There’s a lot of disagreement on higher education these days, but almost everyone agrees, at least so far, in supporting Pell Grants — a financial aid program that is especially critical for first generation college students. It’s crucial to America’s future that it remain popular.
Reasonable people may disagree about how much, how, and when to disperse federal financial aid. The bottom line is that Pell works. Financial aid isn’t a handout. It is an investment — one that pays incredible dividends for all Americans, as higher education propels prosperity like nothing else in our economy, and the more people who can access that education, the better for the country.
Enabling entrepreneurs
How do Pell grants help propel prosperity? By enabling people who could not otherwise afford college, the program spreads opportunity across all classes and backgrounds. It encourages and enables inventors, entrepreneurs, scholars and others whose gifts and energy America wouldn’t have with the grants.
Grants like Pell are a big part of the reason the United States is number one in the world in both higher education and research. “Many Americans don’t realize just how exceptional the country’s university system actually is,” observed former Treasury Secretary and Wall Street wunderkind Robert Rubin.
“Although the United States can claim less than 5% of the world’s population,” he said, “it is home to 65% of the world’s 20 highest-ranked universities (and 28% of the world’s top-200 universities). Americans can get a quality education at thousands of academic institutions throughout the country.”
As to research, it is no accident that higher education is “among America’s most competitive international exporters.” The U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis found that, “In dollar terms, last year, the United States sold more educational services to the rest of the world than it sold in natural gas and coal combined.”
Lost in the tangle about tariffs and trade is the fact that higher education is an answer to, not a cause of, trade deficits. That is because of the quality of research that fuels not just exports, but innovations which lead to trillions of dollars to for profit industries who use those discoveries to make improvements in medicine, science and national defense.
A bipartisan program
Importantly, when Americans are so politically divided, the Pell program receives bipartisan support. Though it bears the name of a Democratic senator, Claiborne Pell, it came into existence with strong support from Republican President Richard Nixon and benefited in the floor debate from the leadership of Republican Senators like Jacob Javits.
Fortunately, so far the present administration has followed its Republican predecessors in supporting the program.
When he signed the executive order dismantling the Department of Education, Donald Trump underlined the importance of Pell Grants, saying they “will be fully preserved,” consistent with his first term expansion of the program. Similarly, during her confirmation hearing, Education Secretary Linda McMahon said she’d “like to see an expansion of Pell Grants.”
A large majority (81%) of Republicans in a recent poll support Pell Grants and don’t want to see them “in the crosshairs.”
Pell “appeals to both the left and the right,” the right leaning American Enterprise Institute explained. “For Democrats, it offers no-strings funds to low-income students. For Republicans, it funds students rather than colleges, providing a voucher that students can use at the accredited institution of their choice.”
Education for anyone
Because of programs like Pell, any American — not just the wealthy ones — can access a world class education. Vice President JD Vance funded his college education in part with federal financial aid, including the GI Bill.
I am a first generation college grad with not a single grandparent who had the chance at a high school diploma. All 11 of my siblings had the chance for higher ed, and federal financial aid helped me to graduate from the same law school as the vice president.
Thomas P. Foley is president of the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities of Pennsylvania (AICUP). His previous article was “What the state’s independent colleges and universities bring.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.