prospect Konnor Griffin, could generate its own version of those memories. What Van Slyke told me, though, was a warning: When you’re close, spend the money, because the window doesn’t hold itself open for small-market teams in a sport without a salary cap.

The title years

Van Slyke arrived in Pittsburgh in April 1987, traded from the Cardinals for masterful defensive catcher Tony Peña. He’d been to the 1985 World Series with St. Louis and knew what winning looked like. By 1988, he was hitting .288 with 25 home runs, 100 RBIs, and 15 triples (most in the majors), finishing fourth in NL MVP voting — he should’ve won it — and winning the first of five consecutive Gold Gloves.

Advertise with us

From 1987 through 1992, Van Slyke accumulated 30.0 WAR (the number of wins the player gave his team compared with an average replacement), a six-year peak that compares favorably to enshrined outfielders. His 1992 alone produced 6.9 WAR: a .324 average, 199 hits and 45 doubles, both tops in the NL. Career total: 41.3 WAR (more than Pirates Hall of Famer Dave Parker), zero Hall of Fame votes.

But Van Slyke told me he doesn’t dwell on individual accolades. “When I look back on seasons, I look at the great moments,” he said. “Winning the division in this city with that bunch of guys — that’s what baseball’s all about.”

The Pirates won three straight NL East titles from 1990 to 1992 and lost three straight NLCS matchups. The 1991 series against Atlanta, which was incredible television for a 9-year-old, featured three 1-0 finishes, four shutouts, and a Game 7 at Three Rivers where Braves pitcher John Smoltz shut Pittsburgh out 4-0.

The losses

The 1992 series still stings. The Pirates trailed 3-1, stormed back, and carried a 2-0 lead into the bottom of the ninth of Game 7 with Doug Drabek dealing. Terry Pendleton doubled. José Lind booted a ground ball. Francisco Cabrera singled to left. Sid Bream, the former Pirate, slid home safe. Van Slyke sat motionless in center field.

“Being up like that and having your best starting pitcher on the mound,” Van Slyke said, “you figure the game’s over. Then your Gold Glove second baseman makes an error on a play he makes 999 times out of a thousand. When you give major league teams an extra out, bad things happen.”

Advertise with us

He knew it was over. Barry Bonds, the MVP and best player in baseball, was a free agent. Drabek, the 1990 Cy Young winner, was a free agent. (Bobby Bonilla had landed an insanely generous contract from the New York Mets a year earlier, one that will continue paying him until 2035).

“The writing was on the wall,” Van Slyke said. “We knew that was our last shot.”

I asked if the Pirates could have kept them, investing in the city’s future before the big money really ruined the sport. “Absolutely,” he said. “The fact that they didn’t even try really bothered me. It was disingenuous to say they were going to continue to build the team and then not do it.” Twenty consecutive losing seasons followed.

The possible future

Today’s Pirates have a Bonds-level pillar in Skenes. They added Marcell Ozuna and Brandon Lowe to address the worst offense in the league.

Van Slyke had advice for the front office: “If you have enough pitching, go out and get guys who can drive in runs. There’s no more patience. You’ve got to sign a few guys if you really want to take a shot, because a shot is all you’ll ever get in Pittsburgh.”

Advertise with us

The Penguins won back-to-back Stanley Cups in 1991 and 1992, yet skating held no appeal for me and I can barely remember their on-ice excellence. What I remember is Van Slyke robbing line drives in the vast gap at Three Rivers, a concrete multipurpose stadium where I also watched the Steelers and the monster truck Bigfoot in the 1980s.

Today’s kids deserve that, albeit with PNC Park’s gorgeous sightlines in lieu of Three Rivers’ cavernous, character-free setting. (The awful artificial turf there and in St. Louis, Van Slyke told me, surely contributed to his two later-life hip replacements). They deserve their own Van Slyke, their own Game 7, their own beautiful, ruinous near-miss that they carry for 30 years. The window is open right now. Perhaps the current team can hold it in place for a while.

Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page who writes every other Thursday, is a historian, journalist and author of the Substack “Oliver Bateman Does the Work.” He lives in Pittsburgh. His previous article was “Will Pittsburgh’s baseball future be the past?.”