Pittsburgh faces a $30 million deficit heading into 2026, prompting City Council to raise property taxes by 20%, the first increase in eleven years. Unfortunately for Pittsburgh residents, this terrible math isn’t another all-too-common UPMC billing error. Already-harried homeowners being nickeled and dimed by persistent inflation will pay an additional $160 annually per $100,000 of assessed value (minus the homestead exemption).
Add Allegheny County's 36% tax increase approved last year and Pittsburgh Public Schools’ 2% approved this month, and residents face a triple squeeze: county, city and school district all reaching deeper into so many pockets you’ll need to switch cargo shorts, to reuse a line about the IRS authored by the late Youngstown congressman and Pitt Panthers quarterback James Traficant.
Meanwhile, the "Big Five" nonprofits — UPMC, University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon, Highmark/AHN and Duquesne — hold $4.3 billion in tax-exempt property and pay virtually nothing toward city services. If taxed at normal rates, they would owe Pittsburgh $41.6 million annually, more than enough to eliminate the deficit entirely. City Controller Rachael Heisler has proposed a voluntary payment system targeting these institutions. The proposal has unsurprisingly gone nowhere.
‘Purely public charity’
The usual objections arrive on schedule. Pennsylvania's constitution protects "institutions of purely public charity" under the five-prong HUP test established in 1985. Mayor Luke Ravenstahl sued UPMC over its exemptions in 2013; Mayor Bill Peduto dropped the lawsuit in 2014, calling it unlikely to succeed. Mayor Ed Gainey's property-by-property challenges since 2023 have recovered just $94,000 annually against $247,000 in legal fees, yet another net loss for a Gainey administration that produced few gains.
All of this talk of legal obstacles is the loser talk of a political class that, like Mike Tomlin’s Steelers, has become accustomed to the toothless status quo. Pittsburgh collects just $1.07 per capita in PILOT (Payment In Lieu Of Taxes) payments, the voluntary contributions nonprofits make to offset their tax exemptions. Erie collects $13.39 per capita. The difference? UPMC pays 50% of would-be property taxes to Erie and Altoona.
By contrast, Boston has found a way to get $35.7 million in cash annually from its nonprofits under a formula requesting 25% of what property taxes would be. Providence, R.I., negotiated $223.5 million over 20 years from four universities in 2023. Former Controller Michael Lamb observed the obvious: "The idea that they're just not going to do it, we know that's not true because they already do it."
Even as these institutions avoid taxation, they pay wages that trap employees in poverty. UPMC's minimum wage reached $18 per hour in 2025, still 19% below Pittsburgh's $22.21 living wage. In 2014, Chaney Lewis, a UPMC patient transport worker, told organizers he made just $11.97 per hour after nine years of specialized work. Roughly 60% of surveyed UPMC workers owe medical debt to their own employer. Beam me up, as the aforementioned Congressman Traficant would say.
Free-riding leviathans
Meanwhile, conditions grew bad enough at Pitt that staff unionized in September 2024, with 69% voting yes. Organizing committee member Kathleen Madonna-Emmerling explained that "many staff at Pitt are rapidly losing ground as the costs of housing, transportation, child care and health care increase much faster than wages."
Graduate students earning $20,600 to $34,515 in stipends voted 97% to unionize two months later. Tenured professors there earn good money, but most lecturers and staff are stuck with bad wages and an ever-dwindling number of benefits.
I was one of those graduate students a decade ago, earning barely half of today’s stipend, but while eggs were cheaper in 2012, the sub-standard wage was no more livable. The paltry salary of a program coordinator in one of the university’s highly-ranked departments two years ago showed that little had changed (other than Pitt chancellor Joan Gabel’s salary, recently raised 33% to $1.25 million).
It is high time we admitted that these free-riding leviathans are not charitable institutions distributing beneficent surplus to our community but rather extractive enterprises whose workers cannot afford to rent much less buy in Pittsburgh’s “awesome” real estate market.
Shifting the burden
What levers remain? City Council could tie zoning approvals and development permits to PILOT agreements. State legislators could introduce bills requiring nonprofits above certain asset thresholds to make baseline payments. Allegheny County could coordinate with Pittsburgh rather than allowing UPMC to play governments against each other, as reportedly happened when Mayor Gainey's tentative $12.5 million deal collapsed because UPMC demanded the county share the burden.
Public transparency would help: regular reporting on who pays what, modeled on Boston's compliance reports, would at least clarify the stakes.
A 25% PILOT agreement with the Big Five would generate over $10 million for the city annually. At 50%, the figure rises to $21 million. These numbers would not solve everything, but they would ease further tax increases on the paycheck-to-paycheck middle class of homeowners while ensuring some sort of budget stability.
But perhaps I’m thinking too big and we need to “get small,” to borrow the title of that hit Steve Martin comedy record from the 1970s. During December's heaviest snowfall in three years, 37 of Pittsburgh's 103 snow vehicles sat broken. Streets in Lincoln Place and Carrick remained covered in nigh-undriveable “cobblestone ice” three days after the storm. The city needs 180 trucks and operates around 100.
Perhaps UPMC and Pitt and Carnegie Mellon can pool their megabucks and buy us some snowplows. Our outgoing mayor certainly couldn't find a way to do it.
Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page, is a historian, widely published journalist and author of the Substack, “Oliver Bateman Does the Work.” He lives in Pittsburgh. His previous column was “What Pittsburgh Public Schools owe their city.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.