The Texas legislature’s unorthodox move to redraw its Congressional seats in an attempt to squeeze out more juice for Republicans in the 2026 elections – five years before their State Constitution allows them to do so — takes the country back to the bad-old-days of redistricting. If the Texas courts don’t step in to fix it, federal courts should intervene to protect the integrity of our federal elections.

Two landmark U.S. Supreme Court decisions during the 1960’s — Baker v. Carr and Reynolds v. Sims — addressed rampant redistricting abuses by states and declared them unconstitutional. Many states were intentionally ignoring their state constitutions that required them to redistrict every ten years, simply to gain political advantage.

This led to gross disparities in population among districts, as people shifted from rural to urban areas, diluting the votes of many citizens. The Court declared this practice unconstitutional, establishing the principle of one-person-one-vote.

Now, the Texas legislature is doing a reverse Baker v. Carr.

Advertise with us

Texas reverses the law

It’s willfully disregarding its own state constitution and improperly accelerating the redistricting process — five years before new federal census data comes out — in hopes of pulling some additional Congressional rabbits out of its hat.

Article 3, Section 28 of the Texas Constitution specifies that “The Legislature shall, at its first regular session after the publication of each United States decennial census, apportion the state into senatorial and representative districts.”

Texas’s fundamental charter specifically ties the reapportionment process to the federal decennial census every ten years, typical of most state constitutions. This in turn links to Article 1, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution, which provides for a new federal census every ten years. It does not permit the legislature or governor to redistrict at random times, based upon whim, caprice or political maneuvering.

There are rules in place. Spit-balling it isn’t okay.

It’s true that the U.S. Supreme Court in Rucho v. Common Cause (2019) held that partisan gerrymandering is generally a political question and beyond the reach of the federal courts. However, that does not mean states like Texas may disregard their own laws and Constitutions in doing so. That is still illegal. Not to mention cheating.

Advertise with us

California’s Constitution, Article 21, Section 2, similarly requires the process to follow the ten-year decennial cycle, in years ending in “1.” Thus, its redistricting commission isn’t slated to perform its job again until 2031, when fresh federal census data is available.

Likewise, in Indiana — the latest state where President Trump is pushing legislators to redistrict out-of-cycle to reap a political windfall. The Indiana Code is crystal clear: “Congressional districts shall be established by law at the first regular session of the general assembly convening immediately following the United States decennial census.”

Whether one likes to see redistricting food-fights sweep across the United States, the fact remains: These maneuvers violate state law.

Texas challenges the Constitution

Moreover, because these moves are designed to affect the results of federal Congressional elections in 2026, they raise serious questions under the U.S. Constitution as well.

The U.S. Supreme Court, in the landmark case of Bush v. Gore in 2000, rebuked the Florida Supreme Court and halted its recount of votes in the presidential election — leading to a George W. Bush victory — on the theory that states cannot arbitrarily change the rules of the game in matters involving the right to vote.

Advertise with us

The concerns are heightened in federal elections. As Chief Justice William Rehnquist stated in his concurrence, when state governmental officials act arbitrarily and ignore their own laws — particularly related to federal elections — they create potential violations of due process.

The federal census process is like counting ants on an anthill. People are constantly moving between and within states; the census is a snapshot at a certain point in time that provides accurate data for the states. Then the ants keep moving.

The Texas legislature redistricted, as required, after the 2020 census. Five years later, there’s no new data to make new reliable maps. The same is true in California and Indiana. The purpose of redistricting is to make districts as fair as possible, so that each citizen’s vote counts equally.

These mid-term maneuvers make a mockery of this purpose. They make districts worse — not better — because the changes are driven by overt political calculations, not reliable data that shore up the rights of voters.

Texas subverts the law

Playing political hardball to gain partisan advantage is not, per se, illegal. Yet disregarding and subverting one’s own laws and constitution goes beyond simple gerrymandering: It undermines the foundations of state and federal government.

Advertise with us

Courts in Texas, California, Indiana and around the country should stop their legislators and governors from playing this dangerous game. Federal courts, too, need to sharply scrutinize how such arbitrary actions affect the constitutional rights of all citizens to have fair rules employed to ensure their votes count equally.

Texas is trying to take the country back to the bad-old-days, and provoke other states to do the same. The courts need to step in and halt this arms race, which will only lead to mutually assured destruction.

Ken Gormley is president of Duquesne University, a constitutional scholar, and a former executive director of the Pennsylvania Legislative Reapportionment Commission. His previous article was “Let our judges be judges, and not servants of the politicians.”