WASHINGTON — In her new book, “Antisemitism, An American Tradition,” American University professor and historian Pamela Nadell says one incident stands out.
“This is a post-Tree of Life book,” she said last week during a discussion with former U.S. Sen. Benjamin Cardin, D-Md., in the nation’s capital.
Nadell, who sits on The Tree of Life’s academic advisory council, said the Oct. 27, 2018, murder of 11 worshippers at the building housing three Pittsburgh congregations led her to write the book.
Far-reaching impact
She said the impact of the shooting reached far beyond Pittsburgh.
“That trauma echoed across American Jewry, because as American Jews we never thought we would live to see murder in a synagogue on a Shabbat morning in this country,” she told me a few days after her discussion with Cardin.
But it continues to be felt most deeply in the Steel City.
Read More
“The murders at the Tree of Life had a devastating impact on the Jewish community — one that had always seen itself as living in a safe neighborhood surrounded by friends and allies,” said Squirrel Hill native Joel Rubin, executive director of the Jewish Electorate Institute.
A few months after the massacre, Nadell said her “little circle of historians of the American Jewish experience” began meeting every month and discussing what had happened in Pittsburgh.
“We asked ourselves the question: How have we missed this story?” she said.
Nadell said it had been three decades since the last good volume had been published on antisemitism in America, and as she toured the country promoting her last book, on Jewish women in the U.S., she asked audiences if they encountered antisemitism.
“I was shocked at the way the stories poured out,” she said. “They poured out with anguish and angst as if they had happened yesterday instead of sometimes 50 years ago, and it proved to me that encountering anti-Semitism left deep marks of trauma in people's lives.”
And then came the worst antisemitic attack in U.S. history.
‘Shocking, shocking event’
“Pittsburgh's the first time Jews were murdered in their house of worship in the U.S. that I know of,” she said. “I don't think there's some other example, and it was such a shocking, shocking event.”
The shooter, Robert Bowers, subscribed to the so-called great replacement theory, which posits that Jews and others are bringing in non-white immigrants illegally to replace white Christians.
Right-wing media firebrand Tucker Carlson broadcasts that theory. So did the late conservative activist Charlie Kirk, who was murdered last month.
That’s also what the neo-Nazis and white supremacists marching in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017 meant when they chanted, “Jews will not replace us.”
The book itself chronicles antisemitism in the U.S. since colonial days. One of the stops on her book tour was at Carnegie Mellon University last Sunday at an event sponsored by The Tree of Life, which is turning the Squirrel Hill building where the massacre took place into a memorial, museum, a center for Jewish life and a place to combat hate and antisemitism.
Pre-Pittsburgh, Nadell named the bombing of an Atlanta synagogue in 1958 as an example of violence against American Jews, and the lynching of Leo Frank in 1915 in Atlanta after being convicted of murdering a 13-year old girl as crowds outside the courtroom screamed, “Hang the Jew.”
And a white supremacist and neo-Nazi tried to shoot up the U.S. Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C., in 2009 but was stopped after killing a special police officer protecting the building.
After Pittsburgh, though, violent attacks against Jews came in rapid succession. Six months later, in April 2019, a gunman killed one person at a synagogue in Poway, Calif. Then in December of that year, three people were killed during a shootout at a Jersey City, N.J., supermarket. And in Monsey, N.Y., five people were slashed at a Hasidic rabbi’s house; one later died of the wounds.
“For the Jewish world, those city names have become metonyms for violence in places where Jews were murdered, either at religious services or in prayer, or in the case of Jersey City in the kosher supermarket,” she said.
From Oct. 27 to Oct. 7
And of course there was Oct. 7, 2023, when Hamas, designated as a terrorist group by the U.S., attacked Israel, killing 1,200 people. The subsequent war led to a spike in antisemitism here and around the world.
Some supporters of the Palestinian cause turned to violence. Two Israeli embassy employees were gunned down on a street in the nation’s capital.
One person died after Molotov cocktails were thrown at participants in a peaceful demonstration in Boulder, Colo., in support of the hostages taken by Hamas. A fire was set at the governor’s mansion in Harrisburg after Gov. Josh Shapiro and his family had gone to sleep.
All of the perpetrators backed the Palestinians in the war with Hamas.
“I think 10/27 leads into what happened on 10/7,” NadeII said. “There are people who are saying Oct. 7 is a watershed in American Jewish life. It is certainly a watershed in Israel. What happens in Israel reflects upon the Jewish community around the world.”
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. He writes every other Friday. His previous article was, “New funding means you’ll still see a lot of Rep. Thompson on C-SPAN.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.