In the wake of the election of a communist and Islamist as Mayor of New York City — remarkably flying under the banner of the Democratic Party — and Senator Chuck Schumer’s capitulation to the demands of the far left in his party to shut down the government, it’s easy to be pessimistic about the future of Democrats as a party.
It would be customary at this point to say “I take no pleasure” in announcing this verdict. But this is not a matter of personal pleasure or displeasure. The question is whether the Democratic Party can be trusted with the country’s future.
A history of failures
For two centuries, with notable exceptions, the Democratic Party has failed the American people in ways that are often lost in the partisan times in which we live. And its failures continue to this day.
This is the party of slavery in the nineteenth century and Jim Crow in the twentieth, and it is the Party that in my adult lifetime elected a former member of the Ku Klux Klan to serve as its Senate Majority Leader.
This is the party whose iconic president, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, invited U.S. Olympians from the 1936 Berlin Olympics to celebrate at the White House. The Black Olympians, however, were not invited, even though they won over half of the country’s track and field medals.
Jesse Owens, who courageously put to rest Hitler’s views of a “superior Aryan race” as the Fuhrer menacingly watched, later said: “Hitler didn’t snub me — it was our President who snubbed me. The President didn’t even send me a telegram.” Owens won four gold medals in Berlin.
This is the party whose President Lyndon Baines Johnson sent large numbers of my contemporaries to death or injury in Vietnam, or had them return with post traumatic stress disorder, and for no reason other than the care and feeding of his immense ego.
This is the party that in the 1970s embraced national malaise as an endemic condition among Americans and concluded more recently that secular stagnation and not growth-driven prosperity is our economic future.
This is the party that celebrates skin color, gender and sexual orientation over merit and believes that boys and men should compete in sports against girls and women and should be allowed to invade their private spaces.
This is the party that adopted an open border policy allowing entry of millions of unvetted illegal immigrants into our country, including criminals, mental incompetents and suspected terrorists, and that now resists attempts to restore regular order to our immigration policy and to address crime on our city streets.
And continuing failures
This is the party that in 2024 advanced a presidential candidate who had withdrawn from primary elections in 2020 without a single Democrat casting a vote in her favor. Party elites anointed her in 2024 without the benefit of primary elections or an open convention allowing Party members to express a view.
This is the party that covered up the mental incapacity of a sitting President so that his wife and a cabal of leftist staffers could run the country and brandish an auto pen with impunity, including the signing of a large number of last minute preemptive Presidential pardons.’
This is the party whose weakness led to wars in Europe and the Middle East, whose support of Israel against Islamist evil has been tepid, and whose Congressional ranks include the so-called Hamas Caucus. It’s the Party that authored a winning strategy for Iran by supplying that murderous regime with billions of dollars in cash and a pathway to nuclear weaponry.
And this is the party that passed on the razor-sharp Governor of Pennsylvania Josh Shapiro as Vice President in 2024 in favor of a far-left nitwit from Minnesota — the Party’s antisemitic wing clearly would not approve of a Jewish vice presidential nominee — and that now seeks to marginalize the highly principled and able Senator John Fetterman.
The Democratic party is lost. Shapiro and Fetterman should mend any tear in their own relationship and with others consider launching a new center-left party. Communists, antisemites and open border zealots need not apply. With the radical left’s takeover of the Democratic Party, there’s already a party for them.
If not a new party, they should consider forming an organization equivalent to the Democratic Leadership Council, which was created in 1985 after the leftist drift of the Democratic Party in the prior fifteen years. The DLC had a lot to do with the election in 1992 of a center-left candidate named Bill Clinton.
Who is to blame for the Democratic Party’s state of affairs? There are legions of blameworthy individuals over the decades, both living and dead. But assigning blame is a waste of time and energy.
What the country needs
This country needs two responsible parties. As now led, and with its problematic history, the Democratic Party has disqualified itself from that role.
Should Republicans gloat? That would be laughable. The Republican Party has its own challenges and fissures to address. It can start with MAGA’s own flirtation with antisemitism and what Ted Cruz calls the rise on the right of “bilious bigotry and rage.”
Democrats, for the good of the country, please take a deep breath. Reflect on what your Party has become. And perhaps listen to the advice of an old Greek. No, not this one. Another one — the one who said: “The unexamined life is not worth living.”
Peter Kalis was, before his retirement, chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates, and is now an independent commentator. He writes every other Monday. His previous article was “The danger of building with BRICS.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.