Today’s topic is economic self-harm. Future historians will have difficulty explaining why countries do things that damage their economies. That would seem the last thing any government would do, but many do, including our own at the moment.
Brexit is a good example from the recent past. After Britain withdrew from the European Union in 2020, its economy grew slower than that of any other major democracies. Th e nation saw less trade, less foreign and domestic investment, worker shortages in some sectors, and wages failed to keep up with inflation.
Why did Britain inflict such damage on itself? Racism, xenophobia, Russian encouragement, false estimates about the economic costs, or a reaction to the loss of sovereignty inherent in being part of the EU may have played a part.
Update on Rumeysa Ozturk
But before going on to America’s latest self-harming actions, here is a brief update on my last article that ran two weeks ago (link below). The Turkish student arrested in Massachusetts has been denied bond because she is supposedly “a flight risk and a danger to the community.”
Apparently whisking her away to a prison in Louisiana was designed to enable the government to find a judge gullible enough to buy its arguments.
Just how ridiculous and dishonest those arguments are was demonstrated by the Washington Post on Monday, when it reported “Days before masked Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents detained Tufts University student Rumeysa Ozturk to deport her, the State Department determined that the Trump administration had not produced any evidence showing that she engaged in antisemitic activities or made public statements supporting a terrorist organization, as the government has alleged.”
So, the government lied about her and continues to do so. Also, if the government’s objective is to deport her, how could her flight be a risk?
America’s economic self-harm
As for economic self-harm, why is America headed down the same path as Britain did five years ago, and at breakneck speed, thanks to Trump’s tariffs? The justification for the tariffs and the method by which they were calculated are as ridiculous as the charges against Ms. Ozturk.
The formula for calculating them includes some Greek letters to make it look scientific, but two of them cancel each other out. They will largely be paid by American consumers. According to the government’s own figures it will add about 10% to the price of every imported item.
And then there is the foreign policy effect. The purpose offered for the tariffs is to balance our trade, so we sell as much as we buy. Doing it on a country-by-country basis is senseless and so is the assertion that a trade deficit, which we have had for about the last 50 years, is some kind of national emergency.
There are 16 countries that we sell more to than we buy, so what is the justification — by the administration’s own reasoning — for subjecting them to a minimum 10% tariff? Four of them are in the Middle East and nine are in Latin America — not regions of the world that need more economic instability.
In addition, free trade agreements, where neither side imposes any tariffs, have been negotiated over several decades with different 20 countries, yet they apparently have now been abruptly cancelled without notice.
When Trump announced the “Liberation Day tariffs” on April 2nd, he claimed they would liberate the U.S. from being dependent on imported goods and do great things for the economy. The only thing it freed us from was rational economic policy and any thought abroad that American policy is predictable as the tariffs are on one day and off the next and their explanation varies from administration spokesperson to another.
Singapore had a free trade agreement and a negative trade balance with the United States, meaning we sold them more than we bought from them. Its Prime Minister gave an eloquent speech to his parliament about how he now feels about the reliability of this country, which is well worth watching on YouTube. In his first 100 days Trump has been able to convince every country abroad that America is no longer a reliable ally politically, economically or militarily.
Why then is America going to inflict far more economic damage on itself than Brexit bestowed on Britain? Here are three possible reasons.
Three reasons
First, Steve Bannon, Trump’s intellectual inspiration, once said “The real opposition is the media. And the way to deal with them is to flood the zone with (a four-letter word for excrement).” The tariffs are just one more in the flood of executive orders designed to throw out so many bad ideas that many of them get through.
Second, imposing tariffs serves Trump’s insatiable need to bolster his ego. He has bragged that countries are lining up to kiss his posterior (not his word) as they come to beg for changes to the tariffs. They will join the long line of corporate CEOs and major law firms also trying to protect themselves by offering him things and displaying their subservience.
Lastly, Trump believes the tariffs will generate revenue to make up for the tax dollars that will be lost by extending Trump’s first-term tax cuts for the rich. Trump has said the tariffs will provide two billion dollars a day, which is not true. To avoid exploding the deficit even more and because the tariffs collected won’t accomplish that, cuts to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid are on their way.
Extending the cuts will lower Elon Musk’s taxes, however. He will save $26 million for every billion dollars he makes. And given that he is only worth half a trillion dollars, who can help not feeling sorry for him?
Dennis Jett, former American ambassador to Mozambique and Peru, is a professor of international affairs at the Pennsylvania State University and the author of “American Ambassadors.” He writes for the Post-Gazette every other Friday. His previous article was “Our government's acting like the Russians'.”
“Trump has said the tariffs will provide two billion dollars a year” has been corrected to “Ttwo billion dollars a day.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.