Allegheny County’s Department of Human Services (DHS) is enacting vital reforms to our mental health housing system to serve more individuals with serious mental illness while protecting taxpayers from overspending on these services.

These improvements — recently examined in a three-part series in the Post-Gazette — are not easy, but they are necessary to better care for vulnerable people struggling with mental illness.

Major challenges

A major challenge we face today dates back to the deinstitutionalization movement initiated by the Community Mental Health Act of 1963. This act sought to shift mental health treatment from large, overcrowded, isolated facilities with an emphasis on containment over holistic care to community-based treatment.

Although this shift was both well-intentioned and necessary, federal and state governments did not sustain the level of investment required to advance psychiatric innovations, provide sufficient community-based treatment, or fund adequate supported housing. As a result, communities nationwide struggle to effectively serve individuals with serious mental illness.

Advertise with us

In Allegheny County, the reality is stark: instead of people getting mental health and other treatment delivered to them in community supported housing, many of our seriously mentally ill neighbors end up in homeless shelters, on the streets, or in jail. Meanwhile, the very system meant to support this population was serving too few people at an extremely high cost, and often excluding the most vulnerable people.

Our county’s mental health housing system, which includes, but is not limited to, Community Residential Rehabilitation (CRR) programs, provides housing for around 500 people at a total annual cost of over $40 million. That is over $80,000 per person, per year for housing alone — before the costs of treatment or client contributions.

That cost is untenable when more than 1,500 individuals in our community are eligible for this care and confront staggeringly high rates of hospitalization, homelessness, incarceration, and premature death. That’s why DHS decided the system needed to change.

No one will lose their housing

In approaching the proposed changes, DHS worked closely with providers on three thorough cost analyses. First, we asked providers for detailed cost breakdowns and found that only about half of the funding they received could be directly accounted for, raising concerns about excessive overhead or cross-subsidization.

Second, we compared these expenses to other DHS housing programs and saw significant disparities.

Advertise with us

Third, we built a client interaction model to assess service needs and resource allocation, confirming that a reduced per-person cost was fair and appropriate. Even with this adjustment, mental health housing programs remain the highest-funded housing initiatives within DHS.

DHS did not eliminate 24/7 support. Providers themselves chose to reduce overnight staffing under the new model. Recognizing the importance of round-the-clock care, DHS has established centralized 24/7 backup services so that individuals still have access to the support they need at any hour.

In its series about these changes, the Post-Gazette editorial board acknowledged that DHS is correct to prioritize the most vulnerable, ensure treatment follows the person rather than the housing, expand the availability of housing, and transition to a more recovery-oriented and outcomes-focused system.

However, DHS is disappointed that there was a failure to recognize that the way to achieve those desired outcomes involves paying an appropriate amount for housing services. We hope readers recognize that overhauling this system is part of a broader push to guarantee that no one in our community is forced to live on the streets or behind bars due to lack of treatment for their mental illness.

The recent editorials may have caused alarm among individuals in programs undergoing transitions. To those impacted, please know: you have not lost and will not lose your housing.

Advertise with us

Your treatment team has worked with you to ensure appropriate additional treatment services. You will also receive overnight support from DHS, as well as regular contact to make sure you have the treatment you need.

For those suffering from serious mental illness, or who worry about people with serious mental illness, at the end of this reform process we expect more timely access to supported housing and community-based treatment, and we strive for a system where nobody with serious mental illness is left to the street or behind bars for lack of care.

Fairer, more responsive care

This is the goal and it’s worth the hard work to transform the system. If you’re concerned or unsure of the plans made for you or your loved one, we encourage you to reach out to the Director’s Action Line at 800-862-6783.

Changing a decades-old model is daunting, but reforms are crucial to building a fairer, more responsive continuum of care. We appreciate the dedication and care of our providers in this effort, and we remain committed to working collaboratively to ensure that all vulnerable residents of Allegheny County receive the support they need and deserve.

Erin Dalton is the director of the City of Allegheny County’s Department of Human Services.