Last week, when I arrived at Congregation Beth Shalom in Squirrel Hill on Yom Kippur morning, the holiest day of the Jewish year, I was greeted with devastating news. My congregants, who know that I abstain from the use of digital devices on the Sabbath and holidays, told me about the terrorist attack at a synagogue in Manchester, England, resulting in the deaths of two worshippers and the wounding of several others.

This attack is yet another painful and tragic event for Jewish people everywhere, and our Pittsburgh Jewish community understands and feels antisemitic violence more than any other American community. But whether in Pittsburgh or Paris, Tehran or Tel Aviv, Jews feel attacked as a people whenever terrorists strike Jewish institutions.

The undeniable fact

Every Jewish building in the Pittsburgh area has implemented on-site security since October 27, 2018, when a home-grown terrorist murdered 11 Jewish people at prayer in Squirrel Hill. European synagogues have employed security infrastructure for decades, due to ongoing threats there.

When I visited the Neve Shalom Synagogue in Istanbul in 1999, a building which had been bombed during Sabbath services twice prior, the security apparatus was far beyond anything I had seen before or since. I surrendered my passport and submitted to a pat-down. We need security because of the undeniable fact that there are people out there whose intent is to kill Jews, wherever they are.

Advertise with us

Two years ago, on October 7th, 2023, Hamas terrorists invaded Israel, killing nearly 1200 people and taking 250 hostages. The surprise attack fell on the Jewish holiday of Simḥat Torah, one of the most joyous days of the year, when Jewish people celebrate the gift of Torah by dancing and singing and parading our Torah scrolls around our synagogues. It was a cataclysmic failure of Israel’s own security forces, and a day that will never be forgotten.

The Jewish people have a long memory for such horrible events; we have had many in our history, and we still mark several of them. Just one example: on the ninth day of the Jewish month of Av in 586 BCE, the Babylonian Empire under King Nebuchadnezzar destroyed the First Temple in Jerusalem, the name of which comes from the Hebrew for “City of Peace.” Every August, when this day comes up again, we fast and mourn for a full 25 hours.

Unfolding history

That is how Jewish history has unfolded over the last few thousand years. We have been persecuted, exiled, welcomed, exiled again, oppressed, welcomed again, massacred, and so on. The Romans destroyed the Second Temple in the City of Peace in 70 CE and exiled the Jews to the four corners of the world. The Crusades brought murder and misery to Jews of the Rhineland in the 12th century and beyond.

The Spanish Inquisition, the Farhud, the Holocaust — the October 7 attack is not a new phenomenon. Our people have lived with deadly anti-Jewish hatred for millennia.

Antisemitic attacks, in England, America, and elsewhere, have been increasing in frequency and intensity for decades. And they have skyrocketed in the last two years. The Jewish people were attacked on October 7th, and since then we have been targeted again and again, all over the world.

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania’s Jewish governor, Josh Shapiro, was targeted in April. A month later, Jews were firebombed and murdered in Washington and Boulder, Colorado, and those are only the headlines. Every graffiti incident, every time someone shouts “Free Palestine” at a group of people simply calling for the hostages to be returned, every time a politician cannot quite denounce globalizing the Intifada, we all feel threatened, and we retreat a little bit further.

America has been very good to us. For a few decades in the middle of the 20th century, we felt safe and welcomed here. So too England, France, and many other diasporic places where Jews live today.

Thank God, Israel will remain a safe haven for the Jewish people. But what Hamas did to the Jewish psyche two years ago has permanently undone the sense of security that we once felt, and this fills me with sadness and anxiety.

A resilient people

We are a resilient people, who have stubbornly and proudly carried with us our textual and ritual traditions as we have moved from place to place throughout our history.

As we mark two harrowing years for the Jews, we will once again dance with the Torah next week, and we will look forward to casting light in the world when Hanukkah rolls around in December, and we will celebrate our freedom from Egyptian slavery during the spring holiday of Passover, and we will continue to yearn every day, as we have done since the Roman exile 2,000 years ago, to be able to celebrate next year in Jerusalem, the City of Peace.

Advertise with us

Now we are more wary and circumspect, and of course still mourning the victims of terrorism. Nonetheless, we hold onto our framework of tradition and pray for a better, safer future.

Seth Adelson is the Senior Rabbi and spiritual leader of Congregation Beth Shalom in Squirrel Hill and author of the substack  The Modern Rabbi. His previous article was “Justice you shall pursue.”