For months we issued a warning: do not hand the nation’s health to a person who treats evidence like an inconvenience, who lets ideology replace science, inside Health and Human Services (HHS).
America did, and the damage is now visible in our communities, in hospital wards, pediatric clinics and the living rooms of grieving families. The “Make America Healthy Again” (MAHA) agenda isn’t just unserious. It’s unsafe.
Unsound data
HHS oversees ten public-health agencies and three human-services divisions — an enormous portfolio with a $1.7 trillion budget in mandatory funding and $144.3 billion in discretionary funds.
Decisions there affect every town, large and small across America. HHS includes, for example, the Centers for Disease Control and National Institute for Health, whose objective scientific work protects and promotes American health in a way no other agency or any business could do.
Concentrating power in the hands of someone who has long sown doubt about vaccines and pushed conspiracy theories and unscientific claims weakened the structures that keep the data sound and policy honest.
For example, Kennedy’s “‘Make America Healthy Again” report cited over 500 sources. That seems impressive. “Those citations, though,” the news site NOTUS reported, “are rife with errors, from broken links to misstated conclusions. Seven of the cited sources don’t appear to exist at all.” NOTUS also found “serious issues” with the report’s interpretation of some of those studies.
When asked, HHS’s spokesperson claimed the problem was only “minor citation and formatting errors.” Formatting describes how you cite a source, not whether your source exists. Seventh graders know the difference, and so should the nation’s top health officials.
HHS also gagged the journals that publish the best science — like The Lancet and the New England Journal of Medicine — blindfolding the clinicians and researchers who rely on peer reviewed studies to guide patient care.
Kennedy undermined many Americans’ confidence in vaccines while refusing to mount a national vaccination campaign, and preventable diseases came roaring back. Measles outbreaks are now the worst in more than 30 years, with nearly 1500 confirmed cases, with 92% unvaccinated or with unknown status — and three deaths, including two children.
Meanwhile, whooping cough is surging while the Secretary has not uttered the word “pertussis,” and the CDC’s pertussis page sits months out of date.
Disinformation spreads like a virus, faster than corrections can catch up. Now, the consequences aren’t theoretical. They’re arriving at ER doors.
Harmful policies
The changes in policy and funding that follow from the disinformation are just as destructive. Cutting small, inexpensive programs will extract a devastating human price.
Funding for Safe to Sleep — a campaign that helped halve sudden unexpected infant deaths — was quietly pulled. CDC’s crowning prevention efforts at CDC were hollowed out until states lost access to the basic tools that protect toddlers around water, even though drowning remains the leading cause of death among U.S. children ages 1 to 4.
These two programs aren’t “nice to haves.” They saved small children’s lives at minimal cost. And they stand for many such programs the administration has pulled, underfunded or eliminated entirely. We will see the costs of that rising.
Kennedy scolded families about “ultra-processed foods” while backing the largest proposed cut to SNAP in history — nearly $300 billion over ten years. That guaranteed more food-insecure kids and, ironically, more reliance on the cheap calories of ultra-processed foods.
Nurses are the most trusted professionals in America, according to Gallup’s 2025 Honesty and Ethics poll. We know how medicine works and see the results every day.
But trust in our ethics hasn’t translated into the power to affect the public agenda or the media narrative. The megaphones that shape national conversation — political platforms, algorithmic feeds, and prime-time gatekeepers — often amplify the loudest and the angriest voices, not the most accurate.
So where do we go from here?
The path back
First, we need to stop pretending that the cost of these choices is abstract. Every time a life-saving program is gutted, there are names and faces behind the budget line, like the baby who doesn’t wake up because new parents never heard about the back-sleeping campaign because it was shuttered.
Second, we insist on a simple standard: if you make health policy, your claims must clear the bar of basic evidence. No phantom citations. No muzzling journals. No performative “wellness” proclamations while slashing food assistance and ignoring mounting outbreaks.
Third, we who remember what life was like before we were protected by so many vaccines must tell our own stories. Some of us remember the 1950s, hiding from viruses, avoiding playmates, staying home as measles and polio swept through schools. Today’s soaring statistics are frightening, because we know the results. Together, 67 million grandparents can turn memories into action and speak with one voice to protect the children we love.
The path back is still open: restore evidence to the center, rebuild the programs that save lives, and amplify trusted community voices so together we can replace the noise with truth. Do that, and we can make America healthy.
Donna A. Gaffney and Teri Mills are leaders in Nurses for America and members of Defend Public Health. Their previous article was “RFK Jr. is making Americans unhealthy again.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.