When in 1954 the chief counsel for the United States Army, Joseph Welch, asked Sen. Joe McCarthy, “Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last?”, decency mattered to Americans.

In his one man crusade to expose communists in the federal bureaucracy, the entertainment industry and the military, McCarthy had lied, slandered and bullied his way to national prominence.

I can only imagine what Donald Trump’s response would be if a critic asked him the same question. Here are three possibilities: “Decency is for weaklings,” “What has decency ever done for me?” and “I’m the most decent person in the world.”

As an 80 year old liberal white guy, I’m spilling my lattes over Trump’s reign of terror against decency.

Advertise with us

Bullying and harassment

He’s bullied judges, harassed reporters, threatened universities, censored museums, strong armed law firms and sent the national guard into cities on the false pretense that crime is rampant. He has openly admitted that he doesn’t mind being called a dictator if it it reduces crime.

His desire for revenge against anyone who has criticized, crossed, disobeyed, or ridiculed him is unlike any other previous president. He’s “not a fan,” a favorite phrase of his, of due process, the separation of powers and emoluments clauses in the constitution, and court orders barring him from the lawless deporting of immigrants.

Most Trump voters either like or are indifferent to Trump’s aversion to decency. Only about 25% of those who voted for him in 2024 regret their votes. I’m not sure why they don’t, so I asked a family member and two friends who support the president. It’s certainly not a scientific study, but it does tell us that for some of his supporters, decency doesn’t matter.

My friend Emma Jean is an evangelical Christian who voted for Trump three times. When I asked her about Trump, her reply was succinct: “A bad man can do good things if directed by the benevolence of Jesus.” She went on to add that “the lord works in mysterious ways” and put Trump in power so that “the lives of the unborn can be saved.”

Emma Jean voted for Trump solely on the issue of ending abortion. Since Roe v. Wade was overturned thanks to the votes of his three Supreme Court appointees, Trump validated her vote. Liberal complaints about him, like mine, didn’t interest her. “Just a bunch of noise.”

Advertise with us

Thad works for a firm in Houston tied to the oil and gas industry. He voted for Trump because he was friendlier to the industry that advances his ambitions than the Democrats. He doesn’t follow the news much. Watches very little television.

What he knows is that Trump is a big supporter of fossil fuels and getting rid of environmental regulations. His final words to me were “Jay, I didn’t vote for the man because I liked him. I voted for him because I thought he would be good for my wallet. So far so good. “

Catherine is a running buddy of mine. Knowing that she is a MAGA supporter has limited our conversations to matters pertaining to running shoes, training and races. I broke our silent agreement when I asked her if ICE’s use of excessive force in arresting illegals bothered her. Her answer was, “If they hadn’t entered the country illegally, they wouldn’t have to worry about how ICE treated them.”

Decent presidents

Decency was something voters expected from their presidents. Whatever their faults and limitations might have been, presidents Eisenhower (the first president I remember), Ford, Carter, Reagan, Bush 1, Bush 2, Obama and Biden were men of public decency.

None bragged about bullying people, lied so continually about their opponents and enjoyed the idea of taking revenge on them. None toyed with the idea of being a dictator or sneered at American institutions like due process and the separation of powers.

Advertise with us

The same applied to the two presidents, JFK and Clinton, who found it hard to link monogamy with marriage. Even Richard Nixon, the “Villain in Chief” before Trump, obeyed the Supreme Court’s order to release the Watergate tapes dooming his presidency and forcing his resignation.

Decency mattered during the McCarthy era, which is why his capacity for ruining innocent lives lasted only four years. The public in the 1950’s demanded decency from its leaders. That’s no longer the case.

A recent report by David D. Kilpatrick, a staff writer for the New Yorker, revealed that Trump has enriched himself to the tune of $3.4 billion during both his first and second terms. Emoluments clause anyone? Republicans didn’t bat an eye.

The quality Trump lacks

The quality most essential to decency, humility, is what the president lacks. The revered hymn, “Amazing Grace,” captures the essence of the Trump tragedy.

It begins, “Amazing grace! how sweet the sound that saved a wretch like me! I once was lost, but now am found. Was blind, but now I see.” Humble people, Christian and non-Christian (I am Jewish), know that we are all wretches, lost and blind, seeking salvation.

Advertise with us

We know we need to be decent people, who treat others well, not bullying, lying, threatening or seeking revenge on them. People who do their job faithfully, for others, by the rules and not for ourselves. One person who is clueless about this is, sadly, the president of the United States.

Jay Wissot is a columnist for the Vail Daily in Vail, Colorado, and frequent contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “If only Donald Trump had ever gotten into a fist fight.”