The murder of 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue on October 27, 2018, was the deadliest antisemitic attack in American history. To ensure such horror never happens again, survivors of the congregation partnered with Pittsburgh’s business community to launch the Eradicate Hate Global Summit.
Each year since, hundreds of policymakers, practitioners, and survivors of antisemitism, Islamophobia, and other forms of hate have gathered to share solutions. The summits have inspired hope that a global community of practice can make the world safer and more tolerant.
That hope is now at risk.
Unprecedented cuts
This year’s summit, starting Monday and running through Wednesday at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center, will take place as the Trump administration has made unprecedented cuts to targeted violence and terrorism prevention programs designed to stop extremist violence before it occurs. The administration has dismantled the infrastructure that supported them.
I know this firsthand. I worked in the State Department’s Office of Countering Violent Extremism since 2016, but in July my colleagues and I were abruptly dismissed during a hasty reorganization.
At the Department of Homeland Security, most prevention staff have been reassigned or fired, programs have been canceled, and leadership handed to an inexperienced political appointee. Nongovernmental organizations that once ran effective initiatives are now rolling them back for lack of federal partnership.
The retreat is not confined to the United States. In Europe, governments facing pressure to increase defense spending amid Russian aggression have scaled back resilience programs in Africa and the Middle East — initiatives that once helped reduce support for violent extremism in those regions.
Compounding the problem, the administration has spread misleading statements about the people and programs it dismantled — including the team now organizing Eradicate Hate. This is not just a misunderstanding of prevention work. It reflects an unwillingness to confront the role President Trump and members of his administration played in fueling extremist violence, most visibly on January 6.
The consequences are dangerous. By pardoning convicted insurrectionists and amplifying conspiracy theories about migrants and elections, Trump has emboldened extremists who believe they can act with impunity.
The Tree of Life shooter himself was driven by such rhetoric. He believed Jewish Americans were orchestrating “migrant caravans” — a baseless conspiracy amplified by Trump and other far-right voices.
That attack was the first in a wave of far-right violence: the murder of 51 Muslims in Christchurch, New Zealand in March 2019; the deadly shooting at the Chabad of Poway in April 2019; and the massacre of 19 people at a Walmart in El Paso in July 2019, among others.
Going backward
The first Trump administration was slow to acknowledge this threat and targeted those who pressed for action. I had developed programs to counter far-right extremism during the Obama administration and faced repeated pushback when I tried to revive them.
At one point, White House officials even contacted my bureau’s leadership about me personally. Only after the El Paso attack — under pressure from Congress — did the administration take modest steps, such as designating the Russian Imperial Movement a Specially Designated Terrorist Organization in 2020. Even then, officials avoided calling the threat what it was, settling instead on the sanitized term “racially or ethnically motivated terrorism.”
The current administration has gone even further backward. Many political appointees from Trump’s first term did not return — reportedly because they were not deemed loyal enough to his agenda. In their place are hyper-partisan loyalists who lack the experience to protect our national security. These decisions do not make Pittsburgh, or any American community, safer.
Seven years after Tree of Life, Pittsburgh continues to lead by example in uniting communities against hate. But without sustained federal commitment to prevention, summits like Eradicate Hate risk becoming reminders of what we once aspired to do, rather than building blocks for what we must achieve.
Michael Duffin was a senior advisor in the U.S. Department of State’s Bureau of Counterterrorism before his position was eliminated in July. In this role, he worked closely with the Eradicate Hate Global Summit and the Pittsburgh Mayor’s Office.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.