In early March, Sen. Dave McCormick laid out a pathway to peace in Ukraine in an opinion piece in the Washington Examiner, “A Way Forward on Ukraine.” As a Ukrainian Catholic priest and as his constituent I want to thank him for his support and affirm that nobody wants peace more than the Ukrainian people.

Peace should always be the goal, so long as both parties to the hostilities are willing to deal in good faith. Unfortunately, Russia has proven over and over that it cannot be trusted to act in good faith, nor can it be trusted to abide by paper agreements it signs.

Security must be guaranteed

While Sen. McCormick makes a number of good points, he leaves open important areas of concern that must be considered so that any ceasefire is not an opportunity for Russia to regroup and rearm in a prelude to a bloodier and costlier eruption of violence against Ukraine in the future.

Real security guarantees matter! The senator alludes to security guarantees, but no concrete agreement has been reached either between Ukraine and the United States or between Ukraine and the European Union. It is imperative that such guarantees be in place, with a mechanism to effectuate them ahead of any potential ceasefire, and not after.

Advertise with us

Some, including members of the administration, may argue “Why don’t they [Ukraine] just sign the mineral rights deal and get on with it?” Here’s why:

Between 2014 and 2022, Ukraine held approximately 200 talks with Russia reaching 20 cease-fire agreements. Russia has violated every single ceasefire. In 2022, Putin used occupied lands in Ukraine (the Donbas and Crimea) as staging grounds for further pushes deeper into Ukraine. Notably, none of the previous ceasefire deals included explicit security guarantees for Ukraine.

Truth to power

If past is prologue, then an unsecured ceasefire will overwhelmingly benefit Russia, to the detriment of Ukraine. A pause in hostilities will give Russia time to regroup, rearm and re-engage, and to push the conflict deeper into free Ukraine as happened in 2022.

This was what President Zelensky was trying to convey in the Oval Office as best he could in English on February 28. Perhaps he showed insufficient gratitude and grace in the Oval Office. I would grant Sen. McCormick that, in hindsight, it was not prudent. However, he was speaking truth to power.

And power did not appreciate it.

Advertise with us

A U.S. economic interest alone in Ukraine is not a security guarantee. As a veteran of the Persian Gulf War, the senator understands that American economic interests in Kuwait were not sufficient to stop Saddam Hussein from invading that nation. What will America do if Russia does the same under such “guarantees”?

Even if Russia chose not to re-engage in an active war under a ceasefire agreement while Trump is president, what happens in 4, 8, or 12 years under a different administration? Ukrainians are well aware that the definition of “assurances” can change over time.

Critical to America

One need look only to the failure of the Budapest Memorandum and the fact that the Obama, Trump and Biden administrations all failed to uphold security guarantees promised by that document, throughout their tenures in office. Those failures have brought us to the full-scale invasion by Russia against Ukraine which continues today.

I agree with Sen. McCormick that “a peaceful Europe and global economic stability are critical to America’s long-term security and prosperity.” That is why it is absolutely critical that we get it right this time. The last 30 years of history have shown we haven’t always done that, and Ukrainians ultimately end up paying the price.

Alexander C. Wroblicky, a Pittsburgh-area priest of the Ukrainian Catholic Church, is  delegate leader for the American Coalition for Ukraine.