The violence Jesus of Nazareth experienced on Maundy Thursday and Good Friday, and our own governor Josh Shapiro experienced on the first night of Passover, overlap to an uncomfortable degree. Both men were embroiled in the political controversies of their day.

Both men and those closest to them had just finished their Passover feast, a meal organized to celebrate God’s redemption of Israel from Egyptian slavery. Both men were attacked in the late hours of the night by those who found their politics unacceptable, and both attacks used the occasion of the feast to make their move.

Faith and violence

I write as a Christian pastor, who has just led his parish in the celebration of Holy Week and Easter. One of the lessons of the events of that week is that for Christians to resent and wish ill against our Jewish neighbors, to express antisemitism in any way, aligns us with the very forces who crucified the God of Christian worship.

Jesus’s preaching called the political and religious elite of his day to higher standards of behavior and relativized their authority in light of spiritual realities. In doing so, he made enemies in very high places.

Advertise with us

According to reports, Mr. Shapiro was targeted by the political fixations of a mentally ill man whose life was in a state of collapse. While no religious motivations for the attack have been explicitly outlined, the Passover timing of the attack is impossible to overlook.

Jewish faith and culture are bedrock foundations for both men’s lives, and for both men, their faith was used against them for violence.

Antisemitism predates Christianity, and is often called the world’s oldest hatred. The Bible itself records an attempted Jewish pogrom in the Persian Empire, stayed only by the bravery of the Jewish queen Esther’s desperate plea to her Emperor Xerxes. The Seleucid Empire attempted to destroy Judaism in 167 B.C. by killing anyone who owned a copy of the Torah or circumcised a newborn.

There are at least three different instances in Roman history of Jews being expelled from the city of Rome. A Jewish friend of mine once wryly joked, “All Jewish holidays can be boiled down to the same story: ‘They tried to kill us. It didn’t work. Let’s party!’”

The Bible’s accounts of Jesus’s crucifixion show evidence of Roman antisemitism. Jesus was dressed in royal robes and beaten by Roman soldiers to humiliate the Jewish idea of a messiah. A sign was placed above his head on the cross reading “King of the Jews” in multiple languages, which elicited protest from Jewish religious leaders. Jesus was almost certainly crucified naked, displaying his circumcision for all to witness.

Advertise with us

Roman humiliation

Crucifixion was meant to terrify Rome’s conquered subjects into obedience, but these biblical details show that the Romans went the extra mile on Good Friday to specifically humiliate Jews.

Again, to wish harm to our Jewish neighbors is to side with the Romans against Jesus. We could point to Jesus’s famous prayer to forgive his murderers, or his life’s work of teaching about loving thy neighbor. We could point to the missionary convert Paul of Tarsus and his biblical epistle to the Romans, where he hopes with all his heart that his beloved Jewish people would come to see Jesus as their messiah.

The New Testament Christians frequently found themselves in conflict with the Jews in their communities. Never once did they respond with violence, but instead followed Jesus’s directive to turn the other cheek. Though the history of later Christendom includes horrifying acts of antisemitism, frequently written in the laws of the nations, it remains the case that antisemitism is anathema to Christian faith and practice. Those Christians re-enacted the Romans’ prejudice and cruelty, not Jesus’s love for others.

Antisemitism is not just unbiblical, but also un-American. Centuries of sectarian violence among Protestants, Catholics and Anabaptists led the founding fathers to imagine a government without an established religious tradition. They hoped that a government without an affiliated religion would be spared of the intense violence that had marked the British Isles and the rest of Europe.

A 1790 letter from George Washington to the leaders of a Rhode Island synagogue sheds light on this hope. In the letter, Washington takes the synagogue’s thriving worship as a sign that the American experiment of religious freedom was off to a strong start.

Advertise with us

Were he alive today, he would certainly be chuffed at the election of a Jewish governor, but troubled at what the arsonist’s assassination attempt meant for the health of the republic.

Praying against antisemitism

Had Mr. Shapiro died at the hands of this arsonist, his death would have left the stain of antisemitic sin on our state for all of recorded history, an example of Americans failing to live up to their values. We should be grateful he and his family were spared from disaster this week.

It is right that those who like me celebrate Easter, hail Jesus as king and love America should pray for an end to all political violence. Given the event in Harrisburg, and the ongoing threats against our Jewish neighbors, it is right that we should offer our prayers specifically against the lies and violence of antisemitism as well. Love for our Jewish neighbors, not violent resentment, is what will make us better Americans and better Christians alike.

Bryan Jarrell is a writer, father and the pastor of Epiphany Anglican Fellowship in Ligonier.