Helping the homeless means respecting their dignity, not putting them in jail. Pittsburgh is already proving this approach works.
This week, a year ago, nearly 150 tents lined our riverfronts and downtown. Today, you’ll see just a handful, usually only for a day or two. That’s an all-time low since we began a weekly count of tents and encampments. And it didn’t happen by threatening people with jail or treating them like criminals.
Working solutions
There’s no question that criminalizing homelessness only makes things worse. It costs the public money to incarcerate people, and when they leave jail, they’re still homeless. The rhetoric coming out of our nation’s capital — equating homelessness with crime, suggesting we can arrest our way out of the problem — is not only misleading, it’s dangerous. It also shifts the focus away from solutions that actually work.
Over the past two years, Allegheny County, the City of Pittsburgh, and our outreach partners worked together on encampment closures. Our outreach teams — people who have built relationships with people living outside and earned their trust — did the hard work of walking alongside them, making sure people knew where shelter and housing was available, making sure they understood an encampment would be closing, and making sure no one was caught by surprise.
Across those closures, outreach teams identified nearly 250 people staying there. More than 80% of these individuals worked with us to create tailored plans for their shelter or housing. The rest either relocated on their own or already had found a place. And no one was taken to jail as a condition of leaving the camp.
Respect and dignity
That is what respect and dignity look like in action. It means treating people as neighbors in need, not criminals. It means giving people choices and support to get back on their feet. It means making good on offers of a safe place to stay.
This required unprecedented teamwork. The County brought social services, the City managed public safety on public land, and those outreach teams from both the City and the County, as well as outside government partners, built the trust that made the difference. Together, we reduced large encampments to the lowest level on record, while keeping our focus on people, not punishment.
At the same time, we know our work is far from finished. Far too many people in Allegheny County (and across our nation) are still experiencing homelessness.
We aren’t declaring victory; instead, we are doubling down on working with partners to: (1) increase the supply deeply affordable housing; (2) invest in more supportive housing; and (3) fund a range of evidence-based treatment approaches that help people struggling with mental illness and addiction recover.
Solving problems
Pittsburghers should be proud. We have shown the rest of the country that it is possible to address homelessness without handcuffs. In Pittsburgh, we put in the work to solve hard problems with compassion.
We don’t throw people in jail to clear tents. We offer them help to get back on their feet.
Erin Dalton is the director of Allegheny County’s Department of Human Services. Her previous article was “Allegheny County serves those with serious mental illness.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.