In a world in which professional athletes and sports reporters routinely opine on matters of constitutional law — usually arguing that courts should rein in the Trump Administration — it may be useful to harken back to an athlete who actually knew what he was talking about.

In 1978, as he interviewed an aspiring law clerk from West Virginia, the late Supreme Court Justice Byron White asked the young man whether he had noticed White’s rather crooked nose. How do you answer that question in a job interview?

The West Virginian’s test

The interview was apparently not Justice White’s most memorable encounter with a West Virginian. The justice said that when he played professional football there were no face masks and a Chicago Bears player from West Virginia named Joe Stydahar would tackle White by punching him in the face. He wanted to test White’s toughness and courage.

As a rookie playing for the Steelers (as they later were known) in 1938, White led the National Football League in both rushing and punting. Even a rugged Mountaineer like Stydahar had to be impressed.

Advertise with us

Byron White was a Depression era teenager in rural Colorado who blocked and thinned sugar beets for a dollar a day; a football All American at the University of Colorado, where he earned nine varsity letters across three sports and was valedictorian; a Rhodes Scholar at Oxford; a decorated World War II hero; the valedictorian at Yale Law School while simultaneously leading the NFL in rushing this time with the Detroit Lions; a Supreme Court law clerk; a distinguished private law practitioner in Denver; and Deputy Attorney General of the United States. All by the age of 44.

And then President John F. Kennedy nominated him to serve as a justice of the Supreme Court of the United States. The Senate unanimously confirmed him. His fellow Justices (most of whom were born in the 19th century) welcomed to their deliberations a young, modest and brilliant figure who was no slave to fashion, including the Warren Court’s judicial activism.

The day after he was confirmed on April 16, 1962, the Court heard arguments in Robinson v. California. The Court’s decision, which was handed down a couple of months later, invalidated a California law criminalizing drug addiction as violative of the Constitution’s prohibition of “cruel and unusual” punishments. Although new to the Court, Justice White dissented.

The state was not punishing the status of addiction, he wrote, but the repeated use of narcotics incident to addiction. He accused the majority of substituting its own policy views for the state’s on a subject — management of the epidemic of dangerous drug use — on which the Court had no expertise.

Miranda and Roe

Let’s jump forward to Miranda v. Arizona, decided in 1966. The majority held that the Constitution requires that suspects in police custody be advised of their right to remain silent and to be represented by an attorney during custodial interrogations.

Advertise with us

Justice White once again dissented by saying the new requirements were not supported by the history or language of the Constitution, which only prohibits coerced confessions, and would undermine the ability of authorities to gather evidence. Again, the Court substituted its own policy views for those of elected officials at different levels of government with direct responsibility for enforcement of criminal laws.

And now let’s move to 1973, when Roe v. Wade created a right to abortion. Justice White dissented by stating that the Court had simply invented a constitutional right for pregnant women with no support in the history or text of the Constitution.

By doing so, a 7 to 2 majority of the Court undermined the democratic process on the subject of abortion. Roe was “an exercise in raw judicial power,” he wrote in his dissent. It was overruled in 2022 in terms foreshadowed by White’s dissent.

The White opinions in Robinson, Miranda and Roe (among others) received a torrent of criticism among legal academics and the pundit class. Some seemingly sought to shame White into toeing the Court’s activist line. Someone might have mentioned to them that Justice White was not born with that crooked nose.

From time to time, the aspiring law clerk from West Virginia, who had the good fortune to spend a year in Justice White’s Supreme Court chambers, recalls his interview and his lessons learned that year.

Advertise with us

His mentor’s message was clear. Law is a contact sport. Be intellectually tough and principled. At the Supreme Court, it’s about hard work and devotion to the Constitution and laws of the United States, not the vacant platitudes of certain pundits and academics nor credentials collected in other endeavors.

Keep the courts in their lane

Most importantly, as was clear throughout Justice White’s entire 31 year career on the Court, it is imperative that we keep the Supreme Court and the subordinate courts in their own constitutional lane, even when they think they know better than the democratically elected branches of government.

The commentariat may be shocked, but that’s precisely the way it’s supposed to work in our constitutional republic.

Peter Kalis was, before his retirement, chairman and global managing partner of K&L Gates. He writes every other Wednesday. His previous article was “Bob Nutting, don't sell the team. Remember Roberto Clemente.”