The bell rings as the last few students find their seats and jockey for the remaining open power outlets at their feet. A student-issued Chromebook left uncharged isn’t worth much.
There are only a few weeks left to go in the last quarter for this group of 9th graders and only one major assignment left for them to complete – an essay. It’s an unseasonably warm afternoon and many students are dragging their feet at every turn towards the finish line of this, their final project.
“Do you care if we use ChatGPT to finish?” Kenyale finally calls out, exasperated.
An interesting place
She is a good student, I think she may just have a future in business, always with an eye towards efficiency. I swiftly redirect her to the rubric which clearly states that use of AI for this assignment is prohibited, surprised that she’d missed that.
“No,” she says, shaking her head. It was I who had missed something. “I know that we’re not allowed to but I’m asking you, do you really care?”
Earlier this month, the American Federation of Teachers announced a major partnership with Microsoft, OpenAI, and Anthropic, The National Academy for AI Instruction. This will be the first of its kind, offering free resources and training for K–12 educators across the country.
And so we have arrived at an interesting place, whereby one industry notorious for its rapid innovation and exponential, breakneck pace of development has now crossed paths with another industry that is known for its slow-moving and at times regressive tendencies.
Why are schools slow to change and adapt? The cause is multi-factorial, and a portion of the blame could be laid at the feet of teachers like me. For years, “21st century learning” has been something on the horizon for us to consider “tomorrow.”
Suddenly it seems as though tomorrow has come early. If post-secondary student success is to be prioritized, I cannot afford to be “too busy” or “overwhelmed” to learn a new skill in the AI domain. Beyond that, it is quite possible that such skills may even lighten my workload.
Embrace the challenge
It would be easy for me to dismiss or repel AI. I am a natural-born lover of language, I love to read. Growing up my favorite classes were always English and literature-based ones where I could express original ideas, discuss with peers, debate things, and write words that were all mine and of course, share them. I got into the classroom in pursuit of such joy, that flicker of a creative spark in my students.
But if I do dismiss or repel AI, I can do so only for so long, and at what cost? Teachers like myself must embrace the challenge that new AI tools offer. We must resist the instinct to reject what feels unnatural based on our own academic experiences and personal biases. We must take advantage and embrace that which may indeed be foreign, daunting or even frightening to us if we are to reinvent learning for the next generation.
This does not mean we forgo all traditional writing in favor of generative AI, but it might mean that we as teachers along with our students, must entertain the notion and grapple with the concept. We must think critically to decide if the occasion calls for the use of such capabilities and do so with vigilance.
In turn, developers in this space must tether initiatives directly to teacher input. Teachers and students will not be shy about voicing their wants and needs and so must be given a platform to advocate for pertinent, useful, and accessible AI implementation.
The capacity for efficiency as it pertains to differentiation for individual learners in the classroom is just one of myriad possibilities that were once unimaginable. Teachers can make an incredible impact with such tools if they are able to wield them with mastery.
But an AI tool in the classroom that is not shaped and defined by teachers and students might as well be a Chromebook left uncharged on a desk.
Ten minutes left
There’s ten minutes left in class and Kenyale has reluctantly made progress on her personal narrative essay, following the steps of Joseph’s Campbell’s “Hero’s Journey” per the prompt I’ve provided. I then tell the class that next week we’ll be doing peer edits using ChatGPT, much to their surprise.
“Why not just let us use it in the first place?” Kenyale asks.
“I’m most interested in what you have to say first,” I tell her. “After that, we’ll experiment with some feedback from AI after your first draft and see what we can learn from it together.”
Jon Bindley Herward is a founding staff member and Technology Integrationist at Environmental Charter High School in Pittsburgh. He is a 2024-25 Teach Plus Leading Edge Fellow.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.