Pittsburgh has long wrestled with its size, topography and aging infrastructure. Taken together, these realities often complicate large-scale, low-cost housing and development strategies that work in faster-growing Sun Belt cities.

Yet those same constraints can become a strength with right approach. Transit Oriented Development (TOD), combined with Pennsylvania’s Transit Revitalization Investment District (TRID) financing strategy, stands out as particularly well suited to the city’s physical and economic realities.

TOD is a planning approach that clusters housing, offices, retail and civic spaces within walking distance of high-quality public transit. The central idea is to build compact, mixed-use neighborhoods around transit stations so residents can meet daily needs without relying on cars.

TRIDs take this concept further by using the future tax revenues generated within a designated area to fund TOD-related infrastructure and development. Rather than requiring upfront public subsidies, TRIDs allow growth to pay for itself — supporting job creation, expanding the city’s tax base, improving transit infrastructure and attracting private investment.

Advertise with us

Most importantly, this model protects taxpayers by ensuring cities are not committing money they don’t yet have, while still giving developers the confidence to build projects that generate long-term economic and community benefits.

This approach is primarily a land-use and transportation strategy. Affordable or low-income housing is not an automatic outcome of TOD, but can be achieved when cities pair it with zoning, financing and policy tools that incentivize affordability.

Winners and losers

TOD is not without controversy. When market demand is strong and safeguards are weak, development near transit can accelerate gentrification. Housing prices and rents often rise faster than incomes, pushing low- and moderate-income households away from the very transit access meant to help them.

Pittsburgh has seen this firsthand. East Liberty offers both a cautionary tale and a model of TOD. Once a symbol of disinvestment, this neighborhood has been reshaped over the past two decades by development tied closely to the East Busway. Since the late 1990s, more than $900 million in new construction has occurred around the station area, anchored by projects like the Home Depot redevelopment and followed by grocery stores, offices, apartment buildings and Bakery Square.

The results have been economically transformative but not without cost. According to a five-year TOD evaluation report developed by PRT, from 2013 to 2018, housing growth and income gains in the East Liberty Station’s surroundings significantly outpaced countywide averages, while rising home values and rents displaced many long-time Black residents and increased the number of cost-burdened renters in the corridor.

Advertise with us

East Liberty is, in many ways, a victim of its own success.

These outcomes underscore a central truth about TOD. It works economically, but it must be guided deliberately. A growing body of research shows that when TOD is planned with equity in mind through mixed-income housing, strong community benefits agreements and robust institutional oversight, it can expand access to jobs and opportunity while reducing combined housing and transportation costs.

The goal today is not economic growth at any cost, but equitable TOD that ensures equity, fiscal responsibility, and long-term public benefit.

Combined strategy

For Pittsburgh, the case for TOD as a citywide strategy is especially compelling. Expanding outward with new roads and utilities is costly and inefficient, particularly in a city defined by challenging terrain and long-standing fiscal constraints.

At the same time, the city’s largest employment centers are already well-served by transit. Downtown and Oakland, home to tens of thousands of jobs, plus universities, and hospitals, are now connected by bus rapid transit, creating a corridor through Uptown with enormous potential for TOD.

Advertise with us

Importantly, TOD is not just a tool for already amenity-rich neighborhoods. It can extend opportunity to historically underserved communities such as Homewood, Uptown, Carrick, Sheraden and Beechview, where high-frequency transit service already exists and the conditions for future growth are strong.

It also depends on supportive zoning, specifically TOD overlay districts that encourage private investment by streamlining permitting and allowing denser development to make projects cost-effective. Development near high-quality transit consistently attracts stronger demand and higher value, and when paired with TRID financing, TOD overlays can create a positive and compelling investment environment.

Perfect for Pittsburgh

Under the leadership of the Urban Redevelopment Authority, Pittsburgh has already demonstrated the power of this approach. In East Liberty and Bakery Square, TRID-supported TOD helped catalyze private investment that now generates significant tax revenue, while the Esplanade project on the North Side is following a similar path. Together, these examples highlight TOD-TRID as a durable model for successful public-private partnership.

If Pittsburgh can encourage transit-oriented growth in thriving, amenity-rich neighborhoods while making sustained, intentional investments in communities that have long been overlooked, it can grow in a way that is both more balanced and more just.

Equitable TOD shows that growth does not have to mean displacement, and progress does not have to come at the expense of inclusion. With proper management and guiding policies, it can unlock opportunity where markets are weak while responsibly managing growth where demand is strong. This approach can help build a Pittsburgh where mobility becomes a source of dignity and prosperity reaches those who need it most.

Panini A. Chowdhury is a professional planner specializing in infrastructure planning. He also serves as a gubernatorial appointee to the Pennsylvania Pedalcycle & Pedestrian Advisory Committee. This article reflects his personal views only.