WASHINGTON —
Behind a podium in a congressional meeting room carrying a sign reading, “Melt ICE now,” Rep. Summer Lee made clear her position on funding the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency.
“We’ve heard about the abuses and the concentration camps,” said Lee, surrounded by activists and some congressional colleagues. “There is no reforming this. … We have to dismantle the tools that have enabled this.”
Lee, D-Swissvale, has emerged as one of the fiercest congressional opponents of the Trump administration agency whose masked officers killed two people in Minneapolis and have deported U.S. citizens and children in addition to those here illegally.
“I don’t believe that we should keep an agency that is inherently founded on values that I do not share, that so many people within our country do not share, around immigration, immigration reform, and immigration enforcement,” Lee said in an interview in her congressional office.
The wrong call?
But calls to “defund ICE” rather than overhaul the agency may remind voters of the unpopular call to “defund the police” following the death of George Floyd while in Minneapolis police custody six years ago.
Read More
Democrats struggled to explain that they didn’t want to shut police departments. They said they meant the term as a shorthand way to advocate increased spending on social programs to improve communities, rather than only hiring more officers. They claimed their policies would make law enforcement more effective than just swelling the ranks of police.
Republicans, though, seized on the phrase to brand Democrats as anti-police. It worked. The GOP gained 12 U.S. House seats in the 2020 election, even as Democrat Joe Biden won the presidency.
“Whether you talk about defunding the police or defunding ICE, it’s the same thing. It will be used against us,” said Rep. Henry Cuellar, D-Texas. “You don’t have law and order without police, you don’t kick out criminal aliens without ICE. Absolutely, we need to make some changes but to abolish or defund ICE, that will be wrong. And certainly, it’s a wrong policy, but it is wrong politics also.”
Democratic Rep. Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey responded to the defund the police rhetoric before the 2022 midterms by seeking more money for local law enforcement. Now he is seeking new standards to address the worse abuses of ICE, including body cameras, uniform and ID standards, and better training.
“What this administration is doing and going around at churches and schools and restaurants and rounding up innocent undocumented immigrants and rounding up citizens is completely unacceptable,” he said. “The answer is to have the appropriate standards and do it right. I think that’s what my colleagues should be stressing.”
A popular stand?
That’s not stopping congressional Republicans from planning a reprise from the old songbook as polls show their majorities at risk.
“The radical ‘abolish ICE’ crusade from far-left Democrats seemed like a relic of the past, but it’s the brand-new litmus test for Democrats who are barely hanging on and begging on their knees to get approval from their socialist base,” said Mike Marinella, a spokesman for the National Republican Congressional Committee.
But so far, polls show Americans overwhelmingly opposing ICE after its agents killed U.S. citizens Renee Nicole Good and Alex Pretti on the streets of Minneapolis.
That issue currently favors Democrats, but support could evaporate if the party is seen as out of the mainstream, warned Muhlenberg College political science professor Christopher Borick.
“The smart and safe position is to be targeting the unpopular aspects of ICE,” Borick said. “Call for change in leadership, call for a refocus of energy on border security. You have the high ground. Don’t lose the high ground by strategic moves that place you out on a limb more than you need to be.”
In a Washington Post-ABC News-Ipsos poll released this week, Americans opposed ICE tactics by 62% to 31%. And just 28% of Americans in the Post/ABC poll said that most or nearly all of those being deported were violent criminals. By contrast, 70% said less than half or hardly any were.
In an NPR/PBS News/Marist College poll released earlier this month, 65% of Americans said ICE had gone too far in enforcing immigration laws. Only 34% said the agency’s actions were about right or needed to be increased. And by 62% to 37%, they said ICE’s actions were making them less safe, rather than more safe.
Better ways?
In fact, ICE’s actions have made it so unpopular that calls for defunding the agency aren’t out of line, said Ross Baker, a political science professor at Rutgers University.
“ICE has dug itself a very deep hole,” he said. “This is an issue that plays overwhelmingly for the Democrats. The raids were heavy-handed and indiscriminate and provided a lot of footage of negative ads against Republican candidates.”
And Lee argued that there’s nothing sacrosanct about ICE. “We do not have to be a prisoner to institutions as they are conceived and used today,” Lee said. “For me, a starting point is, what do we actually want, what policies do we value, believe in, that we want to implement.”
She added: “I believe fundamentally, that there are different ways and better ways that we can navigate this.”
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. A contributing writer for the editorial page, he writes every other Friday. His previous article was “Mr. Shapiro goes on the campaign trail (for president).”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.