Ensuring that essential services like water are safe, reliable, and affordable is crucial to building a city where families can thrive and businesses can grow. Before voters cast their ballot this primary election and decide the future of our water systems, we must keep an open mind and focus on what truly matters: our communities.
The third question on the ballot asks “Shall the Pittsburgh Home Rule Charter be amended and supplemented by adding a new Article 11: RIGHT TO PUBLIC OWNERSHIP OF POTABLE WATER SYSTEMS, WASTEWATER SYSTEM, AND STORM SEWER SYSTEMS, which restricts the lease and/or sale of the City's water and sewer system to private entities?”
A complex reality
We should consider all options to deliver dependable water services, rather than make a pre-emptive decision that leaves Pittsburgh with limited options on the best way to run Pittsburgh Water (formerly Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority, or PWSA).
Those who support limiting options like working with a private utility often cite rates as the core concern. In doing so, they oversimplify a more complex reality.
Across the U.S., regulated private water utilities invest over $5.5 billion annually in critical infrastructure upgrades. These investments help ensure water quality and long-term system reliability without waiting for a crisis.
In fact, studies show Pennsylvania’s privately managed water systems are over 37% less likely to have health violations under the Safe Drinking Water Act compared to public systems.
The public needs the private
We must focus on fostering conditions and the partnerships needed to support our businesses, enhance our regional competitiveness, and ensure our communities can thrive. Supporting the health and growth of Pittsburgh Water is the utmost importance as an essential service of our community. To support it, we must consider how to strengthen utility operations while improving affordability.
Cities like Baltimore, passed similar legislation limiting options like private regulated utilities. yet now rely extensively on private contractors to manage essential operations, spending upwards of $75 million to fill internal gaps. Additionally, Baltimore has, as early as this year, introduced a 15% increase in water rates.
The lesson: even publicly owned systems require private expertise. These solutions can take a wide range of forms, all of which would enhance efficiency and service delivery. Even within a public structure, Pittsburgh Water relies on private help.
Pittsburgh’s challenges
The challenges facing Pittsburgh’s water infrastructure demand flexibility and openness. We must consider how Pittsburgh continues to modernize its water system, attracts investment, and better serves our communities. Our opportunity today is to look toward the future.
What’s at stake is our ability to ensure options that value flexibility, performance, access, and growth. Let’s stay focused on how we can secure a future where residents enjoy safe, reliable, and affordable water — with all future options on the table today and for generations to come. Pittsburgh deserves nothing less.
Matt Smith is chief growth officer of the Allegheny Conference. Luke Bernstein is president and CEO of the PA Chamber of Business and Industry.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.