Though higher education is still among the most admired sectors in America, right up there with churches, small business owners and the military, people’s trust in its value has declined in the last two decades. Many think it doesn’t pay off any more, that it’s not worth the time, cost and energy compared with other forms of training and education.
As the president of the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities of Pennsylvania, someone who studies higher education, I want to argue that it is worth the time, cost and energy, for three reasons. (A list of member schools in western Pennsylvania appears below.)
Higher income
First, higher education translates into higher income. The average person with a bachelor’s degree earns 70% more than someone with a high school diploma, as reported in The Atlantic. If college were a stock, it would still be the hottest stock on Wall Street.
According to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, a college degree generates an annual return of 12% to 14% over the course of a career. The R.O.I. of a degree beats the stock market, bonds, real estate, and is even a better investment than gold.
Despite sensational headlines about sky-high tuition, most Americans are actually paying less in tuition today than 10 years ago. For context, over a lifetime of spending, you will probably spend five times more on cars than on education. And unlike a car, designed for planned obsolescence and which begins to depreciate the moment you drive it off the lot, a college education is a one-time expenditure that increases in value over time.
It is well-documented that a college degree is still the best vehicle for upward economic mobility in America — and America’s economy is fueled by the innovations and inventions pioneered at American colleges and universities.
More informed citizens
Second, higher education is about far more than income. The founders of our country knew the civic value of education, and the good citizenship of grads is reflected in the data. College grads are more likely to start a business, more likely to vote, and more likely to donate to and volunteer at local charities.
This, of course, is not to say that only college graduates do these things, but the correlation between these things and education is clearest. Perhaps in anticipating these societal benefits, many of the signers of the Declaration of Independence supported higher education, seeing it’s value in preparing citizens for what Alexis de Tocqueville called the difficult tasks of self-government — reason, deliberation, tolerance.
Consistent with this belief, America’s Founding Fathers also founded some of our country’s first colleges and universities, like the University of Virginia, and in Pennsylvania Franklin (now Franklin and Marshall), Dickinson and Penn.
Discerning and synthesizing
Third, in an A.I. age of information overload, the world needs people who can discern, dissect, and synthesize quality information. Consider these figures: You see more information in one day than your ancestors saw in a lifetime.
You even have more words to learn and work with today than William Shakespeare did 400 years ago, as the English language has expanded to perhaps as many as a million words. In fact, 400 “exabytes” of data are generated every day — that’s 80 times more information than all the words ever spoken by humankind.
Some of that knowledge will cure cancer, and some of it is slop. A sound education is critical to developing the filters and perception necessary to see the difference.
Information technology has transformed our world into a landscape where an “arms race” exists between facts and disinformation and where algorithms fan the fires of conflict by filtering us into warring camps and away from the spaces of civil discourse. The “attention economy” captures our minds and robs us of our time for reflection and contemplation, replacing the serendipity of silence with the empty stare of the doom scroller.
How might we respond to all of this? By practicing the skills developed in every postsecondary education environment: listening, researching, evaluating, validating, verifying, talking and listening again in conversations with friends, through interactions with strangers, by exchanges with real human beings, not just computer-generated algorithms.
Mastering the future
Those who choose to pursue the hard work of education and critical thinking can best master the technologies of the future and not just be subject to them. Higher education not only trains people for jobs that don’t exist yet, but it also helps grads develop the cognitive strength and flexibility to develop new skillsets throughout their lives.
This matters — the days of having only one job for a lifetime are in the far distant past; young people today face a future where they will have over a dozen different jobs before they retire. Jobs change, industries change, technologies change.
Learning how to learn and instilling a drive for lifelong learning — whether that is a new hobby, new language, or a new skill, are hallmarks of higher education in America. With these skills, Americans can navigate anything.
Thomas P. Foley is president of the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities of Pennsylvania. His previous article was “Pell grants make America stronger.”
Western Pennsylvania members of AICUP are Allegheny, Carlow, Carnegie Mellon, Chatham, Duquesne, Gannon, Geneva, Grove City, LaRoche, Mercyhurst, Mount Aloysius, Robert Morris, St. Francis, St. Vincent, Seton Hill, Washington and Jefferson, Waynesburg and Westminster.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.