I live in Pittsburgh. Like so many in this city, I was heartbroken by the 2018 Tree of Life Synagogue shooting. I remember the funerals, the vigils, and the way Pittsburgh stood still in sorrow.
Eleven Jewish lives were taken in a house of worship. The shooter’s hatred was pure evil — an antisemitic attack on faith, community, and humanity itself. That pain lives in our city’s bones, and I carry it with me.
At the same time, I support the rights and freedom of Palestinians. I understand why that might be confusing, even upsetting, to some — especially now, during such a volatile and painful time.
You may wonder how someone could speak out against antisemitism here while also criticizing the Israeli government or calling for a ceasefire in Gaza. That’s a fair question. But the answer, for me, is rooted in the same value system: a belief in justice, in human dignity, and in the refusal to accept that some lives are worth more than others.
Let me explain. There’s no doubt that there is a rise in antisemitism not just in this city but around the country. According to the ADL there was a 140% increase in antisemitic attacks in the United States in 2023.
Antisemitism is real. It’s growing. The Tree of Life massacre was a wake-up call that this hatred isn’t buried in the past — it’s here, it’s violent, and it threatens lives. And it must be opposed in every form, without hesitation.
But what’s also true is that hatred doesn’t operate in isolation. Robert Bowers was radicalized by white supremacist conspiracy theories that blamed Jews for immigration — specifically targeting HIAS, a Jewish group that supports refugees. He didn’t just hate Jews. He hated immigrants. He hated Muslims. He hated difference.
This worldview — this idea that some people are inherently threats, inherently less deserving — isn’t just found in Pittsburgh or on fringe websites. It’s found in global policies and power structures that devalue and destroy human life.
Raising voices
That’s why I support Palestinians. Not because I oppose Jews, but because I oppose systems that dehumanize anyone. Palestinians have lived under occupation for almost a century. Gaza, in particular, has been under siege for more than 17 years. Over 60,000 people have died in the current phase of this genocide, many of them women and children.
Families have been erased. Hospitals have been bombed. Food and water have been cut off. This isn’t just a geopolitical dispute. It’s a humanitarian nightmare.
And just as opposing antisemitism doesn’t mean hating non-Jews, standing with Palestinians doesn’t mean hating Jews. The world is not that simple. We are capable of holding more than one truth at a time. We can mourn a massacre in Pittsburgh and still raise our voices when we see mass suffering in Gaza.
Some of the strongest voices for Palestinian freedom are Jewish residents of Pittsburgh. Many of them were the same people lighting candles in Squirrel Hill in 2018. Because they know — as I do — that “Never Again” should be a promise to everyone, not just a few.
Pittsburgh is a city that knows how to come together. We did it after Tree of Life. We know how to hold each other through pain. We know how to show up with casseroles and candlelight and care.
Justice and love
I believe we can show up now, too — not by choosing sides, but by choosing values: life, safety, freedom, and dignity for everyone.
It’s not always easy to hold complexity, especially when emotions run high and the wounds are still fresh. But I believe we’re strong enough to do it. I believe we can oppose antisemitism and oppose apartheid. We can honor Jewish grief and Palestinian humanity. We can build bridges, not walls.
Justice isn’t a zero-sum game. And love — for your neighbors, your community, your fellow human beings—shouldn’t be either.
Dan Hackett is a Pittsburgh-based writer focused on U.S. foreign policy, media analysis, and international human rights and the host of the podcast “Catching Zs.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.