WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump’s talk about Canada becoming the 51st state isn’t the first time the U.S. has cast covetous eye on its northern neighbor since it invaded during the War of 1812.
Less than a century ago, the forerunner of the Joint Chiefs of Staff drew up plans for an invasion, which were kept secret for 40 years until they were declassified in 1974. The plans were drafted during what later was known as the Great Depression, and they anticipated a future war between the U.S. and United Kingdom over trade.
When we thought of striking first
“The probable ultimate causes of war between Red [the United Kingdom] and Blue [the United States] have been previously estimated to arise out of Blue competition and interference with Red foreign trade,” the plans said.
The military forecast that of the fighting would take place in Canada, which would be used as a staging area for British troops to attack cities such as New York, Boston and Detroit, and cut off shipping to the Midwest by occupying the Great Lakes and Welland Canal.
But since it would take time for the U.K. to build up its forces in North America, the plans called for the U.S. to strike first, taking control of the St. Lawrence Seaway and capturing Montreal, Windsor and other key Canadian cities.
The plans were never put in operation. Indeed, 10 years after they were drafted, the U.S. and Canada set up a permanent joint board on defense.
Read More
Then came World War II, which reordered the world map and cemented ties among the U.S., Canada, and the democratic nations of Western Europe, including the United Kingdom. They formed the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, known as NATO, in 1949.
Meanwhile, the U.S. and Canada, both an ocean away from Europe, became more and more intertwined, especially economically.
“While some have argued that Canada should become part of the U.S., there hasn’t been enough recognition that, while remaining sovereign nations, we’ve spent over half a century integrating economically,” said Gaphel Kongtsa, director of international policy for the Canadian Chamber of Commerce.
The person arguing the most is Trump. During a face-to-face meeting with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney at the White House in May, Trump said he supported annexation but would not push the subject.
Now it’s Trump vs. Carney
“I still believe that, but it takes two to tango, right?” he said. “I do feel it’s much better for Canada, but we’re not going to be discussing that unless somebody wants to discuss it. ...But I think it would really be a wonderful marriage because it’s two places that get along very well. They like each other a lot.”
Carney rebuffed Trump’s entreaties. “Well, if I may, as you know, from real estate, there are some places that are never for sale,” he said. “We’re sitting in one right now. And having met with the owners of Canada over the course of the campaign last several months, it’s not for sale, won’t be for sale ever, but the opportunity is in the partnership and what we can build together.”
But Trump apparently still refuses to take no for an answer. “I love Canada,” he said in June in an interview on Fox News. “Frankly, Canada should be the 51st state, OK? It really should, because Canada relies entirely on the United States. We don’t rely on Canada.”
The president’s rhetoric has Canadian professor Thomas Homer-Dixon, an author and social scientist, saying he believed Trump will not be deterred from laying claim to his northern neighbor.
“Trump poses a mortal threat to Canada — not just economically, but I think territorially and physically,” Homer-Dixon, executive director of the Cascade Institute, a research center in Victoria, British Columbia, told the Canadian magazine Broadview. “I think there’s a real chance that military force could be used against Canada in the future. I don’t know what more he needs to say.”
Asked by the Post-Gazette this month if his views have changed, Homer-Dixon said they hadn’t.
Trump’s call to annex Canada isn’t sitting well with his northern neighbor. Nine in 10 Canadians said they didn’t want to join the U.S., according to a January poll of Canadians by the Angus Reid Institute, a public opinion research foundation based in Vancouver. Just 10% said they supported it.
And by 52% to 32%, Canadians said they believed Trump was serious about making Canada the 51st state.
A trade war western Pennsylvania could lose
While there’s no shooting war, there is a trade war. And that’s a big deal in Western Pennsylvania.
One-quarter of exports from Pittsburgh-based companies go to Canada, a greater percentage than 40 other states, according to the Business Data Lab at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce.
Trump this month imposed a 35% tariff on imports from Canada, up from 25%, but there are plenty of exceptions. The White House claimed Canada had “failed to cooperate in curbing the ongoing flood of fentanyl and other illicit drugs.”
Canada responded with its own tariffs on American-made goods.
Kongsta, of the Canadian chamber, said the two countries should be on the same side, not butting heads.
“North America has become the economic envy of the world because of our free trade zone that enables us to leverage each other’s strengths and produce world-class goods and services together,” Kongtsa said. “Instead of a trade war between neighbors and allies, we should be focused on strengthening North America’s global competitiveness. This disruption and uncertainty haven’t made any of us more prosperous.”
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. He writes every other Friday. His previous article was “Jewish Democrats want other Democrats to stop using extremist language.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.