Mark Twain could really turn a phrase. Here’s one occasionally attributed to him that he didn’t turn: “History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes.”
Its exact derivation is unclear and really doesn’t matter here. What matters is that “Walz” and “Wallace” — two rogue Democratic governors, Tim and George — rhyme in American history.
Three racist governors
My earliest memories of television news date back to the 1950s and 1960s. Before they were supplanted by the visuals of the Vietnam War, those memories largely related to the federal government’s battle in southern states to enforce the Supreme Court’s decision in Brown v. Board of Education.
In the late 1950s, the battle crystallized in Arkansas, where Democratic Gov. Orval Faubus resisted Republican President Dwight D. Eisenhower’s insistence that Black students be admitted to Little Rock’s previously white high school. Eisenhower invoked the Insurrection Act, federalized the Arkansas National Guard, and sent the 101st Airborne Division to Little Rock. The federal law was enforced.
Not to be outdone, Mississippi’s Democratic Gov. Ross Barnett opposed Black student James Meredith’s admission to the University of Mississippi. In 1962, Democratic President John F. Kennedy invoked the Insurrection Act, federalized the state’s National Guard, and deployed troops to enforce federal law and ensure Meredith’s enrollment.
Alabama’s Democratic Gov. George Wallace also resisted enforcement of federal law when Black students sought to be admitted to the University of Alabama. In 1963, President Kennedy again invoked the Insurrection Act, and federalized the National Guard. The students ultimately were admitted.
In 1965, it was Democratic President Lyndon B. Johnson’s turn to cross swords with Wallace. After “Bloody Sunday,” when voting rights marchers were attacked by Alabama state police, Johnson invoked the Insurrection Act and federalized the National Guard. The marchers were protected.
Are you getting the sense that these Democratic governors were not fully invested in our constitutional republic? Maybe they didn’t teach McColluch v. Maryland in the American South.
That unanimous decision of the United States Supreme Court, decided in 1819, affirmed that the national government indeed held sovereign power over the various states. Article VI of the Constitution means what it says. Federal law is “the supreme Law of the Land.”
And now we’re faced with state and local officials — most prominently Democratic Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz and Democratic Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey — who incite mobs to undermine enforcement of federal immigration law.
Walz has described the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement presence as an “occupation” and stated that Minnesota is effectively “at war” with the federal government. He says we’re approaching “a Fort Sumter moment,” referencing the 1861 start of the American Civil War.
And he described ICE agents as “Donald Trump’s modern-day Gestapo.” Frey told ICE officers to “get the [expletive] out of Minneapolis” and called for an immediate end to ICE operations.
Proud Democrats
Governors Faubus, Barnett and Wallace would be so, so proud of them.
In my lifetime, the Insurrection Act of 1807 has been invoked 10 times. The statute doesn’t provide a strict definition of insurrection. Rather, it leaves large discretion to the president of the United States to decide when to federalize a state’s national guard or to deploy the military domestically.
It’s a straightforward question: Do conditions on the ground undermine the ability of the United States to enforce its laws? If the answer is yes, the Insurrection Act can lawfully be invoked.
Western Pennsylvania plays a central role in our understanding of the Insurrection Act. It turns out that our late 18th Century forebears did not take well to the new federal excise tax on distilled spirits.
The Whiskey Rebellion was suppressed by President George Washington under a precursor to the Insurrection Act. He mobilized state militias from several states. For part of the trek, he personally led 13,000 troops as they advanced toward the rebellious Pennsylvania counties. The Whiskey Rebellion collapsed.
Trump has not invoked the Insurrection Act to deploy the military to Minnesota or to federalize the National Guard. But conditions on the ground clearly impede the ability of the federal officers to enforce the nation’s immigration laws.
Nor did he invoke the Act during 2020’s “summer of love” that destroyed billions of dollars in property and took lives in major U.S. cities. There was precedent for such a use.
In 1967, President Johnson invoked the Insurrection Act and deployed the 82nd Airborne Division to quell the Detroit riots triggered by alleged police brutality and racism. In 1968, President Johnson again invoked the Insurrection Act, federalized the National Guard, and deployed federal troops to multiple cities across the country to address the violent reaction to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s assassination.
More restrained than Eisenhower
Could it be that Trump is a man of great restraint? More likely, since goading Trump into a forceful response is the obvious goal of the “resistance,” he wishes not to fuel the Gestapo narrative heading into important mid-term elections.
Yet one wonders how Presidents Eisenhower, Kennedy and Johnson would advise him to act.
My guess is that they would have invoked the Insurrection Act and deployed the 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions to Minneapolis and other cities as necessary. And George Washington? He would have led the charge of federalized state militias to the Twin Cities.
As for Gov. Walz and Mayor Frey, here’s a piece of advice that is indeed attributable to Mark Twain: “It’s better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt.”
Peter Kalis was, before his retirement, chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates, and is now an independent commentator. A contributing writer to the editorial page, he writes every other Monday. His previous article was “Donald Trump wants to preserve the Europe worth preserving.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.