Last week, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced the launch of an initiative to discover the cause of autism, claiming that “By September, we will know what has caused the autism epidemic and we'll be able to eliminate those exposures.”
But is this realistic? Decades of study suggest that autism has a complex, mostly genetic cause. It's not contagious, and it's not something people are exposed to. It's also not a condition that we should be aiming to eliminate.
Not an epidemic
This isn’t the first time this administration has drawn attention to autism. In the document “Establishing the President’s Make America Healthy Again Commission,” rising rates of autism and other conditions like ADHD were described as “a dire threat to the American people and our way of life.” The White House claims that autism spectrum disorder affects 1 in 36 children in the U.S., up from 1 to 4 out of 10,000 children in the 1980s.
This sure sounds like an epidemic, and people are understandably concerned. However, the reality is that autism spectrum disorder was not diagnosed at all in the 1980s. Autism was, but the diagnostic criteria were significantly more restrictive. Most children diagnosed with autism today would have received a different diagnosis forty years ago, if they were diagnosed at all.
I have three children with Autism Spectrum Disorder. The oldest is non-verbal and requires round-the-clock support. If we go to a restaurant, I can show him simplified pictures of foods on the menu and he can point to what he wants, but that’s the upper limit of his communication skills.
My middle child had delays in literacy when she was younger, but now reads above grade level. She has difficulty interacting with strangers, and is often unaware of basic social scripts.
Read More
On Halloween last year, she silently stood in front of doors waiting for candy. We assumed she was uncomfortable, but when her father reminded her to say “Trick or Treat,” she replied, “Oh. I forgot you are supposed to talk to the people.” At home, she talks regularly and easily. She does well in school and scores in the upper range on IQ tests.
My youngest also has literacy delays, but is catching up much like his sister did. He talks constantly, to everyone, but isn’t able to tell when a random stranger isn’t interested in a description of his latest Minecraft build. He has sensory sensitivities, gets easily overstimulated, and often needs support at school to regulate his nervous system. He loves chess and scores well in math, but he needs help in most other subjects.
My older child would have been diagnosed with autism fifty years ago, the younger two would not. People of my generation had the same symptoms, but were rarely identified and usually didn’t receive support.
No one understood
Those who had meltdowns in school because of overstimulation were either punished or expelled — they had “behavioural problems,” but nobody knew why and there wasn’t any help. Those who excelled intellectually were told to “try harder” and “apply your intelligence” to areas of struggle.
Teachers and parents were often at a loss to explain how a “smart” child could be oblivious to basic social cues or be unable to navigate simple, everyday situations. The assumption was that if a child was highly capable in one area, they should be able to extend that capability to other, unrelated domains.
Today we realize that cognitive traits like intelligence are not global: a person might be gifted in one area and have serious disabilities in another. Human brains are complex systems, and that strength in one area can’t always compensate for deficits in another. Expecting people with neurological conditions to reach their “potential” without support is like expecting that a Paralympian will stop needing their wheelchair if they just train hard enough.
We now think about autism as a spectrum because of evidence that similar underlying genetic and neurological causes contribute to the variety of symptoms and profiles we see in autistic individuals. There is overwhelming evidence to support genetic causation.
Parents of kids with autism often fall into the “broader autistic phenotype,” meaning that they have autistic traits even if they don’t meet diagnostic criteria. Autism runs in families.
There isn’t a single “autism gene,” but there are similarities in the brains of autistic people. Evidence suggests that autistic brains don’t undergo sufficient “synaptic pruning.” This means that damaged or unnecessary connections in the brain may not be eliminated, which may impede the efficiency of neurotransmission.
On the other hand, some people with autism have unique skills and talents as a result of the difference in how their brains are wired. There is evidence, for example, that autism may increase interest in STEM disciplines, and some employers have started to develop hiring practices to harness neglected autistic talent. Some people with autism have clear “savant” capabilities in specific tasks that far exceed the human normal.
Different brains, different abilities
It might be possible to help some people on the autism spectrum overcome the more disabling aspects of the condition, but if we were to eliminate autism it would also mean eliminating neurological diversity and potentially eliminating valuable skills and talents that enrich our communities.
Autistic brains are different, but these differences contribute to both disability and enhanced ability. Many autistic people need extra support in some areas while excelling in others.
Autism is a complex spectrum of conditions. It’s not an epidemic. The increase in diagnosed cases seems to be caused by changes in diagnostic criteria and in the availability of diagnostic specialists, rather than an actual increase in the number of people affected. It is highly heritable, and there is not good evidence that it is caused by environmental exposures.
Melinda Robinson is a graduate student in philosophy at Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, and author of the substack I Believe in Life After God.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.