A few days before the November 2024 election, I offered the readers of this newspaper ten reasons I thought the Republicans, especially Donald Trump, deserved their vote. Each was based on a campaign promise.

As I explained, I had been a strong Democrat — for example, I raised money for Bill Clinton and Jay Rockefeller — but became a registered Republican in my early 60s because the party had begun to drip with condescension toward the people of West Virginia and Western Pennsylvania. I grew up in Wheeling and lived in Pittsburgh for fifty years and did not like the good people I knew dismissed as a “basket of deplorables.”

My change on policy came later. I found that the Republicans expressed my policy preferences very well. I happily voted for Donald Trump and other Republicans.

Trump kept his promises

On the strength of these promises, Trump won both the popular vote and the electoral college. Has he kept those promises?

Advertise with us

1) Secure the southern border. Within weeks, Trump closed the border to illegal immigration and exposed Biden, Kamala Harris, Alejandro Mayorkas (Biden’s Secretary of Homeland Security) and others as inveterate liars committed to the cynical strategy of adding future Democrat voters through a wide-open border. Grade: A+.

2) Peace through strength. Trump is credited with heading off a war between India and Pakistan and for achieving peace between Rwanda and Congo. Chairman Kim in North Korea is quiet as a church mouse. China is struggling with Trump’s tariffs. Iran has been deprived of its nuclear future; Israel has received unequivocal support; and additional Abraham Accords are on the horizon. Russia invaded Ukraine twice, once on Obama’s watch and once on Biden’s. Trump successfully pressed to have NATO countries increase their defense expenditures and is attempting to mediate an end to the hostilities. Grade: A.

3) Constitution-based Supreme Court. With no new appointments, his grade must be based on his appointments from his first term — Justices Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Barrett. They haven’t always agreed with Trump but they have consistently refused to act as a super legislature and have grounded their decisions in the Constitution and applicable statutes. Grade: A.

4) Merit over identity. With the impetus created by the Supreme Court’s 2023 decisions in the Harvard and UNC cases, Trump signed Executive Orders to eliminate DEI in the federal government and is working to return the entire country to a merit-based approach to rewards. The effort remains a work in progress but so far so good. Grade: A.

Sex, spending and ideas

5) Ban biological males from female sports. One of Trump’s earliest Executive Orders sought to ban biological males from girls’ and women’s sports. His Administration has used funding leverage against educational institutions and is battling certain states, especially California, in court to honor the promise of Title IX for American girls and women. The effort remains a work in progress but, again, so far so good. Grade: A.

Advertise with us

6) Reduce government spending. The One Big Beautiful Bill includes spending cuts of about $1.6 Trillion over ten years, a dent in our debt-financed federal spending. Future additional cuts are promised but uncertain. Grade: C.

7) Deregulation. Soon after his inauguration, Trump signed an Executive Order requiring federal agencies to repeal ten existing regulations for every significant new regulation. The EPA and other federal departments and agencies have been forceful in the deregulation effort. The goal of unleashing the American economy seems well underway. Grade: A.

8) Address the ideological conformity in higher education. The Trump Administration is trying to expose and reduce the leftist litmus tests in higher education. It’s a bit like draining poisonous venom from a nest of vipers. One possible success is Harvard discussing creation of a center for conservative thought comparable to Stanford’s Hoover Institution. Grade: B.

9) Fight antisemitism. Trump has called to task the bastions of antisemitism in America starting with the Democrat Party and higher education icons like Harvard, Penn and Columbia. His support for Israel has been unwavering, and his willingness to use American military power to eliminate Iran as a nuclear threat has received universal acclaim in the Jewish state. Grade: A.

A growth economy

10) Create a growth economy. Inflation is largely eradicated; unemployment is low; real wages are up; the stock market is at or near record highs; gas at the pump is at a four-year low; and the Atlanta Federal Reserve Bank estimates that second quarter GDP rose by nearly 3%.

Advertise with us

With the 2017 Trump tax cuts now made permanent, along with additional tax incentives for businesses to grow; with tips, overtime and Social Security benefits shielded from taxation; with the regulatory state in retreat; and with tariffs driving investment into the U.S., expect the economy to be turbocharged into the future. Grade A.

If you object to the grades, fair enough. If you object to the promises themselves, you are rooting not only against Donald Trump but also against the United States. And that’s where we find the Democrat Party today.

Peter Kalis was, before his retirement, chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates. He writes every other Wednesday. His previous article was “Justice Barrett 1, Justice Jackson 0.”

He commends former Post-Gazette columnist Salena Zito’s new book, “Butler: The Untold Story of the Near Assassination of Donald Trump and the Fight for America’s Heartland,” calling it “a magnificent read.” An adapted excerpt appeared on Sunday as “Why Donald Trump went to Butler.”